Yeah, That’s Flaming Hypocrisy, Colleges: What Are You Going To Do About It?

My guess? Nothing. Or as Matt Cooper says to Amity Mayor Larry Vaughn in “Jaws,” “You will ignore this particular problem until it swims up and bites you in the ass!”

Forbes reports that colleges, in varying standards, forbid applicants from using artificial intelligence to complete their submissions. For example, Yale regards submitting substantive AI-produced content as application fraud, yet it allows AI for grammar, spelling, general advice, and early topic ideas. (I would not permit those either, but you know, Yale.) Cornell allows applicants use AI to research colleges and build a list, but not to outline, draft, write, or translate their responses. (But then that school will kick you out if a co-ed has second thoughts about a drunken orgy she eagerly participated in and accuses you of rape. But I digress…)

Ah, but all colleges are now using AI to compose their letters to potential applicants, and the students know it. They also know that the schools will use AI to sort, rank, and evaluate their applications, including rating their essays. Forbes:

AI can answer a student’s question in seconds, probably more thoroughly than a busy admissions officer could on the spot…Some systems can flag unusual cases and hand them to staff, which helps. But a handoff only matters if a knowledgeable person is available and empowered to act….Recruitment has always involved marketing: buying student names, segmenting audiences, competing for applicants. AI makes it faster and more sophisticated. Research on AI in academic marketing lists chatbots, personalized messages, recommendation tools, and predictive information services among the tools changing how institutions talk to students.

A college can currently tailor messages to a student’s major, location, activities, or finances, then generate variations, test them, and adjust. That may help students find opportunities they’d otherwise miss. But a message that appears personal isn’t proof that anyone paid personal attention. An officer writing to a student after reading her application is doing something different from a system filling in data points. Either may be useful, but only one shows a person actually considered the student.

Colleges promise small classes, mentoring and communities where students aren’t anonymous. If the recruitment process becomes largely automated, they should ask whether it supports those promises or quietly undercuts them.