Culture, Not Race

I ran across two essays just as I was prepping for a rare, in-person live seminar for young lawyers focusing on basic non-legal, life-competence skills essential to the effective and professional practice of law. One of those is understanding the importance and the power of culture. We all have a responsibility to care for the various cultures we swim in: a bad culture will corrupt us; a good culture will ennoble us and make us more successful and virtuous. If you can’t change a culture, you have to get out. The upcoming election is about, about, other things, what kind of culture our nation will have. People who don’t understand culture (or who don’t make the necessary effort to know what their culture is, like Malcolm Gladwell in his recent book) create problems for everyone, especially themselves.

That infuriating video above prompted a racist substacker named Max Remington (maybe) who describes himself as an “America First, isolationist, unilateralist, shameless nationalist, and post-Christian radical right-winger” to post this long essay. It’s lucid, more-or-less well-written, and provocative, but also displays the logical and ethical fallacies typically embraced by racists who are made stupid by their bias. I know them well: my ex-Marine law school room mate was a racist (and anti-Semite) much like this guy. My room mate got himself killed, but I have another racist friend with similar views, and most of my Greek-American relatives on my mother’s side were racists, including Mom.

In response, another substacker who goes by Sensurround Q Catgirl (or maybe that’s her real name) wrote this essay. Its main theme is that Max “provides absolutely ZERO evidence that race is the cause of the behaviors he’s describing.” “He provides statistics,” Catgirl continues. “He describes experiences. He identifies behaviors he finds objectionable, but then he makes an enormous logical leap from observing behavior to attributing that behavior to race.”

She’s right, Max is wrong

Watch the video, and read the essays.

I’ve got to get ready for my seminar…

12 thoughts on “Culture, Not Race”

  1. In recent weeks I have written some comments that may have been interpreted by some as potentially racist. They were not and I am not.

    Culture is the issue as pointed to by our host. There are plenty of people, irrespective of their race, who have allied themselves with narcissistic and thug oriented culture.

    If you are interested in this distinction, there is a black gentleman with a YouTube channel called Consider Culture. Cultural affiliation is the central theme of his channel and addresses how gangster rap culture swamped the opportunity culture of the mid 1980s and embraced a criminal and anti-white racist mindset.

    This same culture, now allied with /oppressed thinking has swamped across racial lines and obliterated any notion of social and economic mobility.

    Subscribing to this culture is the death of perceived individualism and a buy in to systemic oppression.

  2. I noticed the following quote in Max’s substack article:

    To that point, people often argue “It is not race, it is culture.” To that I would say, at what point specifically can you separate a race from its culture? Eventually, you have to face the reality that there is a point where you cannot. Ethnicity has the root word ethno meaning “race, culture.” Culture and race inform and influence one another more than white Americans want to admit, but I truly believe this has been the case for so long due to a lack of exposure to racist minorities.

    When there is a strong correlation between race/ethnicity and certain categories of negative behavior like the one we saw in the video, then an attitude of “Let’s keep race out of it because it is hundred percent about culture” is going to be unproductive.

    First, we need to acknowledge this correlation, as most people can spot this with their own eyes. There is a street takeover in Seattle? You can be almost hundred percent sure that the majority of those involved are black. Two gay men being harassed in a train in the Netherlands, and assaulted after laving the train? If you suspect that the perpetrators have a Muslim background, you are almost guaranteed to be correct. We might call that prejudice or stereotyping, which is wrong according to liberal dogma; but two days later a video appears at YouTube capturing the event, or the police makes arrests and names and mugshots are published, and the prejudices and stereotypes are confirmed. We therefore cannot moralize prejudices and stereotypes away, as they are based on authentic experiences of reality. And reality is what we live in, and if we want that reality changed we have to first address reality as it is.

    Second, we need to name this negative behavior and call out those racial and ethnic communities that produces most of this, preferably by people who belong to that community and have a certain level of trust. See for example the YouTube video at the bottom of my comment.

    Third, we have to stop the gaslighting. E.g. in Europe the government sponsors television campaigns against street harassment of women, where the cat-caller is invariably a stereotypical white male. In reality most street harassment of women occurs by men of a Muslim background who object to the way Western women dress and basically think they are whores. But addressing that reality by having the cat-caller be a man of North African background cannot be done as that would stigmatize ethnic minorities….

    Black fatigue is real. So is Muslim fatigue in Europe. Playing the racism and Islamophobia card against people who notice is a tired tactic, and stopped working a long time ago. Same for appeals to systemic racism. Who are you going to believe, liberal moralists or your lying eyes?

    • CB: I would hope beyond the pattern recognition you can see this culture has infected every race in the form of class warfare, sexuality warfare, and other types. While the point of origin and higher rates of adoption might be in one racial group the mindset has spread to many others and threatens America from all adopting quarters.

      • I would give pattern recognition its due, and not ignore race/ethnicity because of taboos we adopted after the civil rights struggle in the 1960s. We need to get rid of those taboos and call a spade a spade, and bad behavior bad. We need to learn to ignore people who play the race card in order to deflect blame, such as the guy in the video. This guy behaves like a nigger, and does more to perpetuate negative racial stereotypes than any Substack article.

  3. Race, or culture, I’m not sure it matters. It’s a seemingly intractable problem. Three generations after the Civil Rights Act and the declaration of The War on Poverty, things seem to have only gotten worse. The black underclass continues to fail to thrive. And the innumerable apologists have simply redefined failure to thrive as success!

  4. Okay. I’m taking up the challenge. Let’s see how I do.

    “If you didn’t watch it because you didn’t want your blood pressure to go up, I understand.”

    I mean, he’s not wrong here. I hate these videos. Stupid people do stupid things just to make their point. Maybe he’s right or wrong, but the fact that it’s not happening the way he hoped is only making him and me angry. No wonder we struggle with civil dialogue.

    They talk at, not talk to, the police officer, verbally abuse him, immediately bring race into the discussion, and begin yelling uncontrollably.

    Seems like a fair assessment. I only watched the first 8 minutes. By then, he had already been tased.

    As you might imagine, the police officer, who remains calm and courteous throughout the entire exchange, cuts the meeting short, and asks the couple to leave.

    Again, it seems like an accurate description. I would say perhaps police officers had an obligation to hear said complaints. How hard would it have been to get a piece of paper and take notes? He certainly doesn’t help the situation.

    A physical struggle ensues in the lobby, and both D’Angelo and Halsey are tased, ending up in handcuffs for disorderly conduct and assault on a police officer.

    It appears D’Angelo shoves the officer, which starts the arrest. Both sides are to blame here, but the assault falls squarely on D’Angelo. He somehow gets out of the handcuffs and throws up fisty-cuffs. He was lucky he was only tased.

    We’ve all encountered someone like this before, some having the misfortune of direct interaction.

    Sure. I had a guy come to my office wanting to talk about the Bible. He immediately got upset when I told him I use the ESV. I asked him to leave after that. He was white, by the way. I can tell we are going to disagree here.

    And yes, race has everything to do with this.

    Okay, doubtful but okay. Let’s hear you out.

    If the police truly were racist, they would’ve probably told them to hit the road right there in the lobby. They might’ve even arrested him just for showing up.

    Maybe if this was the 1950s. Now we have lawyers and lawsuits. People maybe dumb, but most are not that dumb.

    He immediately escalates, with the full support of his proudly anti-racist White girlfriend, verbally abusing the man trying to help him.

    Agreed. She really made the situation a whole lot worse. I wonder if she saw herself as a white buffer.

    Is everyone really so ideologically indoctrinated to think D’Angelo and Halsey are any kinds of victims, here?
    The implication is no, but maybe yes. They seem to be upset about some kind of stop sign going up after a black man gets stopped there. I don’t know how it works there, but in our town, but you can’t just put a stop sign up. That has to go through council, then code, then you have to put up a sign saying a stop sign will take effect in 30 days. Bureaucracy at its finest, but the fact that it did go up overnight is suspicious.

    There are inevitably liberals out there who’d claim this to be a both sides thing, who’d say the police could’ve done better, even if they concede D’Angelo and Halsey were wrong.
    I guess that makes me a liberal.

    What the hell was the police officer supposed to do? Please, if you really think the folks with badges could’ve done better here, enlighten us all.

    I expect him to do his job. I expect him to sit down with them and de-escalate the situation. I expect him to see things are getting out of control and offer to take a step back. He’s the one with the badge. Of the three of them, the officer is the one who should know better.

    Assume they wanted to file a complaint in any other venue, such as a fast food restaurant.

    When I worked in fast food, I was taught how to de-escalate. It doesn’t always work, but it does work 95% of the time. I don’t feel like the officer did what I was taught to do.

    He’s there to trigger a confrontation, get some digs in, and hopefully end up being able to file a lawsuit.

    IF that’s the man’s goal, then sure, he’s right. But you’re making an assumption, and I’m going to give him the benefit of the doubt.

    He’s unresponsive to your compassion and empathy. He’s strong and you’re weak. He’s willing to use violence to have his way and you’re not. There’s a natural pecking order and you’re below him

    Us vs. them mentality. Frankly, I’m sick of it. The political season is full of it.

    These are the people who get shot by police. These are the people liberals of all races harbor unqualified sympathy for.

    By people, he means black people. If he were just describing people who act like D’Angelo (He sees them as the same), he would make a much more convincing argument.

    I’ve studied police use-of-force for years and I never saw a case where a black man who got shot didn’t resist in some fashion or cause some other problem.

    I’m at least willing to concede this is more often the case than the opposite.

    But police don’t have that luxury. They have to deal with him.

    Exactly. Which is why this should never have happened if they were doing there job.

    I once heard a police officer admonish applicants by telling them that if they don’t have a thick skin, they’re in for a rude awakening on the job.

    Try ministry. Got to be ever worse when the people pretend to love you.

    The Left had managed to beatify one of the most vile characters that had existed in our society (Regarding Michael Brown and George Floyd)...But when it comes to black people? We turn them into mythical figures, an indelible part of our national story.

    I believe this is his strongest argument. This seems to happen a lot with black people. But that is not a black race problem, but more with how the left treats it.

    All I can say is, show me your heroes and I’ll show you your future.

    Again, he’s not wrong. But this is not limited to race. There are numerous white people who honor Marx, Lenin. Plenty of Chinese still honor Mao. I would argue these 3 are significantly worse than Floyd.

    He’s literal human trash, but we’re not allowed to criticize him in even the mildest sense.

    I feel like this is true, but again not limited to black people (though they may receive the most benefit from it). It’s certainly true for people who are not male, heterosexual, Christian, and white.

    If your response is something to the effect of “he’s just a crazy person” or “there are White people like that too,” you’re failing the test and there’s probably no hope for you.

    Ah, so I must agree with you or I’m wrong…. Or maybe, you’re just failing to make your case. You and I agree there is a problem and perhaps black people as a whole are largely at the center of it, but so far I find your case for it being a race issue far from convincing.

    Yet only one race has a disproportionate number of awful, crazy people.

    There are some stats to back up that one race has a problem the others don’t seem to have, but cultural issues are better explanations than being born with a certain pigment.

    If you ever run into D’Angelo out in public and you successfully defend yourself against him, oh boy – be prepared for an onslaught of character assassination and public condemnation, maybe even criminal charges.

    I’ve made it 43 years so far. My church is 40% black. I like my odds. That’s not to say I don’t have concerns of cancel culture, I just try to live in a stronger Christian one.

    By the way, if any White liberals think a White person acting in the same manner as D’Angelo would’ve been treated any better, they should go down to the nearest police station, pull the same stunt, and see what happens.

    Watch those sovereign citizen videos. They are overwhelmingly white. He’s right here in that it would not work out for them.

    The reality of race in America, the way our society turns a blind eye to the black community’s failures, the double-standards, our failure to be honest about it all,

    I agree…

    and how the outrage which should be directed towards them is instead re-directed towards Whites, how every single one of us, immigrants included, are at the mercy of merciless, feral, and uncivilized blacks like D’Angelo, made me question and reject this whole dumb experiment.

    Mostly agree, but again this has more to do with how the black race is coddled by the left and the media. There are plenty of black people rejecting and speaking out about it (Sensurrounding Q being one of them). It is not an indictment of black people. They are not a monolith.

    Still, no other group puts me on alert like black people do.

    There is some truth to that. I think some famous black person in his old age said the same. But I’m guessing this has more to do with your prejudice than anything.

    Again, why do we let such awful, useless people dictate how we should live our lives?

    Again, true, but this is true about the bottom 2%, which is a white majority in America.

    The cold hard fact is this – you can’t fully integrate a group of people with an average IQ of 85 into a society created by people with an average IQ of 100. That is one standard deviation of difference. Because of that gap, the black minority will always lag behind the dominant European group.

    Average IQ by race in America.
    Asian Americans: Frequently average around 103 to 106 (with specific subgroups varying).

    White Americans: Centered at a baseline of 100.

    Hispanic / Latino Americans: Typically average roughly 89 to 95, depending on the specific national or ethnic breakdown.

    Black / African American: Historically average around 82 to 85 in traditional broad-sample assessments.

    So he’s right on the number. There is a genetic component to having a high IQ, but studies show IQ is determined by growth, nutrition, development, money, parent involvement, social status, and good decision-making. Those issues are largely cultural.

    Ever tried talking to a stupid person of any race? You can’t get through to them.

    You’re undercutting your argument here.

    Look at it like this – Jews in Europe had everything taken from them during World War II, during the Holocaust. Within a generation or two, Jews were back to being among the most productive, wealthiest members of society. If we’re all truly equal, then what’s black people’s excuse?

    I’m not a WW2 or Post War Expert, but I expect it has more to do with giving them a chance to thrive on their own and not constantly coddling them. We literally put them in another country and said “figure it out.” What would our country look like if it didn’t have DEI policies or Affirmative Action? I don’t know, and neither does the writer.

    The fact is, black people are simply not invested in a long-term relationship with anyone else. They can barely manage affairs in their own community.

    I don’t think this is true and my experience has told me its not. I do know my very good friend (he’s black) has pointed out that black people as a whole are holding themselves back. They are told to only look out for the whole. He used an example of a wealthy black person giving a talk in front of a black community. The man was talking about how they needed to change as a whole, and the people called him an Uncle Tom. Genetics don’t breed that way of thinking; culture does.

    Which brings me to Halsey.

    I don’t want to say too much about Halsey. I know a girl like Halsey. She drove her black husband crazy to the point that he divorced her. That’s also a cultural problem that seems to plague white liberal women. Maybe we should treat them the same as the author attempts to treat black people? I say this in jest, but he’s about to argue it.

    Many White liberals have very little firsthand experience with black people, however.

    He’s not wrong here. They tend to be more racist in there thinking, but they see it as good racism.

    Meanwhile, that racist White conservative down South? He shares a community with black people. He worked with them. He even went fishing and hunting with them. Served in the military with them.

    And its because of that, he knows they are not a monolith. He knows there are good ones and bad. It’s because he still choices to live there, work there and socialize with them. You undercut your argument again.

    Confronting the black problem in America means also confronting the White liberal problem.

    They do seem to go hand in hand. The word “problem” is doing a lot of work here. I might rephrase it as “the problem plaguing black people.”

    There’s no solution to the black problem in America. None. Nada.

    Well, I guess if you say so.

    For one, we can’t even acknowledge there’s a problem, or what the real problem actually is.

    Seems like this would be a step towards fixing it. It’s AA. The first step to recovering is admitting (correctly) there is a problem.

    For two, blacks cannot succeed and thrive on their own.

    The fact that plenty of black do is proof enough.

    For three, blacks themselves don’t want to get along with anyone.

    See point two.

    They just want to be able to beat America over the head with their problems.

    As a whole we need to move on from slavery, reconstruction, and Jim Crow. Plenty are choosing to. It’s some like Obama that keep forcing us two steps back.

    That’s easier and more fun, anyway.

    Um…no? Maybe for some, but if they hate it, then they want to improve it. For the most part it looks like they are trying to improve it.

    For four, as long as White liberals like Halsey are around to throw themselves onto the bodies of their angry, retarded black boyfriends, there’ll always be someone standing in the way of what needs to be done with these savages who don’t belong in any civilized society.

    I see you’re working towards that solution you just told me doesn’t exist.

    So, yeah. I’m tired. I’m tired of pretending.

    He has 3 paragraphs of this. 272 words! I’m tired of reading this thing.

    To that point, people often argue “It is not race, it is culture.” To that I would say, at what point specifically can you separate a race from its culture?

    This might be his second strongest point and where I think the disconnect comes from. We treat them as the same. We capitalize Black. We believe they can only vote democrat. Assuming every Black person grew up in an urban neighborhood. Saying someone is “acting Black” because they use certain slang. Assuming every black person will feel more comfortable around people of the same race, regardless of shared interests or experiences. But these are cultural differences. A black person living in KC probably loves BBQ and Patrick Mahomes. The same black person living in Argentina most likely loves Asado and Lionel Messi. In Canada: Connor McDavid and Poutine. Portugal: Francesinha and Christian Renaldo. All cultural differences that they likely share with any white, brown, or Asian person living in the same area.

    No other group fails the way the black community fails.

    There is truth to this. But all of those reasons can go back to cultural differences.

    Finally, I’m tired of pretending there’s a political solution for this. There isn’t. No other group fails the way the black community fails. This simply cannot be blamed on the system anymore. What Pete North says about the situation in his country can be applied to the problem of blacks in the U.S.:

    Missed one. Add another paragraph and 53 more words to the “I’m tired” phase of this rant.

    Their only other avenue is organised crime.

    Thought the Italians had a lock on this. Joking aside, I wonder if he would consider that racist?

    How many jobs would you trust someone like D’Angelo to perform?

    You are who you are on your best day and you are who you are on your worst. Most of us don’t live in the extremes. With that in mind, I’m sure he’s quite capable of doing many jobs.

    You cannot expect the genetically stupid to do much more than the simplest of tasks, and even that often proves too much to ask.

    You expose yourself, sir. Somehow, I don’t think this bothers you.

    I want to say that I know there are good black people out there. I’ve known them. I stand by them. They stand by me.

    More proof you undercut your argument. If it was race, then these people wouldn’t exist.

    To be frank, I’m not sure it’s even black people I reserve my greatest contempt for.

    I think you’re almost there.

    It be for the people who ought to know better, but don’t, and suck down the ideology of race in America
    You’re so close.

    As for Halsey, two of four charges were dropped, she plead no contest to the other two, paid over a thousand dollars in fines, plus many more in legal fees, and is back among the general population.

    Would this be evidence for systemic racism?

    Anyway, rant over. What did you think about this incident involving this toxic couple?

    I think they need a lot of work. They are in no way indicative of their race or gender. Maybe their culture, though. Maybe they are just terrible people outside of race, gender, and culture. Maybe they are just normal people having a bad day. This rant says more about you than it does about them.

    • I still don’t understand the basis of their complaint. Was D’Angelo arrested for running a stop sign that wasn’t there? How would that work? Was it a new stop sign that he rolled past because he hadn’t been paying attention? Is he trying to argue the stop sign shouldn’t be there? Do the police in that jurisdiction have any authority over such things?

  5. There are hundreds and hundreds of police body camera videos online that show a multitude of socially corrupted morons (black, white, male, female, adult, teenagers) that end up getting arrested because they’re doing something that’s damned stupid, drunk driving, trafficking drugs, physically fighting officers, resisting with or without violence, or investigation obstruction. There are loads of these morons can’t, or won’t, stop their pie hole from spewing utter nonsense that they firmly believe is fact, like the guy in the video above, but it’s usually just hate filled, race baiting nonsense. The worst of the worst are openly racist morons and won’t stop their lips from flapping long enough to hear anything a police officer is trying to say.

    We have social justice warriors in my neck of the woods that fight tooth and nail against area police officers having body cameras because they know for a fact that well over 90% of the time the recorded videos of police and civilians show the officers actions are correct and the arrested morons are dead wrong. All these body camera videos are accessible via FOIA requests, that’s how they end up on YouTube channels like Sheriff Lamb, Bodycam Files, Midwest Safety (the video above), Sergeant Curtis, etc. Some of these bodycam videos are narrated and picked apart by actual retired or off duty police officers.

    P.S. Some of the videos on the YouTube channels I mentioned above can be quite entertaining but mostly they show what police have to deal with on a routine basis.

  6. If you want proof, consider this.

    Americans of Japanese descent are among the most law abiding populations in the U.S.. The miurrder rate among them is lower than the murder rate in western Europe (the peer countries gun control activists like to compare us to)

    Contrast with the behavior of Japanese people in 1930’s Nanking.

    • What are you trying to proof? The behavior of the Japanese Army in Nanking showed a cultural problem in the army related to the concept of bushido, which is the traditional moral and ethical code that governed the samurai class in feudal Japan. So we cannot separate these war crimes from Japan.

      The behavior of the black dude in the video is a cultural issue to, located primarily in the African American population. That means that we cannot simply say that we need to leave race out of it as it only relates to culture. Culture has a location. Race and culture interact. Consider rap music and ghetto culture.

  7. <blockquote>To that point, people often argue “It is not race, it is culture.” To that I would say, at what point specifically can you separate a race from its culture?</blockquote>

    I’d say it’s the point at which two people from two different races walk into a police station together, demonstrating the same belligerence, the same invincible ignorance, in short the same culture.

Leave a Reply