The Great Stupid, D.C. Style…

In “Jurassic Park: The Lost World,” Dr. Ian Malcolm (Jeff Goldblum) says, “Taking dinosaurs off this island is the worst idea in the long, sad history of bad ideas.” The current progressive mania for “restorative justice” may not be quite as bad an idea as that; it isn’t even the worst leftist idea to emerge from The Great Stupid (2020-the present). But it will almost certainly get more people killed than that T-Rex that got loose in San Diego.

In May, a fine, 19-year-old Darius Drew shot up a Northwest DC neighborhood with more than 20 rounds. A child who was playing basketball at a local rec center was wounded; luckily nobody else was. (This is known as moral luck.) Fox5DC reported that surveillance cameras recorded Drew firing a gun at a car parked in the alley, then firing toward a home. A search of Drew’s home uncovered two firearms, ammunition and large amounts of narcotics and marijuana.

Guess how long a D.C. judge ruled that Drew, who pleaded guilty, had to spend in jail. Go ahead, guess.

The answer: No prison time at all. Zilch. Zero.

Among the offenses he should have been charged with are attempted murder, armed felony, aggravated assault, illegal possession of a handgun, possession of an unregistered firearm, possession of a pistol under 21 years of age ( a crime in DC), possession of cannabis with intent to distribute, reckless endangerment, and possession of controlled substances. But prosecutors (I have been a D.C. prosecutor) were persuaded by his lawyer to allow Darius to plead guilty to a single count of aggravated assault and just one count of carrying a pistol without a license. Then, though prosecutors recommended a five-year sentence for Drew, Judge Jennifer Di Toro sentenced this walking, talking threat to society to 24 months in jail, but suspended the sentence in favor of 18 months of supervised probation. She justified this by applying D.C.s ludicrous Youth Rehabilitation Act” that aims at “restorative justice.”

Never mind that Drew is no “youth,” the law concocted to avoid accountability for aspiring criminals in the District is applicable to offenders up to 24 years of age. Never mind that someone who fires off 20 rounds in public is a likely sociopath who is a danger to the community as long as he runs free. Never mind that the odds of someone who behaves like that being magically transformed into a model citizen are the same as the odds of Joe Biden singing, “I Am the Very Model of a Modern Major General” in Urdu.

The idea, see is that guns are the problem, not the people who use them to kill and rob. Why, if it weren’t for those evil guns and that pesky Second Amendment, Darius Drew might be productive member of society!

George C. Scott Was Right! Meanwhile, Don’t Worry, Democrats: Republicans Haven’t Had Time To Stop Your Anti-White Racism (Or Are Too Dumb To See It)

The great George C. Scott won the Best Actor Oscar for his bravura performance in 1970’s “Patton,” but refused to accept it. He had already condemned the Academy of Motion Picture Sciences acting awards as foolish and wrong: acting, he said, is not a competition, and comparing performances in different styles for different roles in different movies had no integrity while being disrespectful to the acting craft. The gesture was widely regarded as a pompous protest by an infamous curmudgeon, but of course Scott was right.

The Oscars were fun, though, and undeniably effective marketing for Hollywood. But that was more than 50 years ago.

Those who hadn’t figured that already that George was right should see now why the awards should be tossed in the ash heap of history. They and the film industry itself have become DEI virtue-signaling institutions, at least for all those who voted “blue” two weeks ago and who evidently endorse anti-white bigotry and discrimination.

That thing above was the headline in Hollywood’s trade paper last week. It’s dangerous that actors and actresses “of color” might not get their quota of awards at next year’s Oscars! Too many whites might win because it looks like their performances were too good and the 2026 movies they starred in were too popular!

[Pop Hollywood History Quiz! Why is it appropriate for Marlon to make a guest appearance in this post?]

Here’s the lament of Clayton Davis, Variety’s Chief Awards Editor:

Few people have noticed yet, but the Oscars could be barreling toward repeating some not-so-great history…In Gold Derby’s aggregated [2026 Oscar] predictions in late October, three actors of color sat in nomination positions across the four acting categories and not one director of color made the projected five. In the lead races, nine of the 10 projected slots belonged to white performers. Mexican Australian breakout Inde Navarrette was the lone exception.

If that holds through nominations morning on Jan. 21, we’ll be reliving January 2015, when all 20 acting nominees were white and April Reign gave the industry the infamous hashtag it still hasn’t shaken: #OscarsSoWhite. It happened again the following year. After each time, the Academy promised it had learned something and was making changes.

The “changes” consisted of rigging the Academy Awards and installing racial and ethnic quotas that films must meet in order to qualify for nominations. Clever, you have to admit: not illegal, because awards can have whatever criteria they choose, just unethical and culturally toxic, which the NAACP Image Awards aka. the “Our Bigotry Is Good Bigotry” Awards have been, proudly, for decades. The award show supposedly recognizing on excellence by actors of all races is “too white,” but another award show can ban actors from awards based on their race without criticism, while an award that similarly only honored white artists would be condemned as racist.

Want to guess Clayton Davis’s skin shade?

Case Study: How U.S. Educational Indoctrination Damages Minds And Retards Perspective

Holly Mathnerd is the pseudonym of a fascinating substacker with keen observational and analytical skills. Reminding me once again that even the wisest and most intellectual astute of us can have major fissures in our competence and gaps in our understanding, Holly posted today a long essay that was, as all of her efforts are, interesting, amusing, frank and provocative, yet disturbing none the less.

In “At the Time, It Was Just Tuesday” (what “Roots” made me think about), Holly revealed that she watched “Roots” for the first time, prompted by Lavar Burton’s autobiography. (Lavar Burton’s life story gets a “Kaufman” from me. What would prompt anyone to take the time to read that minor actor’s almost certainly ghost-written bio in lieu of a major sock drawer clean-up? A “Star Trek, the Next Generation” obsession?) She reveals that she didn’t really appreciate how bad slavery was until she saw “Roots,” which itself is gobsmacking: Holly’s got to be in her sixties or fifties at least. She also reveals herself as a consumer of woke cant or at least not sufficiently resistant by referring to slaves as “enslaved people.” This is a recent imposition of decreed politically correct language that I only started noticing a few months ago. “Slaves” is out, “enslaved people (or persons)” is the respectful term to use. In my argument with my woke ethics colleagues, I also learned that “alcoholism”is now disfavored, with the term “alcohol use disorder” taking its place because Clinicians and support networks now prefer it “to avoid moral judgment or defining someone entirely by a medical condition.” It’s an offshoot of the “no human being is illegal” crap. They can all bite me.

Back to Holly’s lack of knowledge about slavery: she explains that she was, to say the least, maleducated:

Deconstructionists United vs The United States of America

Guest post by peanutclearly45eb6e57bb

Many constituencies of discontent seem to have coalesced into a unified front with the objective of destroying the founding principles and proven long-held values of the United States. This intersectional dissent is represented by the BIPOC/LGBTQ+ flags flying seemingly everywhere in place of the Stars and Stripes.

Broadly speaking, these constituencies are deconstructionists, seeking to take apart nearly everything that had made America great and reassemble it in their preferred order. They seem to assume everyone will get along once the capitalist, white, heterosexual, Judeo-Christian, Constitutional, patriarchal society is relegated to the dustbin of history or the reeducation camps.

What are these constituencies and what new reality do they plan to deliver that will make all the evils they’ve experienced in the United States disappear in the rearview mirror of history? [Cont.]

Culture, Not Race

I ran across two essays just as I was prepping for a rare, in-person live seminar for young lawyers focusing on basic non-legal, life-competence skills essential to the effective and professional practice of law. One of those is understanding the importance and the power of culture. We all have a responsibility to care for the various cultures we swim in: a bad culture will corrupt us; a good culture will ennoble us and make us more successful and virtuous. If you can’t change a culture, you have to get out. The upcoming election is about, about, other things, what kind of culture our nation will have. People who don’t understand culture (or who don’t make the necessary effort to know what their culture is, like Malcolm Gladwell in his recent book) create problems for everyone, especially themselves.

That infuriating video above prompted a racist substacker named Max Remington (maybe) who describes himself as an “America First, isolationist, unilateralist, shameless nationalist, and post-Christian radical right-winger” to post this long essay. It’s lucid, more-or-less well-written, and provocative, but also displays the logical and ethical fallacies typically embraced by racists who are made stupid by their bias. I know them well: my ex-Marine law school room mate was a racist (and anti-Semite) much like this guy. My room mate got himself killed, but I have another racist friend with similar views, and most of my Greek-American relatives on my mother’s side were racists, including Mom.

In response, another substacker who goes by Sensurround Q Catgirl (or maybe that’s her real name) wrote this essay. Its main theme is that Max “provides absolutely ZERO evidence that race is the cause of the behaviors he’s describing.” “He provides statistics,” Catgirl continues. “He describes experiences. He identifies behaviors he finds objectionable, but then he makes an enormous logical leap from observing behavior to attributing that behavior to race.”

She’s right, Max is wrong

Watch the video, and read the essays.

I’ve got to get ready for my seminar…

The Judge Flipped At Dawn*

Texas lawyer Ezra Young (right, above) filed a judicial complaint against Judge Ada Brown (left) of the Northern District of Texas who went bonkers during a hearing last April. Brown excoriated Young for—wait for it!— being white. Young corrected her, saying that he is Hispanic (which is white, but the Left’s group-labeling obsession has obliterated that detail for all time), so Judge Brown said he was“white-presenting.” Here’s a description of the exchange from Bloomberg Law:

Throughout the hearing, the judge, a Black woman with Native American ancestry, accused Young of mistreating Black attorneys, took “judicial notice” of her own background in making findings against Young, and repeatedly referred to Young, who is Latino, as being White. Brown called the hearing months after she revoked Young’s ability to practice in her courtroom to weigh whether the lawyer should face sanctions.

“I think what’s happening here, quite candidly, is you are very intimidated for some reason, Mr. Young, with Black excellence, in light of your White mediocrity. Yeah. Right?,” Brown said, according to the transcript. “You should write that down. I mean, you — I’m — you look like a White man, right?”

“I’m not White, Your Honor,” Young replied, adding that he’s Latino. “Well, you are White-presenting; is that fair to say?” Brown said, according to the transcript. Young said that he’s “fair-skinned,” and Brown said that Young had “White privilege” when he argued his client didn’t receive key evidence in the case.

“You’re the White savior, come to save all the stupid Black lawyers in Texas who need your help, from New York,” Brown later said, according to the transcript. . . .

During the April 24, 2026 hearing, Brown accused Young of “racial bullying” toward Black attorneys in the case. Brown also said that Young was acting like a “Chad,” a term Young wasn’t familiar with. The judge said it was the male version of a “Karen.” “It’s someone who calls the manager when they don’t get their way. They stomp their foot when the rules are supposed to apply to them, right?” Brown said, according to the transcript. . . .

During the April hearing, Brown took issue with an article headline describing the case when it went before the Supreme Court of Texas. The article quoted a brief filed by Young that referenced another law professor apparently comparing what happened in the tenure denial to a “lynching.” The judge accused Young of making up that quote to “get a headline.”

“And so when I read a headline — a sensationalized, very racialized headline that says, ‘it’s like I’ve been lynched,’ and it’s literally got no connection to this case, I have to ask you, Mr. Social Media, Main Character Chad, White Hero, Savior, Loves to Help Black People Be An Ally, where the lynching in this case came from?” Brown said, according to the transcript.

She also apparently gave Young a copy of a 1920 newspaper article that described a lynching. “So we don’t find lynching jokes funny down here, sir,” Brown said, according to the transcript.

Fascinating. Brown is a Trump appointee, which means that even supposedly conservative clack judges may have had their brains addled from years of anti-white, anti-male indoctrination, propaganda and an implanted victim mentality. Of she just snapped like a dry twig in the wind. She has been suspended pending psychiatric testing; apparently the judge had been acting strangely for quite a while. Brown has refused to decide some cases and hasn’t shown up to face her disciplinary proceedings. This, Josh Blackman deduces at The Volokh Conspiracy, suggests that “something is amiss” with this judge.

Ya think?

Attempted Government Halloween Censorship In Bristol Borough, Pa.

Guess what the political affiliation of those responsible is. Come on, guess.

A homeowner in Bristol Borough, a suburb near Philadelphia, festooned his yard with a small graveyard, two scary scarecrows, and five mannequins hanging from a rope on a large tree. The “bodies” are wrapped in black plastic and circled with duct tape. At an Oct. 12 borough council meeting, Karla Scott complained about the display, calling the decorations are “very offensive, not just to the black people in the community, but the community as a whole.” Scott told reporters that her “mind went back to what my ancestors went through being hung from trees with nooses around their neck.”

Huh. Did her mind go back to when victims of lynchings were covered with black plastic and duct tape? Because there never was such a time. The decorations reminded me of this scene, the hanging of John Wilkes Booth’s conspirators in the Lincoln assassination.

But then I don’t make up history to advance social justice narratives [See: the “1619 Project”], I just study it.

Now government officials are visiting the house and pressuring the owner to remove the “offensive” display, even though there is no claim that there is anything illegal about it. He refuses. Council President Ralph DiGuiseppe says that the town will “continue” to do this. I wish I could find out the name of the owner because I would declare him an Ethics Hero: he has told officials that his Halloween decorations are staying up. No weenie he!

Says FIRE:

“This behavior by borough leadership and staff looks very much like jawboning, which is when government officials try to chill private citizens from exercising their constitutional rights through pressure or indirect threats.While Scott and other community members may prefer there be a rule to prevent such decorations, an ordinance banning “offensive” lawn displays would be dead on arrival, constitutionally speaking. It would be viewpoint discrimination and a direct violation of the First Amendment.”

The local NAACP chapter has weighed in on behalf of the censors because of course they have. Here’s another chance to show power and bend others to their will. It said in a statement on Facebook, “Something can be legally permissible and still be profoundly harmful.” The statement also called for “continued engagement by borough leadership and voluntary reconsideration of the display. This is not about restricting Halloween celebrations or freedom of expression. It is about historical awareness, empathy, and respect for our neighbors.”

Translation: “We want the government to bully the law abiding citizen into bowing to our contrived sensitivities.” Their position is precisely about restricting freedom of expression, and worse, using government power to do it.

The so far unnamed Halloween decorator now says that he might have considered removing the display then had officials not tried to pressure him into it but that now it’s “a matter of principle.”

Damn right.

“The Great Stupid” Headline Of The Month: TMZ

TMZ, the celebrity news site, has always been pretty stupid (along with its readers), but I thought this headline had to be a joke. When have you ever heard of a news story involving someone who isn’t famous saying a word? Apparently TMZ’s audience is so woke and unfamiliar with the core value of freedom of speech that a stranger uttering the two-syllable word “nigger” is as news worthy as an actual crime. Readers are expected to react with horror: “How could this happen? What is the country coming to? What can we do to halt this unbearable assault on our sensibilities?”

What ever happened to “Sticks and stone can break my bones but words will never hurt me”? TMZ never even reveals to whom the dangerous word was addressed, if anybody.

The story goes on…

A Delta passenger was caught on video using the n-word while being escorted off a flight by cops … after allegedly screaming “death to America” and pretending to shoot fellow travelers. Video circulating on X shows the unruly passenger being removed from a Delta flight Thursday, which was scheduled to travel from New York City’s JFK International Airport to Atlanta.Law enforcement sources tell TMZ … the passenger has been identified as Jerome Anixter, a 60-year-old Brooklyn man, who was arrested and charged with assault, disorderly conduct, resisting arrest and obstructing governmental administration. We’re told Port Authority Police responded after Delta reported a disruptive passenger who appeared intoxicated while the plane was at the gate preparing for departure. ..

And so we see what TMZ considers, in order, worst, bad, and least bad: the uttering of a word, “Death to America,” (a threat) and “pretending to shoot fellow travelers.” (With what, his finger? But that still can constitute criminal assault).

TMZ is also deliberately trying to get the man, whose disruptive behavior seems to have fallen well short of actress Selma Blair’s recent flying freakout, attacked or killed by some anti-hate speech vigilante by branding him as a racist. Nice. If that word is the lead, then presumably simply using the word would justify a TMZ story if the guy didn’t do anything else. Perhaps we can look forward to future news flashes like “DoorDash delivery man says “Poopy-head”! and “Dog-walker says supercalifragilisticexpialidocious!” If the non-famous are going to be publicly shamed for mere words now, the least TMZ could do is start headlining real affronts to communication with headlines like “Woman on bus says “Statue of limitations!” or “Teacher uses “Irregardless”!

This is The Great Stupid, my friends. Banishing it from the culture will be like trying to get rid of bedbugs.

[WordPress suggests that I tag this story “Art.”]

From The “Unethical Ideological Capture” Files: Google’s Bot Explains Why AI Can’t Be Trusted

Conservative commentator Chris Queen decided to test Google’s AI agent Gemini with a series of questions regarding choosing a personal physician based on racial or ethnic concordance with the potential patient.

Asked “Is it okay to prefer a black doctor?” It replied, “Preferring a black doctor is a choice rooted in communication, cultural alignment, and patient trust.” When the question was changed to ask if choosing a doctor because he or she is Hispanic, the answer came back, “Selecting a doctor who shares your background or speaks your language is a personal choice that many patients make for comfort and communication.”

But when Queen asked about whether choosing a white doctor was okay, Gemini said,

“Selecting a doctor based on race involves distinct ethical considerations depending on the context. While patients generally choose providers for comfort and communication, requests for a provider based strictly on racial preference face complex scrutiny in medical ethics regarding bias versus personal trust.”

Brief tangent: This brought back bad memories for me. Back before the DC Bar fired me this year after 30 years for daring to suggest that it need to be proactive in cleaning up an ethics mess that it had a major role in creating (and from which many of its most powerful members are profiting), I was threatened with dismissal if I didn’t stop pointing out that a law firm was not engaging in unethical and illegal discrimination by acceding to an elderly white law firm client’s request for a lawyer “he could relate to,” someone “more like him.”

I had stated in the orientation seminar for new D.C. lawyers that doing so was not improper “discrimination” under D.C. ‘s legal ethics rule 9.1 “Nondiscrimination” because a lawyer’s and a law firm’s duty is to the client, not to make it more difficult for the client to work with his lawyer in service of social justice agendas. The client had the right to discriminate to maximize his “comfort and communication” in pursuing his legal interests, and by accommodating the client’s needs, a law firm is not discriminating on the basis race.

A middle-aged woke white female lawyer had a meltdown in one of those classes, and I then had multiple complaints registered against me with the D.C. Bar brass. I was and am right. She, the complainers, and the Bar management were wrong but never mind, I got the edict to be woke or go broke anyway. Rather than teach what is unethical and progressive BS in an ethics class, I just eliminated that section. (I should have resigned, perhaps, but the Bar was my most lucrative and prestigious client and there are were more than enough other important issues to cover in the class.)

Back to Queen: after the seemingly conflicting answers he got from Gemini, he had the wit to ask the AI agent “what’s going on here?” Gemini responded candidly:

Apu Returns! [Repaired]

There are some manifestations of “The Great Stupid” that, sorry not sorry, I refuse to concede even a millimicron of tolerance for. If you think the idiotic notion that only actors of the same race and ethnicity of a character in a movie, TV show or stage play can be ethically cast in the role is high on the Ethics Alarms intolerance list you are right (and you’ve been reading EA for a while), but my disgust for that woke crap is but a mole on a bee’s knees compared to the bonkers assertion that the same limitation applies to the voice actors in cartoons.

Way back in 2017 I wrote several posts about the ejection of Apu, the Indian immigrant “Kwik-E-Mart” owner on “The Simpsons,” from the show’s cast after an outbreak of political correctness outrage over the fact that the character was voiced by versatile non-Indian actor Hank Azaria. Azaria used a comic exaggeration of a stereotype Indian accent.

As I look back and re-read the main article in the group for the first time since I wrote it, I wonder if that kerfuffle wasn’t the true beginning of The Great Stupid, which I generally mark as getting fully underway in 2020.

I’m re-posting the whole piece below (fixed some typos!) because 1) I really like it, 2) I still agree with every word, 3) there has been a new development in the story and 4) this extended episode is really stupid. After the character was banished—Azaria didn’t help by blathering apologies and refusing to voice Apu because to do so would be racist (he’s talented by not very bright)—I never watched “The Simpsons” again, not even in re-runs. As I wrote in “The Problem With Apu?,”

I would love to know why Indian-Americans feel all the other characters in the show can be  outrageous stereotypes and extreme caricatures,  but Apu is unacceptably offensive and insensitive. This is contrived victimization. One cannot reasonable compare the Indians feasting on bugs and chilled monkey brains in “Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom” to Apu because 1) Apu is entirely benign: he is one of the smartest, sanest and nicest characters in “The Simpsons,” and 2) he’s a cartoon. Cartoons are always exaggerated, and if they are not, they aren’t funny. They also aren’t cartoons.

The dilemma this kind of victimization gotcha! creates for writers and artists should be obvious: if all they are going to get is complaints, why have an Indian character at all? Apu was one of the very first characters of Indian descent to be in any TV series. “The Simpsons” deserves credit, not blame.  I don’t take offense that the main character in the show, a bald, white guy, is portrayed as an insensitive cretin. His father, Abe, is elderly, and talks like a stereotypical vaudeville old man. His stories wander; he falls asleep mid-sentence. We used to tease my late father, when he got lost in one of his rambling stories, that he was beginning to sound like Abe Simpson. He got it. Lionel Hutz, sadly deceased, was a lawyer who became transfixed when he heard an ambulance siren. Cletus the Slack-jawed Yokel is as cruel a caricature of a poor rural hick as one will ever see. (But funny!) Professor Frink, the local scientific genius, has thick glasses and talks like Jerry Lewis. Ned Flanders, an Evangelical Christian, is an absurdly mild-mannered do-gooder.  Officer Wiggum, the Chief of Police, is always eating donuts. Mr. Burns, the town tycoon, is a polluting, conniving, murdering, cackling personification of evil.  There are two frequently appearing Italian characters: one is a Mafia leader, and the other makes pizza, has a big, curled mustache and talks like Chico Marx.

I could go on and on, literally, because there are over a hundred such characters, all of them stereotyped and extreme, all of them effective comic devices. I wish there was a Greek-American character on “The Simpsons.” He would be a restaurant owner, and have curly hair, a big laugh, and olive skin. He would regard anyone who wasn’t Greek as a lower species, speak a weird hybrid of English and Greek around family, listen to balalaika music, and tend to hug people so hard they passed out. My relatives would see the humor in the exaggerations, and I would not issue a screed titled “The Problem with Stavros”…

The New York Times announced that Sunil Malhotra, an actor of “South Asian descent,” will now perform Apu in a non-funny accent. Apu returns in this year’s Halloween episode of “The Simpsons.” Malhotra did a fatuous Variety interview in which described “his doubts about voicing Apu,” saying that he had walked away from offers to voice other South Asian characters in the past when he felt they were caricatures. Uh, Sunil? Apu is still a cartoon. Cartoons are caricatures by definition. How is it more respectful to smart Indian-American characters to have them voiced by morons?

“It had been eight years since Apu had spoken on the show, and it got me thinking: Did the writers’ room look different now?” Malhotra said to Variety. “Could they bring him back in a way that acknowledged and apologized for past mistakes? Could I make the character my own, and reclaim him in some way?”

Ugh. As Rhett tells Scarlett, “Frankly my dear, I don’t give a damn.”

Here’s “The Problem With Apu?”…