Fox Nation: Fair, Balanced, Biased, and Incredibly Gullible

If you read a story like this, what would you think?

“Famed global warming activist James Schneider and a journalist friend were both found frozen to death on Saturday, about 90 miles from South Pole Station, by the pilot of a ski plane practicing emergency evacuation procedures.

One friend of Prof. Schneider told ecoEnquirer that he had been planning a trip to an ice sheet to film the devastation brought on by global warming. His wife, Linda, said that she had heard him discussing the trip with his environmental activist friends, but she assumed that he was talking about the Greenland ice sheet, a much smaller ice sheet than Antarctica.

“He kept talking about when they ‘get down to chili’, and I thought they were talking about the order in which they would consume their food supplies”, Mrs. Schneider recounted. “I had no idea they were talking about Chile, the country from which you usually fly or sail in order to reach Antarctica.”

I would think, “This has got to be a gag.” Wouldn’t you? If I were a dyed-in-the-wool global warming skeptic, someone who was 100% convinced that the whole thing was an environmentalist/progressive scam to cripple American industry, however…no, I’d still think it was a gag. (The Chile bit is a dead giveaway.) But when someone on the Fox Nation staff saw this story—on a satire site!—he, she or it was so thrilled with its delicious irony that it got passed on , all the way to the website itself, where it was published as fact this week.

As Snopes.com, the  web’s hoax-checker, explains:

“…the original source for the story (which is linked from the FOX site) was a 2006 article from ecoEnquirer.com, a satirical site featuring spoof articles such as “Court Orders Fisherman to Apologize to Eagle” and “Penguins ‘Fed Up’ with Media Attention.” Additionally, the site’s disclaimer notes that all the content on the ecoEnquirer site is satirical, not real news: “All content on this site, being a mixture of parody, satire, and lame humor, is for entertainment purposes only. If any content is found to be offensive or objectionable in any way, please accept our apologies … but we also suggest that you get a life.”

The ethical issue here is not dishonesty. The ethics breaches are in the realm of competence and bias. Fox has been unusually vocal, to the point of sounding ignorant, in its scorn for any scientific claims about climate change, even modest ones. Many of its cable personalities, like Glenn Beck and Sean Hannity, go so far as to declare climate science an international conspiracy. This mindset preconditions Fox to believe the worst about any irregularity in the climate change advocates’ position, and the truth of any hilariously ironic story about a “global warmist” freezing to death.

In other words, bias makes Fox stupid, as it does us all. The difference is that this is supposed to be a professional news organization, not a Middle School journalism club. Fox is professionally obligated to be aware of its biases (they are also called “shortcomings,” “flaws” or “weaknesses”) and guard against them compromising the quality of its reporting.

Posting as true a fake news story with a link to a humor site shows such abysmal quality controls, lack of competence, miserable judgment and minimal respect for readers that the Obama administration’s attacks on Fox  as less than a legitimate news organization seem suddenly seem plausible, even reasonable. It just isn’t ethical journalism to run stories because you wish they were true.

3 Comments

Filed under Around the World, Journalism & Media, Popular Culture, The Internet

3 responses to “Fox Nation: Fair, Balanced, Biased, and Incredibly Gullible

  1. Jacob Hanson

    That last paragraph about Chile made it clear that it was satire.
    I only took a semester of journalism in high school, but I do remember something about having two independent sources….
    Fox should certainly be more careful, but from the little I have seen, they seem more concerned with their ratings and their base than with biases.
    Anyway, this has happened before. The Onion has fooled Bengali and Chinese news organizations (and possibly others) into printing Onion news as real news.

  2. The problem I have is that I tend to agree ideologically with most of what Fox has to offer. But I tire of the endless commentary and criticism of liberals. They are no more fair and balanced than CNN is in the other direction. Which is fine, but they should not promote themselves as such if the facts indicate otherwise. To do so damages their credibility and the credibility of the conservative message…

    Sheriff Ray
    http://www.PoliceDynamicsMedia.com

  3. Michael

    When I saw the story it looked fishy. I couldn’t find any prominent environmental scientist named James Schneider, but I DID find an artist named James Schneider who described himself as an environmental activist.

    From time to time, self-important people just seem to show up at one of the south pole bases unannounced for a documentary, etc and are outraged when people aren’t exactly glad to see them. I assumed this was another such incident, poorly planned.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s