New York City And The Mayor: Case Study In The Simpson Principle


The Simpson Principle does not refer to Homer but Alan, the now-retired Republican Wyoming Senator who once sat next to me at a press conference announcing the Reagan administration amnesty for illegal immigrants. Conservatives hated amnesty back then, too, and Simpson was regarded as a conservative. When I found myself seated next to him at lunch (my Foundation for the Chamber had done a study on immigration reform), I took the opportunity to quiz him on why he took the lead in this issue. (Those Chamber events were fun: another time, I ended up alone at a table with Gene McCarthy.)

Simpson said, as I remember it, “Well, ideology is great, but eventually you have to use real measures to solve real problems. If you keep flogging ideology when you know it won’t work, you’re a fool. It’s dumb, it’s irresponsible, and it’s wrong.”

You will note that 1) Simpson’s plan didn’t work either, though it wasn’t the plan’s fault, 2) Conservatives still oppose what they call amnesty, and yet haven’t a single rational, practical recommendation for how to handle the 13 million illegal immigrants who have slipped into the country since that Eighties luncheon chat, and 3) both liberals and conservatives have been meeting Simpson’s definition of fool lately.

[Aside: I ran into Simpson at LaGuardia last year, introduced myself and thanked him for that wisdom. He remembered me, amazingly, but didn’t remember that comment. “I said that?” he said. “Wow. I was smart that day. Thanks for reminding me of it. I wish I had run into you a few years ago.”]

One of the primary fools who is running amuck these days is Mayor Bill de Blasio, who is determined to again try the lassez faire, look the other way, “compassionate,” kinder, gentler law enforcement policies of his former boss, the infamous Mayor David Dinkins. In the 1980ss, Dinkins continued the transformation of  New York City into a declining, filthy, crime-riddled hell, and only the long, painful, much-criticized introduction of the so-called “broken window” theory into the city’s management by Rudy Giuliani turned the crisis and the city’s fate around.

As chronicled by Myron Magnet on one of my favorite blogs, City Journal, de Blasio is determined to relive the Dinkins experiment, because it would be nice if that way of running a big city works. Already, the completely predictable results are in evidence.

He writes:

[Mayor de Blasio’s] heavy anti-cop rhetoric, and the ongoing efforts of his city council allies to decriminalize quality-of-life offenses like fare-beating and public urination, threatens to sweep away many of the unskilled hospitality-industry jobs that the orderly New York of Mayors Rudy Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg nurtured. …Take a walk around the Grand Hyatt and neighboring Grand Central Terminal these days. It’s often like stepping out of H.G. Wells’s time machine straight back into the 1970s or 1980s. Vanderbilt Avenue, in particular, is becoming once again the urinal of the universe, with one block wall-to-wall “bum stands,” as my son, with childhood inventiveness, used to call them: the stolen supermarket shopping cart, the garbage bag full of scavenged cans and bottles for redemption, the prone figure wrapped mummy-like in a filthy blanket. The heart sinks. It took so much effort by so many people to clear up the human wreckage that so many years of liberal “compassion” had created in a dying New York. And to see it all—I can’t put it any better than the esteemed New York Post—“pissed away” by a mayor not smart or perceptive enough to have learned one thing from the experience of the last 20 years, since his own personal demons have left him stuck in the politics of the 1950s and 1960s, is tragic. It is so hard to build; so easy to destroy.

“Dumb and wrong,”

The Simpson Principle.

I hadn’t been aware of what de Blasio’s personal demons were until yet another City Journal post today. Cowabunga:

To call de Blasio a self-made man would be a charitable way of putting it. More accurately, he is a made-up man. Born Warren Wilhelm, Jr., he painfully watched his Loomis- and Yale-educated war-hero father decline into anger, depression, and drunkenness after he lost his federal budget-analyst job in the wake of a congressional probe into his and his wife’s left-wing politics. Sparked by ex-Communist Whittaker Chambers, who’d known the couple as fellow Time magazine staffers before the war, the investigation cleared both Wilhelms of being Communists but noted their “sympathetic interest in Communism,” which cost de Blasio’s father his security clearance, even though he had shown ample proof of patriotism by giving part of his leg for his country at the Battle of Okinawa, for which he won the Bronze Star. So, despite going on to prestigious posts as a Texaco economist and an Arthur D. Little management consultant, he couldn’t let go of the grievance of being a target of McCarthyism. He destroyed his marriage when his son was only seven, ultimately got fired, and put a bullet through his heart in 1979.

“I have a real respect, and a real anger and sadness at the same time,” said de Blasio, trying to describe his feelings about his father to the New York Times. “I don’t think I’ve ever been able to do the math on exactly what it all means.” So wounded was he by the triple abandonment of alcoholic stupor, divorce, and then suicide that he junked his father’s name and took his Smith-graduate mother’s maiden name. Returning as a Sandinista-booster from a Nicaraguan trip after NYU and then Columbia graduate school, de Blasio brought his angry radicalism with him when he joined the administration of Mayor David Dinkins, whose placidly feckless Leftism might have seemed tamer than his 33-year-old aide had hoped. But de Blasio found all the fire he wanted in diminutive fellow staffer Chirlane McCray, a black lesbian just as angrily radical.

In America, F. Scott Fitzgerald tells us, we are all free to become our own Platonic conceptions of ourselves (or at least to try), but one senses a messier, less self-assured process at work in the self-invention of de Blasio and McCray. Reader, she married him, despite her years of relationships with women, and she joined her racial grievance—nursed as the only black in a New England high school, and then at Wellesley, where she also felt she “didn’t belong”—to his political grievance as innocent collateral damage of a right-wing witch hunt. They became each other’s completing counterparts—“she’s my most important adviser and the person I’m closest to in the world,” de Blasio has said of McCray—and together they stoked a shared anger against injustices that belonged to an earlier, and largely vanished, America.

How can a responsible political party nominate someone like this? To some extent all leaders work out their inner demons in public life, but when voters see evidence of demons this virulent, they should run.


Sources: City Journal 1, 2


20 thoughts on “New York City And The Mayor: Case Study In The Simpson Principle

  1. At the risk of sounding a bit cynical, it is New York, after all. I have not seen since Detroit a city so determined to destroy itself. Choosing Giuliani as Mayor was, I believe, an anomaly. DeBlasio is more their norm, along with Boss Tweed…either incompetent or dishonest…or both. One of the definitions of insane, though a somewhat less rigorous one, is trying the same thing over and over, expecting different results every time.

  2. “How can a responsible political party nominate someone like this?”

    What do you mean? He is a prime contender for a future governor of New York and Dictator (in the White House – I don’t use that “P” word for that position anymore), or at least a Vice Dictator. He just might be the best Vice Roy to come along for Liz Warren or Gavin Newsom since Julian Castro.

  3. To be fair, I think some republicans would tolerate an amnesty as long as steps are actually taken to secure the border first. They’ve been burned before by promises to secure the border that didn’t materialize.

  4. We do not need law enforcement to be kinder or gentler. We need them to be feared by the general population.

    The only way to keep people safe is to terrorize them into submission. If we want a safer society, we need to adopt practices like arbitrary searches and arrests. Only the fear of force can get people to act civilized.

  5. “At the risk of sounding a bit cynical, it is New York, after all.”


    What’s the old Borscht Belt line, Charles? “Just because your cynical doesn’t mean you’re wrong?”

    I think NYC and its environs might as well be Denmark, of which I’ve heard it said “If adopting Sharia law were placed on the ballot, they’d vote in favor of it.”

    As I’ve said before, we have Commies as the mayor of NYC, the President of the US and Pope. I guess the Cold War wasn’t over when the Berlin Wall fell after all. We forgot about the insurgency that’s now succeeded. DeBlasio isn’t dumb, he’s just intent on destroying first NYC and then the rest of the country so he and his cadre can rebuild it the way they want it.

    Say what you will about Sen. McCarthy, no one’s ever denied the vast majority of his targets were Soviet agents or pretty heavy duty sympathizers at a time when the Soviet Union posed what is now called an “existential threat” to all us grade schoolers pointlessly being drilled on learning to “shelter” ourselves beneath our desks. Maybe our President can direct his Education Department to require federally funded universities to conduct bomb shelter drills on all college campuses now that our lovely Mullahs in the Margins are going to have an atomic bomb. Those silly “safe spaces” may come in handy after all. Oh wait, that might traumatize some students. Never mind. Sorry.

  6. It has been said that we get the government we deserve. Nowhere is that more true than in New York City, who elected de Blasio by giving him almost 75% of their votes.

    It seems to me that they prefer dystopian hell-holes throughout their city, much like they had during my first and only visit there in the early 1980’s. They should be happy that NYC is still better than Cairo, Egypt. They’ll always have that, it seems.

    Just think – the next sci-fi post-apocalyptic movie filmed there won’t even require a set or special effects. It’s a feature, not a bug!

  7. Btw, the GOP’s opposition candidate, Joe Lhota, was known best for being the top guy at the LIRR. My sister-in-law, a native of Suffolk County, said it best, after one too many delays on that railroad she’d vote for the devil himself over Lhota.

  8. “How can a responsible political party nominate someone like this?”

    I don’t understand what you mean. He is the PERFECT Democratic candidate. His father was a Communist sympathizer who was stained during the Red Scare. He married a radical lesbian. He actively supported a Communist dictatorship in Central America. He ticks off all the boxes for the Democratic Party. This is what the Democratic Party stands for. It is for racial, gender, and sexual identity politics above all else. They don’t care about defending the borders, getting roads and bridges built, or educating people. They only care about creating divisions, gaining power, and controlling others. It is hard to control people who don’t need you, so having a law-abiding society where people have jobs, money, and freedom is antithetical to the Democratic Party’s goals. Having helpless people dependent on the government for food and shelter, scared for their safety in a crime-ridden world where they are not allowed to defend themselves is their ultimate goal. Look at Detroit. Look at Chicago. These aren’t failures, they are successes! People like de Blasio and Obama WANT the country to be like that. It isn’t that they haven’t learned the lessons of the past. They have. De Blasio wants the Dinkins New York back.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.