A Contrarian Ethics Take On “Body-Shaming” Performers

I guess I’ve read too many articles like “Country Star Issues Blunt Response After Being Criticized for Her Appearance: ‘I’m Seething’” Not that I’ve read a lot of articles about country singer Lauren Alaina, yet another star in that genre introduced to the world by “American Idol”: I’ve never heard her, or of her. But I have been reading and hearing performers, particularly women, going into high dudgeon about fans, movie-goers, concert ticket-buyers and others who criticize them regarding their physical appearance, particularly their weight. Apparently Lauren’s furious because a lot of people criticized her weight based on a recent video of her performing. The singer wrote on Instagram in part,

“I’m literally so mad right now. I’m seething…We’ve got to change the way we’re talking about women on social media. We need to retire the obsession with women’s bodies. If you care about the music…talk about the music. If you don’t…. well, that’s fine too.
But this culture of speculating about women’s bodies?
It’s tired. Do better.”

Alana went on to emote about the phenomenon later. “A few weeks ago, I saw a TikTok of me up on stage singing, and all of the comments were about my weight,” she sobbed. “People were saying that my tour needed to be sponsored by Ozempic and just horrible things. It really affected me,” she said. “I am in recovery from an eating disorder that I’ve battled for a very long time. This just really upset me…I have an 8-month-old daughter, and we can’t talk about women this way. This is bull crap. If you’re a woman out there and people are commenting on your body, and saying this, myself included, we’ve gotta ignore that, and we all need to be better. This is crazy.”

“Well allow me to retort!” I say, in my best Samuel L. Jackson impression. (No, I’m not going to shoot her.)

2 thoughts on “A Contrarian Ethics Take On “Body-Shaming” Performers

  1. I’ve never heard of Alana, nor saw a performance. What you said about Elvis and other stars does it apply to Alana? Did she once have good looks and let herself go?

  2. You can get great or horrible food at a hole-in-the-wall restaurant, and great or horrible food at an opulent one. If you’re after good food, the food is what you hopefully focus on. If you’re after good singing, Fats Domino, Aretha Franklin, and Luciano Pavarotti, perhaps, but don’t put them all in on the same bandstand at the same time. And if you can’t simply avoid the performances that feature an overweight person, for some reason, and you feel the need to publicly shame them, although you don’t have my support, you can shame with the knowledge that a few good people have your back…

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.