One infamous passage certainly sounds like it comes from Jill. Incredibly, whoever Joe’s mouthpiece is expresses indignation that his descent into incoherence during his infamous debate with Donald Trump led to him being forced out of the 2024 race. “[E]very other President was given the chance to redeem themselves in a second debate,” the book says. Uh, yeah, that’s because no other President 1) was so widely believed to be loosing brain cells at the speed of light; 2) had been periodically photographed looking lost and disoriented at public events, and 3) those other Presidents who had poor debates never said anything remotely similar to “Making sure that we’re able to make every single solitary person . . . eligible for what I’ve been able to do with the uh, with the COVID, excuse me, with um dealing with everything we have to do with uh. Look, if we finally beat Medicare.”
“I wasn’t living in a dream world,” Biden” writes. “I believed I was the best person to lead the world.” He also may have believed that he was Marie of Rumania, Rin Tin Tin, or Zontar from the Planet Smung, depending on his medication mix.
The New Yorker’s Amy Davidson Sorkin, in “Joe Biden Is Still in Denial/The former President had it in him to write a great book about the loss of his powers as he aged. ‘Promise Me, America’ is not that book”, actually writes in her review of these fake memoirs that Biden “had it in him to write a great book about the loss of his own powers as he aged, and how it led him to lash out at people… who said what they saw, and at allies who loved him but knew that he was done…. That this memoir is not that book is a literary as well as a political tragedy….”
There is absolutely no evidence at all that Joe Biden ever has had it in him to write a great book, and a mountain of evidence that even if he once did (which is flamingly unlikely) he certainly hasn’t had it “in him” for a very long time. And yet reporters maintain the lie anyway.
The ethics verdict here is that calling a book that was not actually written by its subject an “autobiography” or “memoirs” is dishonest, a misrepresentation, and unethical. Claiming ghostwritten memoirs were written by the subject all by himself or herself is worse, and pretending memoirs that couldn’t possibly have been authored by the subject were is insulting to the public’s intelligence and the most unethical of all.
_________________
Pointer: Althouse.
Great post, my wife and I were discussing this yesterday.
Hmmmm, wondering if Hunter Biden included any of his “art” for this “project”?
Wasn’t the last President to actually write a book Theodore Roosevelt?
Teddy was a prolific historian and wrote between 35 and 47 books during his lifetime, depending on how you count multi-volume sets and co-authored works. He’s the most prolific POTUS author, but Jimmy Carter wrote over 30 books, all on his own. Ike authored his own memoirs. Taft wrote 9 books…he could write, and Wilson was a professor before going into politics. He would have written a memoir if not for his stroke, but wrote 9 scholarly works before the Presidency.
He’d probably have to read it to decide if he had written it…and I’m not too sure he’s even up to that.
Looks like poor old Joe isn’t even going to be able to cobble together funding for a presidential library. Supposedly, there’s barely even any mention of Slojo in Obama’s grotesque temple to himself…You would think Barack could spare a closet.
(Would it be ethical or just cruelly hilarious for Trump to offer to build Joe a library?)
If he did offer to build it, would he go the extra mile and try to get his name on it?
“The Joe Biden Library, created by the best, most accomplished, supreme, and totally awesome Donald Trump”?
I don’t know, might be a bit far fetched…
I was thinking more along the lines of “The TRUMP Library given to Crooked Joe Biden (because he couldn’t afford it)”.
Chances are equally good that chimpanzees wrote Gone with the Wind.
Joe Biden was never President. If he actually won the 2020 election, highly doubtful, it was Obama who became the de facto President as they had always planned.