Yeah, That’s Flaming Hypocrisy, Colleges: What Are You Going To Do About It?

My guess? Nothing. Or as Matt Cooper says to Amity Mayor Larry Vaughn in “Jaws,” “You will ignore this particular problem until it swims up and bites you in the ass!”

Forbes reports that colleges, in varying standards, forbid applicants from using artificial intelligence to complete their submissions. For example, Yale regards submitting substantive AI-produced content as application fraud, yet it allows AI for grammar, spelling, general advice, and early topic ideas. (I would not permit those either, but you know, Yale.) Cornell allows applicants use AI to research colleges and build a list, but not to outline, draft, write, or translate their responses. (But then that school will kick you out if a co-ed has second thoughts about a drunken orgy she eagerly participated in and accuses you of rape. But I digress…)

Ah, but all colleges are now using AI to compose their letters to potential applicants, and the students know it. They also know that the schools will use AI to sort, rank, and evaluate their applications, including rating their essays. Forbes:

AI can answer a student’s question in seconds, probably more thoroughly than a busy admissions officer could on the spot…Some systems can flag unusual cases and hand them to staff, which helps. But a handoff only matters if a knowledgeable person is available and empowered to act….Recruitment has always involved marketing: buying student names, segmenting audiences, competing for applicants. AI makes it faster and more sophisticated. Research on AI in academic marketing lists chatbots, personalized messages, recommendation tools, and predictive information services among the tools changing how institutions talk to students.

A college can currently tailor messages to a student’s major, location, activities, or finances, then generate variations, test them, and adjust. That may help students find opportunities they’d otherwise miss. But a message that appears personal isn’t proof that anyone paid personal attention. An officer writing to a student after reading her application is doing something different from a system filling in data points. Either may be useful, but only one shows a person actually considered the student.

Colleges promise small classes, mentoring and communities where students aren’t anonymous. If the recruitment process becomes largely automated, they should ask whether it supports those promises or quietly undercuts them.

Pre-Thanksgiving Open Forum!

As long-time readers here know, I appreciate the importance of Thanksgiving but have not been able to enjoy the holiday for many years, coming as it does in the middle of a stretch of bad dates and bad memories: November 22, when the only President assassinated in my lifetime was killed; November 23, which would have been my 46th anniversary if Grace hadn’t dropped dead in 2024; and my birthday, December 1 (marked by one of the least distinguished lists of people born on that day on the whole calendar), which has officially been “Finding Dad Dead in His Chair Day” for me since I did in 2009.

This year, I am going to try to celebrate Thanksgiving for the first time in four years, by going out to dinner with two women, a lawyer and a teacher, who are MSNBC addicts and so Trump Deranged it is literally dangerous to mention the President’s name in their presence. Pray for me.

But first, please engage in enlightening and erudite banter about emerging ethics issues and developments. As usual, there are a lot of them.

Ethics Dunce, “Bias Makes You Stupid” Victim and General Embarrassment: Amy McGrath

Amy was the Democratic nominee for the U.S. Senate in Kentucky, and given the other idiots people voted for while throwing their tantrum over the cost of Oreos, it’s amazing that she lost. Now she has decided to show the world just how dumb she is, posting this now viral entry on “X,”and sucking leftist writer Kurt Anderson into her humiliation in the process:

Trump’s the moron. That’s the Philippine flag, not the Russian flag. Confirmation bias! Is there anything it can’t do?

Then Amy proved that she’s an asshole as well as an idiot. After being thoroughly mocked for both her mistake and being so certain she was right and Trump was wrong, she posted this:

A Democratic Senate candidate mixes up the flags, is snotty in her certitude, then deflects by saying Trump could have been doing what she falsely claimed, so there. And over 2,000 people “love” that response.

Marryin’ Sam and Li’l Abner want an encore:

List Incompetence Again: Variety’s “100 Greatest Movie Stars” [Expanded]

Is this one worse than the “The 100 Best Vocalists of All Time” that left off Bing Crosby and Judy Garland, among others? Hard to say. Variety’s list of the top hundred movie stars is objectively ignorant and lazy, but still helpful in that it shows how incompetent the so-called Bible of show business has become in 2026. The selectors couldn’t have done too much worse tossing darts at names on a poster. Maybe that’s what the five Variety staffers who concocted this mess did.

As you can see—they apparently couldn’t but you can, I hope—they didn’t even follow their own criteria, which they claim was..

Measuring the greatness of a movie star can be like catching lightning in a bottle. It’s a process that requires chemistry and finesse, as well as a search for the perfect mix — that fusion of artistry and popularity, history and currency that adds up to the incandescent ideal of stardom. Not every movie star is a great actor; not every great actor is a movie star. Many of the choices on our list reflect that. Yet there’s a magic zone where talent and luminescence fuse. And there’s another overlap that might be even more important: the one between the way these people pop onscreen and the way they dance in our dreams. To choose the 100 Greatest Movie Stars, we had to use our heads, our hearts, our guts, our fantasy lives. We were looking for the stars who magnetize us, the ones who awe and overpower us and make us swoon. The ones we wish we were, and the ones who inspire the ultimate movie-star thought: “That’s who I am.”

Uh-huh. Fine words, until you look at the list. It’s not worth either of our sock drawer times to do a thorough debunking, so I’ll just mention some obvious problems because if I start writing in detail, I may never stop. (cont.)

A Visual Lie

I was going to let this one go, I really was, but then another one of my Trump Dearnged actor friends—great guy, talented, gullible—posted this just now, and then another friend, smarter, usually reasonable, also posted it. I couldn’t restrain myself, writing to the latter:

“Come on, I know you’re better than this. That’s a fake photo. Please don’t spread visual lies. Anyone can criticize the ballroom on the facts, but circulating false information (I’m sure you didn’t accept this hoax intentionally, but we have to be careful) to make a case in court would get me suspended as a lawyer, and is no more excusable for a responsible citizen.”

Then I posted the images above. “Mike,” a friend of my friend, a composer, so I guess I shouldn’t expect him to check facts before sounding off, had written as a reply, “It is a sad state of affairs we find ourselves in.” I wrote, “And to Mike, whoever you are: the sad state of affairs is previously fair and trustworthy people being sucked into a hate mob.”

I was shocked myself when I saw that fake photo, and thought, “Good Lord, that’s truly a monstrosity. This is the kind of thing that helped lose the mid-terms.” Then I checked. And it is the kind of thing that lost the midterms: mass misrepresentation, social media hate, and manipulation of public opinion against the nation’s elected leader.

As EA readers might discern by now, I am increasingly losing the daily wrestling matches with my fingers as my friends post more and more unethical, ignorant, biased, hateful garbage and expect nothing but”loves” and “likes.”

A News Aggregator Read My Mind! [Corrected]

I finally had read too much clickbait lately, and was particularly disgusted with deliberately misleading or ambiguous headlines about the deaths of minor artists and celebrities. The one that triggered my determination to post about the unethical but now routine practice was the headline, “Beloved CBS Comedy Star Dead in an annoying news aggregator called Internews Group.

“Oh no,” I thought. Dick Van Dyke? Carol Burnett? So I clicked on the story. The “beloved” star was…Anthony Clark. Who? He was a cast member in a forgettable sitcom called “Yes, Dear.”

Back when I was taking journalism classes, I was taught that the standard for headlines was to convey succinctly the news event so someone reading only the top of the article would still know what happened. Thus the headline in this case would have been “Anthony Clark, Stand-up Comic and Sitcom Star, Dead at 62.” But the internet ruins, if not everything, certainly a lot of ethics, so online headlines now are written to hide key information in order to attract “clicks.” The next step, as the Internews story demonstrates, is to add ambiguous misinformation. Oh, I’m sure someone loved Anthony Clark, but calling him a “beloved” star is pure deceit.

When I sat down at my sesk this morning to get the post written, the headline, which I had up on my screen overnight, had changed! Now it reads, “Popular CBS Comedy Star Dead at 62.” [Notice of Correction: the original misleading headline did not include the age. I was lazy and careless and just copied the new version. I know Dick and Carol are a lot older than 62…] Withholding the name is still unethical journalism, but that’s much better.

I’ll take my ethics victories, as wan as they are, whenever I can.

Wouldn’t It Be Great If People Could Tell Ethical Values From Cantaloupes? The Middletown High School Football Debacle…

This is what happened…

Less than a week after his undefeated team forfeited a playoff victory for using an ineligible player for 53 seconds of the game, Middletown (New York) High School football coach Tim Strenfel (above) resigned. (So did assistant football coach Isaac Cayetano, a bit later). Strenfel had been the team’s coach for ten years, but he put a kicker who was ineligible to play in any playoff games into one for eight plays. Though they lasted a less than a minute in total and had no effect on the final score, that mistake in the Section IX Class AAs play-offs wiped away his team’s perfect season, making its final record 9-1.

The player had been on the Middletown Boys Soccer team before joining the football team in the middle of the regular season. He was cleared to play in the regular season games but was ineligible for the play-offs because he was not on the team roster for the minimum three regular-season games. That rule is right in New York State Public High School Athletic Association guidelines. After the game, the coaches of the losing team, Newburgh Free Academy, learned about the ineligible player and registered a protest to Valley Central officials. Valley Central Athletics Director then reported the rules violation to Section IX officials, who decreed that Middletown had to forfeit the win.

Middletown challenged the disqualification through the athletic appeals process before taking the matter to Orange County Supreme Court last week. Following a nearly two-hour hearing, the district withdrew its petition once the judge indicated she would not reverse the forfeit.

Let the finger-pointing commence! (cont.)

Comment of the Day: “Unethical Quote of the Month: Some Deranged Friend of a Friend on Facebook—And the Toxic Asshole Diagnosis Challenge!”

AM Golden took up The Toxic Asshole Challenge and knocked it out of the metaphorical park. After that thorough fisking, no one else was going to venture into the fray, so we have a winner!

Here is AM’s Comment of the Day on the rueful post, “Unethical Quote of the Month: Some Deranged Friend of a Friend on Facebook—And the Toxic Asshole Diagnosis Challenge!” I had a total of 219 asshole points as a maximum score, and I’ll add up AM’s results, in brackets, as the post proceeds. I’ll also add some commentary in italics.

***

Okay, I’m back from church, I’ve had my nap and the TV is still out because of a Cable outage that has inevitably lasted longer than they expected, so, let’s give this a go.

“I’m just flat out unfriending now.”
Starting out your screed with how you are unfriending the person you are going to rant at really gives no real incentive for a normal person to read it. [Score: 10 pts. Unfriending anyone simply for having a different opinion is almost peak asshole.]

I don’t have it in me to educate people, especially while on vacation in Thailand.

And, yet, the following essay certainly took much longer than just the act of unfriending. It certainly seems like you are trying educate someone. Or, perhaps, re-educate them into your way of thinking which you appear to think is best. [Score: 6 pts. Subtotal: 16]

And if people are determined to blame Democratic leaders for *checking notes* winning on such an unprecedented level that Republicans may never recover again, then clearly they aren’t interested in the same kind of progress I am.

Because your type of progress is the best progress of all? Being concerned about the behavior one’s own winning party when that party seems intent on destruction means that person isn’t as good a person as you are? Also, reports of the deaths of political parties, Republican or Democrat, are historically greatly exaggerated. [Score: 8 pts for the false assertion that the mid-term sweep was “unprecedented; 10 more for the moronic claim that the GOP will never win again..” Subtotal: 34]

I don’t know why they feel the need to be shitting all over the party that just delivered us this win (I have some theories, but different theories may apply to different people and bottom line the reasons are irrelevant), but clearly they have lost the plot.

Oh, maybe because the winning party won for reasons that they are now shunting to the side in order to engage in partisan warfare? [I didn’t have points for this. AM gets 4 Bonus Points. Subtotal: 36]

Be a fucking ally.

You are either my kind of Democrat or no kind of Democrat. [Four more bonus points: I didn’t flag this.Subtotal: 40] [cont.]

From The Res Ipsa Loquitur Files…

I have had similar conversations with my progressive, knee-jerk Democrat friends. I still don’t get it, but the experience has helped me understand why German Jews too so long to catch on to Hitler’s plans.

One party has embraced anti-Semitism, will not grant Israel’s right to exist and enabled Hamas terrorism. The other party is the party of Donald Trump. Who to support should be pretty clear, but, amazingly, it isn’t.

On St. Patrick’s Day Parades and “Malicious Compliance”

“Florida just canceled their annual St. Patrick’s day parade due to Republicans’ anti-DEI policy,” a lying Democratic social media account announced last week. Naturally, much of social media reported the fake news as fact, with the message that this exemplifies what’s so wrong about anti-DEI policies. NBC framed the story as “A new anti-DEI law championed by Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis that goes into effect next year has resulted in the cancellation of a St. Patrick’s Day parade,” but at least explained that only one municipality did it, the city of Delray Beach, which “announced that it was pulling the plug on the popular 60-year-old spectacle — as well as the city’s annual Pride celebration.”

“Following a review of the legislation and its requirements, the City has determined that it is legally prohibited from organizing, funding, or promoting these events in 2027,” a city spokesperson said. “Although the city is no longer able to fund these events, it does not prevent private entities from sponsoring these or similar events,” the city of Delray Beach posted on its official Facebook page.

DeSantis pooh-poohed the city’s interpretation and dismissed it as “malicious compliance,” which is when authorities deliberately interpret a law overly strictly in order to make the law look bad. I disagree. That law should be interpreted strictly. Governments should not be paying to celebrate any ethnic, religious, acial or sexual group. That they have done so for a very long time doesn’t mean that it is tolerable in 2026. Today it is St. Patrick’s Day, tomorrow it is Somali Scamster Day. There isn’t any way off that slippery slope.

These various ethnic celebrations originated at a time when immigrant groups were being discriminated against and assailed by American nativists. Then, they may have helped persuade the greater community that the new American were a benign and positive addition to our society. Now, and for some time, many of these events are framed as defiance, statements that a group will not assimilate and that it may even reject the values of the society around it. The government should not participate in that.

DEI was a demonically clever way to allow governments to play favorites and elevate one group over others on the pretense of past grievances. Once that became a fad, embracing a celebration like St. Patrick’s Day because of the color and the cute characters, catchy songs and an excuse to get drunk is no longer a luxury the U.S. can afford. Well-funded activists are ready to weaponize the tradition against equal protection under the law.

Yes…“this is why we can’t have nice things.” Nonetheless, the Florida law became necessary, and while Delray Beach may have intended malicious compliance, its action was necessary too. If a tribe wants to celebrate itself, that group should pay for the privilege.