
I have sworn to flag this every time it happens, which is too often. A popular conservative news aggregating website. “Not the Bee,” headlined its story, “The thing that never happens just happened again. Are we allowed to talk about it yet?” The “thing” was a dog attack that killed a 6-year-old child in Virginia, and the topic we are supposed to talk about is how pit bulls are deadly. The site has been stumping for “pit bull” bans for years. But the linked news story did not describe the dog involved a “pit bull” or even one of the six or seven dog breeds dog ignoramuses call “pit bulls.” That one said the dog was an American Bully, which is not one of the several breeds frequently lumped into the “pit bull” category.
Notice of Correction: I originally included a photo of what one source indicated was the dog involved. I learned from commenter mardybum that it was a stock photo. So we have no photos of the actual dog called a “pit bull” by “Not the Bee” and an American Bully elsewhere. Heck, reporters, police and others are so bad at identifying dog breeds, the dog could have been anything. A cocker spaniel. As long as the photos being used are stock photos unrelated to reality, I’ve replaced the one the post had before with my favorite pit bull photo, which better reflects the dogs’ personality.
Never mind. This is how the dogs get banned in many counties and countries—it was how my pit bull mix ended up on a three year Hell-journey among three abusive owners until Grace and I rescued him.
I don’t believe that any dog is inherently vicious. Vicious dogs are taught by humans to be that way.
Do greyhounds need to be taught to run? Herding dogs need to be taught commands, but they are born with the instinct to herd. Why is it unthinkable that breeds that were bred to fight are good at fighting?
Every dog that I’ve known that comes under the “pit” umbrella has been a sweetie, but most of those were before they were as widespread as they are now. I think the main problem isn’t necessarily who owns them, although that certainly factors in, it’s bad or careless breeders – the ones who, if they consider temperament at all, are looking for violent dogs.
Viciousness is not an inherent quality in canines. They are pack animals that have social hierarchies. To me there is substantial difference in being genetically powerful and have the ability to be violent and and being naturally violent. If the breed was naturally vicious you would not see so many who are friendly docile pets.
Bingo. Also, pure-bred “pit bulls” are the vast minority. Most of what the dog bigots call pit bulls are mixed breeds. If a dog is part Lab, part German Shepherd, part Staffordshire Terrier and part retriever and bites someone. it will be reported as a “pit bull attack.”
Dog’s temperaments were bred over 10,000 years to defer to humans. Even herding is a specific trait bred over 10,000’s of years. It is just not logical that a few amateur breeders are going to create a supervillain dog. Any dog, treated poorly, will be aggressive.
Pit bulls (that is, the American Pit Bull Terrier) were known as “the Nanny Dog” in the first half of the 20th Century because they were so good with kids. Hence “Petey” in the “Our Gang” comedies and “Little Rascals.” They were not bred to fight, or be aggressive. The “fighting dog” among the breeds incorrectly called pit bulls is the Bull Terrier, originally bred for bull-baiting in the Middle Ages: the dog would grab a bull by the face and not let go. Today’s bull terriers are friendly, funny dogs that are also good with kids.
Not every breed of dog is suitable for any owner, and some people simply should not own dogs. Some breeds are very powerful and protective, and need to be well trained and socialized. To name one breed, according to Google AI the Presa Canario is not inherently vicious, but it possesses a high level of natural territorial drive, strong dominance tendencies, and a powerful guarding instinct that can manifest as severe aggression without experienced handling. Should you have a Presa Canario, Cane Corso, Dogo Argentino if this is your first dog, have small children, or live in an apartment? Probably not, in my impression. That means that somebody who wants to own a dog has some ethical obligations, namely a) in choosing the dog that is right for his family, b) knowing the core temperament and aggression traits of the dog, c) properly training and socializing the dog, d) taking good care of the dog, e) receive training as an owner. This is kind of similar to owning a gun, where the owner has responsibilities to handle the gun in a safe way, and be properly trained.
Yes. Dogs are animals, with all that entails. (Or should I say, “all that entales?”)
Not a dog breed expert, but on Googling “American Bully” and looking at the pictures, they look pretty similar to the picture here to me, aside from from the colors, or is that the tell? And did the dog picture come from Not the Bee, because it’s not in the linked news article.
That’s not a photo of the killer dog. It’s a stock photo available through Shutterstock and Adobe.
Then no source has a photo of the actual dog involved! Hell, it could be a sheepdog or a tea cup poodle. THAT pisses me off. I’ll take down that photo, which was used in one of the stories and implied that it was the dog. Thanks.