A Psychic Ethics Train Wreck in Liberty County

Surprise: her anonymous tip is not credible.

I have been remiss in not discussing a recent Ethics Train Wreck that occurred two weeks ago, a fiasco that occurred in Liberty County, about an hour from Houston, Texas.

A self-professed psychic who calls herself Angel called police and told them that she had a vision that a mass grave containing the dismembered bodies of children was on the property where Joe and Gena Bankson lived. She also described some of the features of the property. That was enough for the Liberty County Sheriff’s Office, which armed itself with a search warrant and cadaver-sniffing dogs and converged on the home,  along with a mob of reporters and two news helicopters. As the police dug holes, somebody jumped the gun, and soon cable news stations flashed alerts that up to 30 bodies had been found.

There were no bodies.

There were no missing children. Authorities had talked a judge into issuing a warrant based on an anonymous tip from a woman who admitted that her information came in a vision. As a result, the privacy of a law-abiding couple was not only shattered, but they were momentarily identified around the world as alleged serial killers.

When you are challenged to prove how an individual’s ignorant, uninformed or naïve beliefs can be harmful to others, remember this story.  Liberty County officials still stand by their conduct, saying that when a serious allegation of a crime surfaces, they have an obligation to investigate. They say that nobody would have noticed the incident had not the rumor about bodies being found gone viral over the web. This is nothing less than frightening. There was no serious allegation; the vision of a psychic is not evidence of anything but imagination run wild. An anonymous tip based on a psychic revelation should not be the basis for the issuing of a search warrant—ever. Anyone who thinks it should be—police officer, prosecutor or judge—is by definition too gullible and incompetent to be entrusted with the power they hold.

It is astonishing how many cable shows deal with the supernatural and psychics as if they are real. It is almost noon on a Saturday, and I just flipped through the channels as a test: sure enough, there is a program about haunted American landmarks, and another featuring celebrities telling their real life ghost stories. Later, the SyFy channel will be running several “ghost hunter” reality shows. “Medium” and “Ghost Whisperer” episodes are on other channels. This stuff can be fun, but when people start believing it all, bad things happen. Scam artists move in for the kill; the unhinged start taking their delusions seriously.

Superstition and fantasy reign when education and common sense fail. In the past, this has led to witch hunts, hangings and persecutions. In Liberty County, it led to the violation of an innocent  couple’s Fourth Amendment guarantee against unreasonable searches.

Ignorance is never harmless, but when it is coupled with the police power, it is dangerous.

10 thoughts on “A Psychic Ethics Train Wreck in Liberty County

  1. I’m stunned a warrant was issued for a search. I can’t even imagine the thoughts going through the innocent couple’s mind. It must have been an absolute nightmare come true.

  2. I just wanted to say that when this happened, I first got a local news alert and read it online. Then I turned to the local new channel. Then CNN picked it up. They were all sitting there with bated breath watching an empty field with a slew of cops running around like chickens with their heads cut off.

    I admit. I was amused.

  3. Everyone screwed the pooch here. While you’re amazed that law enforcement is defending their actions, I’m not at all surprised. If you don’t admit to a fault these days, many people will not believe you messed up.

    Moreover, believing in supernatural phenomena is still celebrated in our culture. When I first starting posting here, we had some long back and forth over this issue, but it appears you’re coming over to my side:
    * “This stuff can be fun, but when people start believing it all, bad things happen.”
    * “Ignorance is never harmless”

      • Thanks for noticing my absense!

        I had a canadian vacation (no internet), followed by a horrible bug that made thinking about ethics too hard. In the extra week off, my project was saddled with even more work for our already ridiculous deadline, so I’ve been playing catch up, and haven’t had the free time I usually do. I should be back to normal in July.

  4. 1. AS a Native Texan, sadly, this doesn’t surprise me much.
    2. At least on Medium, to get a warrant, etc., they always had something besides the vision to go on, because they’d make sure someone was missing or get real world validation that something was up. Yes, she would talk a detective into checking it out, and calling it an ‘anonymous tip’ was often enough to start questioning someone. But the writers there worked better than actual criminal justice folks did in this case.

  5. For myself, I’m ashamed to say that this story bypassed me completely! Liberty County (which adjoins Houston’s Harris County) as long had a somewhat nutty reputation. But this! How did this sheriff get a warrant to search (and tear up!) someone’s property based on the vague musings of a self-styled psychic? And what does it take to qualify one as a psychic anyway? A license?? When occultism comes to be accepted anywhere as a legitmate means for invading someone’s property and exposing them to vile speculations, then we’re all in a lot of trouble. That family should have every reason in the world for suing both the county and the alleged soothsayer who brought this on them. One can only hope this sheriff will be likewise run out of the county on a rail!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.