List Incompetence Again: Variety’s “100 Greatest Movie Stars”

  • Henry Fonda is last on the list. Last. Variety highlights “Twelve Angry Men,” which was ignored for most of Hank’s career. Fonda was at the head of more classics and more varied fare than at least two-thirds of the actors on the list: “The Lady Eve,” a screwball comedy; “Young Mr. Lincoln,””Mister Roberts,” my favorite of his roles; Ford’s “My Darling Clementine,” “The Grapes of Wrath,” “Once Upon a Time in the West,” proving he could play a vicious villain,”Fail Safe,” many World War II roles, including Theodore Roosevelt Jr. in “The Longest Day,” and of course his last movie, “On Golden Pond.” His less talented and more obnoxious daughter Jane is rated ahead of him, which even she would find objectionable.

See, I wrote too much already. This list pisses me off: Variety’s callow staff should show some damn respect. Watch some movies.

  • Marilyn Monroe is #1. Quick, name three MM movies. (The two most likely to come to mind are “Some Like It Hot” and “The Seven Year Itch,” and she was just a supporting actress in the first one.)
  • What are foreign movie stars like Toshiro Mifune doing on the list at all? In his few U.S. films, the Japanese star was dubbed: in “Midway,” he was dubbed by Paul Fries, the same voice actor who played Boris Badinov in “Rocky and Bullwinkle. One foreign actor who is regarded by many as the greatest of all time, Sir Lawrence Olivier, is not on the list; neither is Alec Guinness, Charles Laughton or Richard Burton.
  • Meanwhile, no Peter Sellers, no Mickey Rooney (greatest male child star ever), no Charlton Heston (incredible), and again, no Bing Crosby, just to mention some of the more ridiculous omissions. Instead we get Zandaya, Whoopie Goldberg, Emma Stone (seriously?), Lillian Gish (did they pick her name out of a hat filled with the names of forgotten silent movie stars?), and…wait for it…Divine, who is best known for eating dogshit on screen. I guess she would qualify as trans today, so that means she must have been wonderful.
  • Shirley Temple was sui generis, the greatest child star by far, an icon, freakishly charismatic, a cultural touchpoint, imitated to this day, and we will never see her like again…and she ranks only 47th behind silent star Rudolph Valentino, who is virtually forgotten.
  • Making Fred Astaire share 41st place with Ginger Rogers is an insult and shows, again, ignorance and laziness. Fred is an icon by himself, belonging in the top ten. Many of his best numbers were solos (like “Drum Crazy” in “Easter Parade”) and some of his best partnered dances weren’t with Ginger (such as the sublime “Dancing in the Dark” with Cyd Charisse.)
  • The list is marred by DEI stunts. Yes, Sidney Poitier belongs, but #5 is absurd: ahead of Cary Grant, often cited as the ultimate movie star? Poitier’s best three movies were within a bit more than single year’s time, and he had no range at all. Grant excelled in many genres, and remains the best looking star ever, maybe the best looking man who ever lived. Too bad he was white. The list’s including Whoopie, Pam Grier (who couldn’t act), and especially Dorothy Dandridge (name her biggest hit, please) is nonsense.
  • I checked the list three times because I couldn’t believe Frank Sinatra was missing. And Elvis is is #61! He was a dud on film if he wasn’t singing; Frank and Bing could act, won Oscars, and sold as many records as Elvis. None of his movies could be called “good”: the Beatles made a better movie than any of Elvis’s.
  • The list includes the Marx Brothers, but snubs Martin and Lewis, Abbott and Costello and Laurel and Hardy, all of which were as iconic and as successful on screen. Which team has the single most famous film routine? You get one guess. Bob Hope and Jerry Lewis didn’t make the cut, and if comedy stars count, and they do, they should have.
  • Orson Welles was a star director. He was never a box office star as an actor.
  • I’ll end with the obligatory note that listing John Wayne at only #19, behind Clint Eastwood, a contemporary equivalent but nowhere near as important in film and cultural history, Barbra Streisand (great singer, not a top 100 movie star) and worst of all, James Dean, who made just three films and whose scenery-chewing method acting has not aged well, is unconscionable. The Duke made more classics than anyone on the list except James Stewart, who is also under-ranked at #28. Both Jimmy and John Wayne belong in the top 10. I could make a persuasive argument that Wayne should be #1.

I’ll stop now; I’m getting nauseous.

Leave a Reply