Unethical Quote of the Month: Some Deranged Friend of a Friend on Facebook—And the Toxic Asshole Diagnosis Challenge!

This time, I was not able to wrestle my fingers to the floor. One of my usually nice, previously smart, woke lawyer and theater associates who is a relatively moderate TDS victim tried to write a sort-of reasonable response—I guess you would call it “restrained”—to the following rant by one of his friends, whom I fortunately do not know and would hide behind a bush if I saw coming. Not to be overly redundant, but I have to point out that she is the kind of toxic maniac conservatives, Republicans and irresponsible Americans have allowed to get a grip on the levers of power.

I don’t know the jerk but I told her (she’s a retired nurse who probably murdered her Republican patients) off in a comment anyway, because clearly all of her friends are as ethically inert as she is and she deserves the truth even if she wouldn’t recognize it if it came with instructions.

Before I post this thing (hold on to your head!), here are the rules of the Toxic Asshole Diagnosis Challenge.

I identified 26 separate unethical, dishonest or mind-meltingly stupid assertions in the post. I didn’t count standard partisan opinions that I may believe are wrong but are within rational bounds. I scored each with a Toxic Asshole number between 15 and 2 for a perfect score total of 219. Obviously the numbers are subjective and reflect my own personal level of nausea.

Purely stupid statements only get a couple of points. I’ll start you off with 10 free points: both times the screed resorts to calling anyone who disagrees with her “privileged” are scored a 5. The “privileged” tactic, which we’ve discussed extensively here in the past, is a cheap and dishonest tactic progressives use to disqualify anyone who disagrees with them without having to actually rebut the critic’s points.

Ready? Here we go:

On The Unethical Hegseth Impeachment Drive

[The full resolution can be read here.]

GOP Congressman Thomas Massie, a lame duck and evidently an unrepentant asshole, has been pushing for the impeachment of Secretary of War Pete Hegseth since September. This is from September 15:

The Congressman’s grandstanding is unethical in so many ways that it makes my teeth hurt. He knows that even if the impeachment effort is successful in the House, the chances of conviction are nil, so all he can accomplish at most is a colossal waste of time. In addition, it will only further degrade the Constitution’s safety valve on rogue officials, which the Democrats pretty much destroyed already by redefining impeachment as a partisan weapon rather than a bi-partisan, last resort means of removing an objectively corrupt or dangerously irresponsible government leader. Treating “following the policies of the elected President” as a high crime or misdemeanor is a dangerous precedent to pursue, and especially so now, when the Democratic Party has signaled that it finds the Constitution and democracy annoying impediments to its plans for permanent domination. But never mind: Massey really, really, really doesn’t like the Iran war, and as a mere representative, he doesn’t have the authority to stop it. His solution to this problem is throwing a tantrum and filing indefensible articles of impeachment.

As one pundit put it, “Donald Trump is Commander in Chief. Pete Hegseth didn’t sneak into the Pentagon one night, find the big red WAR button and start bombing Iran while Trump was asleep. He’s Trump’s Secretary of Defense, carrying out the military policy of the administration.” I have heard more than one progressive parrot use the Nuremberg excuse to justify punishing Hegseth for Trump’s policies. Since the very first war crimes trial (in the U.S., over the Andersonville prison), the dirty little not-so-secret has been that empowering subordinates to disobey the orders of their superiors based on judgments they are not empowered or qualified to make is a recipe for chaos and disaster.(cont.)

Ethics Dunce: Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang

“Ethics Dunce” understates the epic cretinism and stunning lack of responsibility on display here. This is a complete ethics alarm malfunction.

Jensen Huang, CEO of the tech giant Nvidia, has resigned under pressure and in disgrace after the company launched an investigation following news reports that Huang not only had an extramarital affair with one of the company’s clients who had been recruited by China’s top spy agency. Then another affair was reported, this one with an Nvidia executive whom he supervised.

Huang is one of the most important business leaders in the United States; Nvidia dominates the market for the chips used to train and run artificial intelligence. His departure caused Nvidia to dive in the stock market.

The arrogance and recklessness of leaders who do this—and so many of them do— constantly amazes me. They have responsibility to employees, families, investors, their families, and the economic health of their country.

I guess they took as gospel the Democratic Party’s rationalization for Bill Clinton’s conduct. Remember? “It’s just sex!” Also: “It’s private personal conduct with no relevance to how well he does his job!” Showing oneself to be unworthy of trust, capable of terrible judgment and unable to resist personal gratification that involves risk and betrayal are absolutely relevant. In fact, they are definitive.

Huang is supposed to be an innovative tech genius, but he couldn’t figure out the complexities of basic professional and personal ethics.

Defeated Members of Congress Actually Do This? And We Let Them Get Away With it?

Buried hundreds of words deep within an article in “The Athletic,” the New York Times’ online sports publication, about the looming failure of the Protect College Sports Act after the Democrat sweep, is this fascinating bit of information:

“Many lawmakers simply don’t return to Washington after being voted out. They lose their physical office space starting next week.”

What? WHAT???? They lose the election and blow off their last two months on the job? No elected member of Congress who does that should be allowed to hold elected office ever again. They should forfeit those two months of salary and their pensions. No one should hire them for any job; they should be shamed and shunned. Their names should be prominently displayed, published and circulated. In fact, this practice—how long has it been going on? Centuries?—should have been illegal, and a law should be passed imposing a hefty fine on any House member or Senator who engages in it.

My head started exploding when I read that passage 20 minutes ago, and it hasn’t stopped oozing brain matter like Mt. Vesuvius oozed lava yet.

The 2026 Mid-Terms Ethics Train Wreck is gathering steam…

Comment of the Day: “Scary Trump-Deranged/Wokified Facebook Friend Update”

I want to apologize to Gamereg, who authored this terse and astute Comment of the Day for getting it posted so tardily. Fortunately, the foolish (but disturbingly typical) sentiments he was generous enough to thoroughly rebut remain evergreen and ever destructive even though the election has come and gone.

Before I turn it over to Gamereg, I want to express particular disgust at the first line. There is nothing racist about the Republican Party, its elected officials or Donald Trump, and yet this claim—not even claim now but official Big Lie—remains a staple of progressive, Democrat, Trump Deranged cant despite my efforts and those of many others to demonstrate beyond dispute that it is untrue. When I confront the “Trump is a racist” chanters and insist that they tell me what they think is their smoking gun, their answers range from “Oh, everybody knows he’s a racist” to “He said mean things about Barack Obama/Kamala Harris/ Colin Kaepernick/”The Squad” to “He called the white supremacy protesters in Charlottesville “very fine people “to “he called nations with ‘people of color’ ‘shit-hole countries'” to “huminiahuminahumina.” The most substantive response anyone has come up with is the October 1973 DOJ civil rights lawsuit against Trump, his father Fred Trump, and their real estate company, Trump Management Inc., alleging systemic violations of the Fair Housing Act of 1968 in New York City. The Trumps settled the lawsuit in 1975 by signing a consent decree without admitting any wrongdoing or liability. The Justice Department’s evidence was strong; undeniably, the Trumps engaged in racial discrimination. Also undeniably, the episode is fifty years old. Fifty years ago Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama opposed gay marriage. I stipulate that when a public figure’s last racially discriminatory act was a half century ago, the “racist” label cannot be sustained.

I also want to respectfully challenge Extradimensional Cephalopod, our esteemed missionary of effective and civil discourse with immovable ideologues who have adopted an unshakable belief and are inclined to disrespect anyone who attempts to dislodge it regardless of the evidence offered. I would like to read a non-fantasy formula for convincing a progressive shill that the first first line is the utter bias and counter-factual smear that it is.

He/She/It has been especially smug of late with the now familiar “Oh, you poor dim Earthlings, if only you could learn the skills I bring you, the talking past each other that has resulted in such bitterness and enmity in our political disputes would be no more!” I am reacting particularly to our recent debate on this thread, which contained a reference to my post seeking the most ethical way to treat a neighbor who tells me she cuts off anyone who doesn’t sufficiently oppose Donald Trump and support the Democratic Party.

Update: I invited her to dine out with me for Thanksgiving, since my family is dead or will be elsewhere, and she is estranged from hers. She was thrilled. We will not talk politics.

Here is Gamereg’s Comment of the Day on the post, “Scary Trump-Deranged/Wokified Facebook Friend Update”…

***

Signature Significance and Res Ipsa Loquitur For An Ethics Dunce: Prof. Scott Galloway

Stay classy, you experts!

Scott Galloway, professor of marketing at the New York University Stern School of Business, former board of member of Eddie Bauer, The New York Times Company, Gateway Computer, Urban Outfitters, UC Berkeley’s Haas School of Business, and current a regent at the University of California, said in an interview that he once owned a Tesla, but sold it to express his disapproval of Elon Musk, first “taking a giant dump in the passenger seat.” Earlier, he has suggested that Musk be executed. Not only did he defecate in a car he was about to sell, but he isn’t even ashamed of it.

CNN’s token conservative Scott Jennings writes in reaction to Galloway’s revelation,

“So he sold a car to someone after placing his feces in the front seat and this is a very serious person that we need to take very seriously because of his very serious thoughts.”

Bingo. I wouldn’t hire someone who boasted about pooping a car to mow my lawn, and this jerk is sitting on a Board of Regents because he hates the right people.

I told you that I would be posting this a lot, and here it comes again:

Take note, you conservatives and Republicans who let the “Blue Wave” swamp the nation, for these are the execrable people you allowed to get power over your lives because you wanted to throw a tantrum about inflation.

Disgusting (But Not Atypical) Leftist Hate-Mongers Issue A Rare Level #11 Apology (“The Impossible Apology”)

Not accepted.

Progressive podcasters Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan laughed uproariously at an joke about digging up the body of assassinated conservative activist Charlie Kirk in order to kill him again.

The vile hosts of the “I’ve Had It” podcast read an X post stating, “We’re digging up Charlie Kirk and doing it again” on the air following Democrats winning majorities in the House and Senate in the midterm elections. They thought it was so hilarious—and assumed their sick listeners would as well—that they engaged in unrestrained hilarity at the idea of desecrating the body of a murder victim whose sole “crime” was opposing radical leftist cant. They chose—poorly. So far five sponsors of the podcast have pulled their advertising, with Cash App., which had one of their ads read right before Welch and Sullivan’s self-reveal as hateful ghouls stating curtly:

Family Ethics: Apparently “The Ethicist” Has Decided To Only Answer Stupid Questions From Now On…

This is the latest question from an ethics-challenged boob that “The Ethicist” (the New York Times Magazine’s ethics advice columnist, Kwame Anthony Appiah) thinks is worthy of discussion and publication:

“Can I Have an A.I. Chatbot Field My Mother’s Endless Complaints?” “Would using a chatbot as an emotional buffer be compassionate, or would we be failing in our filial duty by substituting an algorithm for a child’s attention?”—Name Withheld

Wow. No wonder you withheld your name from being attached to that disgusting suggestion, Whoever You Are. If you didn’t, everyone with an ethical brain cell left would know you’re a heartless asshole.

The answer is “No!” Sure, you can do it, just as you can set the neighbor’s dog on fire. But it’s obviously unethical, wrong, unforgivable, and a terrible idea. Of course it is. Gee, would it be all right to substitute a bot for actual parenting when your child is upset? Oooh, tough one! Would it be ethical to have chatbot in the confession booth while the priest takes a nap?

I wrote this before bothering to read what good ol’ Kwame wrote. Let’s see…

Ugh. “The Ethicist” actually thinks this abdication of family duty might be justifiable! He writes,

“The fact that a chatbot is no substitute for human companionship doesn’t mean it can’t play a useful role when other people aren’t available. You owe your mother attention and companionship, but not in unlimited quantities. It’s relevant that you and your brother are feeling exhausted by emotional demands that exceed what you can reasonably supply. If your mother would feel better having an A.I. chat partner, that counts as a reason to provide one.”

The last sentence is a despicable cheat. “If your mother would feel like she was getting exactly the same amount of attention and loving concern from a machine that she obviously needs from her children, then why not?” That’s a self-ratifying proposition. It would be just as valid if you substituted “trained snail” or “inanimate carbon rod” for “machine.”

If my parents , or my wife or my sister, or my son felt the need to talk to me, and especially me, for any reason important to them, I would be there for them, and they knew it. There was no limit. There would never be a limit. The same is true of any friend. (My clients, on the other hand, pay for the privilege) If I were running short of time due to other commitments, I would say so with apologies, but promise to be available as soon as possible. What I would never say is, “Hey, here’s a bot you can talk to. Good luck!”

You can read the whole exchange here. If I were you, I’d use my time more judiciously.

Ethics Quiz: The Sentimental Cheer-Off

This is an “Awww!” story that rings some ethics alarms. Heartwarming but stupid. Kindness and courage marred by toxic empathy and a rejection of merit for “feelz.” I’m interested in where you come out on the The Sentimental Cheer-Off Affair.

14-year-old Jorgia Walls from Lawrenceville, Georgia, an eighth-grader, found herself the only remaining member of her cheerleading team for the Peachtree Ridge Youth Athletic Association. It was an eight-girl squad in early summer but had dwindled to just Jorgia by September. Ethics Alarm #1: That’s a teeny bit suspicious, don’t you think? It sounds like mutant of two Kirsten Dunst movies, “Drop Dead Gorgeous” and “Bring It On.” The AOL story casually says the strange exodus resulted from “the summer heat in Georgia” and “family factors.” Seven cheerleaders quitting the same squad? What a coinkydink…

Walls refused the options of joining the seventh-grade team or quitting the eighth grade squad herself, but instead decided (with the complicity of the cheerleading squad’s coach) to keep cheering on the eighth-grade football team all by herself. THIS reminds me of a memorable Monty Python segment where space aliens (who look like giant puddings) turn all of Earth’s tennis players into non-playing Scotsmen so the aliens can win Wimbledon. The sole un-transformed human tennis pro has to play himself by running around to both sides of the net. A single cheerleader is almost as silly but not as funny. (cont.)

Culture, Not Race

I ran across two essays just as I was prepping for a rare, in-person live seminar for young lawyers focusing on basic non-legal, life-competence skills essential to the effective and professional practice of law. One of those is understanding the importance and the power of culture. We all have a responsibility to care for the various cultures we swim in: a bad culture will corrupt us; a good culture will ennoble us and make us more successful and virtuous. If you can’t change a culture, you have to get out. The upcoming election is about, about, other things, what kind of culture our nation will have. People who don’t understand culture (or who don’t make the necessary effort to know what their culture is, like Malcolm Gladwell in his recent book) create problems for everyone, especially themselves.

That infuriating video above prompted a racist substacker named Max Remington (maybe) who describes himself as an “America First, isolationist, unilateralist, shameless nationalist, and post-Christian radical right-winger” to post this long essay. It’s lucid, more-or-less well-written, and provocative, but also displays the logical and ethical fallacies typically embraced by racists who are made stupid by their bias. I know them well: my ex-Marine law school room mate was a racist (and anti-Semite) much like this guy. My room mate got himself killed, but I have another racist friend with similar views, and most of my Greek-American relatives on my mother’s side were racists, including Mom.

In response, another substacker who goes by Sensurround Q Catgirl (or maybe that’s her real name) wrote this essay. Its main theme is that Max “provides absolutely ZERO evidence that race is the cause of the behaviors he’s describing.” “He provides statistics,” Catgirl continues. “He describes experiences. He identifies behaviors he finds objectionable, but then he makes an enormous logical leap from observing behavior to attributing that behavior to race.”

She’s right, Max is wrong

Watch the video, and read the essays.

I’ve got to get ready for my seminar…