Reflections on a Day That Changed Everything

Last year, once again pondering the date in history that most Americans of my generation look back on as The Day We Remember Where We Were the way more recent generations think of 9/11/2001, I wrote in part,

“Today I barely saw a mention of Kennedy’s assassination, and, frankly, I very much doubt that anyone who didn’t experience the national reaction to the events of November 22, 1963 and its aftermath could comprehend what it felt like to be an American jerked violently out of the sedate 1950s into the turmoil, anger, fear and upheaval of the mad 1960s.

“November 22, 1963 was the catalyst for that cultural shift, and we will never know what was lost or gained. All we can know is that all of our fates, and the fates of everyone who follows us, was altered forever.

“I have always looked back on November 22 as a cursed day. Tomorrow is my wedding anniversary, now another sad day, but I changed our wedding date from the 22nd, when it was originally scheduled, because I could not conceive of being completely happy on the day John F. Kennedy, so young, inspiring and full of hope, died

“And you know, I sometimes think that this country has never been as happy and optimistic as it was before Lee Harvey Oswald fired his rifle from that warehouse. I wonder if it will ever be again.”

Well, the past year certainly has not provided a hopeful answer to that query, has it? That thought pointed me to another November 22 Ethics Alarms post, that one from 2013. I think it is especially relevant today, so I am reposting it.

Grassy Knoll Ethics: How Deception Breeds Distrust

Continue reading →

“Oopsie!” Incompetent School District of the Decade: Albemarle County (VA.)Public Schools

Unfortunately, I can’t find a public schools system song that would be the equivalent of the EA favorite from “Li’l Abner,” “The Country’s in the Very Best of Hands.” If there was one, I would surely use it today.

Albemarle County Public Schools, which operates 29 schools and special facilities, is being shut down through Thanksgiving. It seems that hundreds of staff members were not screened to see if there were past complaints of child abuse or neglect against them.

Oopsie! Well, anyone can make a mistake…

The district, headquartered in Charlottesville, Virginia, has more than 14,000 students and over 2,800 staff, many of which may be lying in wait to molest them, as far as school administrators know. Acting Superintendent Chandra Hayes said last week that it had been discovered that more than 500 new hires in the district had undergone criminal background checks but for some reason (Pssst! Poor oversight and gross incompetence and negligence!) were not checked against the Child Protective Services Central Registry maintained by the Virginia Department of Social Services. “We investigated the matter and took immediate action,” Hayes said.

Immediate action…years late.

“The personnel responsible for submissions to Child Protective Services did not consistently follow established processes,” she added. Ya think???

More on “List Incompetence Again: Variety’s ‘100 Greatest Movie Stars’”: Seeking Integrity and Legitimacy [Expanded]

Is this an ethics issue? Sure it is, at least to me and Ethics Alarms. Quite apart from the basic ethics breaches of competence, diligence, integrity, responsibility and fairness engaged in by Variety’s hacks to produce this careless mess, the botched exercise distorts history, damages the legacies and reputations of artists who have earned the right to be honored and remembered, and perhaps worst of all, makes recent generations more ignorant while withholding information that could lead them to life-altering cultural discoveries and experiences.

Again, I do not have the time to thoroughly repair the horrible job the Variety Five did on the list, but I do feel compelled to clarify and enlighten regarding the process and how it should have proceeded.

Standards

Ethics Quote of the Month: Andrew Sullivan

I haven’t visited Andrew for a while. As always, he writes beautifully and is often bother perceptive and bold. Too bad he decided that being gay and loyal to his tribe took precedence over his values, which are consistently conservative. Oh well.

Andrew’s ethics quote is from his recent substack in which he properly calls out Bill Kristol (above) and, by extension, The Bulwark, the Lincoln Project, George Will and all of the alleged conservatives and Republicans who decided that they would rather discard their long-espoused core values and embrace the adverse because they couldn’t bear having to support that icky Donald Trump.

Of course, Ethics Alarms has been pointing this out for a decade (See, for example, this essay from 2018, which concluded with the Kristol diagnosis: “What an ass.”) but Andrew has more readers than I, so attention must be paid. He writes in part,

The NFL Reminds Us That It Is The Most Unethical Organization In Sports [Corrected]

True, its latest disgusting move seems relatively trivial for a league that makes America complicit in the a blood sport that leaves young men facing a future with brain damage leading to an early death. Nevertheless, it is signature significance: this is an unethical organization run by hypocritical, unethical people.

And trashing the principle of free speech isn’t trivial anyway.

Baltimore Ravens cornerback Marlon Humphrey has a podcast(Doesn’t everybody?) called “The Marlon Humphrey Show.” He was asked what Baltimore made best. The host’s first two answers were the National Anthem and National Bohemian beer, the local brew. He then quipped that the city is also “best at making criminals.” So his team suspended him, even though Humphrey is a four-time Pro Bowl performer, a two-time All-Pro and easily one of the top cornerbacks in team history, while the Ravens have a crucial game this weekend as the team tries to end a five-game losing streak.

He was also speaking the truth, or close enough for a wry observation. Baltimore is one of the most dangerous cities in the United States, among the top five cities for violent crime. In population, it ranks 31st, and that makes it the least populated metropolitan area among that elite group. The day Humphrey was suspended, a 30-year-old woman was shot and killed near the M&T Bank Stadium.

“When you say something like that, it’s not a reflection of our team and our organization and how we want to operate,” Ravens coach Jesse Minter said in a news conference, adding that the organization’s brass decided to discipline Humphrey after extensive conversations. I’m not even sure what Minter meant to say. Humphrey wasn’t speaking on behalf of the team. He wasn’t even issuing a political opinion. He made an unplanned quip that just acknowledged what is in the Baltimore news every day.

I wonder what the Ravens would have done if he said that Charlie Kirk deserved to be shot. My guess? Nothing at all. (cont.)

Regarding Trump’s Stupid and Unethical Pete Rose Pardon

Short version: “Not a surprise, unethical, stupid, typical and ominous.”

The first ethics post I ever made online was about Pete Rose, on the old “Ethics Scoreboard,” now in the Land of Lost Websites. [Pete’s EA dossier is here] It is not reasonably debatable that he was a great baseball player on the field, had a remarkable career, and as a human being was what is known colloquially as “shameless scumbag.” There is no controversy over that assessment. He went to prison for tax evasion. He cheated on his wife. He broke baseball’s most well-publicized rule by gambling on MLB games as a manager, and lied for years by insisting that he never bet on his own team. He embarrassed and degraded the sport in many ways one he retired, because Pete had no dignity or class, and would do anything for money, which he always needed because he was not only a gambling addict, but an incompetent one.

Rose was banned from baseball for life as he should have been under the same long-standing rule that banned Shoeless Joe Jackson, another great player with the brain of a gerbil and the ethical instincts of Harry Reid. Rose’s defenders, like the President, keep pointing to Rose’s on-field achievements, which are irrelevant. Actually no, they make his offenses worse. Because the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown was required by its bylaws not to present for election any player who was banned by the game, the shrine could not include the game’s career hits record-holder. (Then another scumbag, Barry Bonds, came along and made the Hall voters exclude the game’s all-time home run leader as well, though for a different offense.) The Hall of Fame has a character requirement, separating baseball from the other sports Halls to its lasting credit and benefit to our culture. The principle is simple and pure: embarrass and harm baseball, its legacy, its image and its status, and a player will not, must not, be honored at Cooperstown. That was Pete Rose, beyond question.

Now on to President Trump’s pardon. I know I use “stupid” a lot, and I wish I didn’t have to write about so many stupid statements, people, situations and decisions, but if there’s a more accurate description of Trump’s post above other than unethical, which is obvious, please tell me:

Serious Question: How Does Anyone Get This Way?

At a Sacramento city council meeting, the woman above launched into a furious verbal attack on the Sacramento’s Democratic Mayor Kevin McCarty. Before her microphone was cut off, she said, among other things,

“If you do not vote in our interest again, you will regret it. We protest. We stop things. We shut things down, Kevin. And careers….So it’s time for your fucking career to end. Maybe retirement, maybe nothing after this. Fuck your decorum!..Do you want everyone to know your address? Because now I know your address. A little birdie fucking told me….I do not give a fuck about your decorum. I do not give a fuck about your privacy!”

She had done this before, but the city council still gave her a forum. Whereupon she promptly abused it. You see, she doesn’t comprehend the democratic process thingy. That doesn’t include “if you don’t do what I want, I’ll hurt you.” But this is the party a majority of voting Americans put in power two weeks ago.

Oh! I forgot to mention what she was—is–so furious about. Like other pro-open borders, anti-ICE activists who have disrupted such meetings, she is outraged that Sacramento, a so-called “sanctuary city,” is cooperating with federal authorities too much as ICE tries to undo the damage done by the Biden administration over four years of refusing to enforce immigration laws.

One conservative commenter writes, “I have absolutely no sympathy for the Sacramento City Council. They have ushered this behavior in. They have pandered to these crazy, delusional people. And now, these same people are turning on them. There is no kindness. There is no loyalty.” Indeed, this is a microcosm of the entire Democratic Party and the Axis of Unethical Conduct, an epitome of the parable about the man riding the tiger. The same pundit writes, “Some of them are teaching our kids.” Don’t kid yourself, Love. LOTS of them are teaching our kids.

That’s part of the answer to my question in the headline. Even the anti-Vietnam War protesters didn’t act like this, and at least they had a colorable moral-ethical argument, unlike these lunatics. Normal, regular, trusting, apathetic Americans let a corrosive, violent, un-democratic culture take root in the schools and universities, and are paying the price. That’s the face of the party the Democrats are becoming. Good job, everybody.

Yeah, That’s Flaming Hypocrisy, Colleges: What Are You Going To Do About It?

My guess? Nothing. Or as Matt Cooper says to Amity Mayor Larry Vaughn in “Jaws,” “You will ignore this particular problem until it swims up and bites you in the ass!”

Forbes reports that colleges, in varying standards, forbid applicants from using artificial intelligence to complete their submissions. For example, Yale regards submitting substantive AI-produced content as application fraud, yet it allows AI for grammar, spelling, general advice, and early topic ideas. (I would not permit those either, but you know, Yale.) Cornell allows applicants use AI to research colleges and build a list, but not to outline, draft, write, or translate their responses. (But then that school will kick you out if a co-ed has second thoughts about a drunken orgy she eagerly participated in and accuses you of rape. But I digress…)

Ah, but all colleges are now using AI to compose their letters to potential applicants, and the students know it. They also know that the schools will use AI to sort, rank, and evaluate their applications, including rating their essays. Forbes:

AI can answer a student’s question in seconds, probably more thoroughly than a busy admissions officer could on the spot…Some systems can flag unusual cases and hand them to staff, which helps. But a handoff only matters if a knowledgeable person is available and empowered to act….Recruitment has always involved marketing: buying student names, segmenting audiences, competing for applicants. AI makes it faster and more sophisticated. Research on AI in academic marketing lists chatbots, personalized messages, recommendation tools, and predictive information services among the tools changing how institutions talk to students.

A college can currently tailor messages to a student’s major, location, activities, or finances, then generate variations, test them, and adjust. That may help students find opportunities they’d otherwise miss. But a message that appears personal isn’t proof that anyone paid personal attention. An officer writing to a student after reading her application is doing something different from a system filling in data points. Either may be useful, but only one shows a person actually considered the student.

Colleges promise small classes, mentoring and communities where students aren’t anonymous. If the recruitment process becomes largely automated, they should ask whether it supports those promises or quietly undercuts them.

Pre-Thanksgiving Open Forum!

As long-time readers here know, I appreciate the importance of Thanksgiving but have not been able to enjoy the holiday for many years, coming as it does in the middle of a stretch of bad dates and bad memories: November 22, when the only President assassinated in my lifetime was killed; November 23, which would have been my 46th anniversary if Grace hadn’t dropped dead in 2024; and my birthday, December 1 (marked by one of the least distinguished lists of people born on that day on the whole calendar), which has officially been “Finding Dad Dead in His Chair Day” for me since I did in 2009.

This year, I am going to try to celebrate Thanksgiving for the first time in four years, by going out to dinner with two women, a lawyer and a teacher, who are MSNBC addicts and so Trump Deranged it is literally dangerous to mention the President’s name in their presence. Pray for me.

But first, please engage in enlightening and erudite banter about emerging ethics issues and developments. As usual, there are a lot of them.

Ethics Dunce, “Bias Makes You Stupid” Victim and General Embarrassment: Amy McGrath

Amy was the Democratic nominee for the U.S. Senate in Kentucky, and given the other idiots people voted for while throwing their tantrum over the cost of Oreos, it’s amazing that she lost. Now she has decided to show the world just how dumb she is, posting this now viral entry on “X,”and sucking leftist writer Kurt Anderson into her humiliation in the process:

Trump’s the moron. That’s the Philippine flag, not the Russian flag. Confirmation bias! Is there anything it can’t do?

Then Amy proved that she’s an asshole as well as an idiot. After being thoroughly mocked for both her mistake and being so certain she was right and Trump was wrong, she posted this:

A Democratic Senate candidate mixes up the flags, is snotty in her certitude, then deflects by saying Trump could have been doing what she falsely claimed, so there. And over 2,000 people “love” that response.

Marryin’ Sam and Li’l Abner want an encore: