Ethics Quote of the Month: Andrew Sullivan

Any belief will do, if all you care about is pursuing power for one political party. And for much of his career, that party was the GOP. But more than that, Kristol was central to pushing it further and further to the right.

He wasn’t just a neoconservative; he was a believer in Cheney-style executive supremacy, with the Congress irrelevant in war-making. He wasn’t just anti-abortion, but a believer that “challenging the judicially imposed regime of abortion-on-demand is key to a conservative reformation in politics, in morals, and in beliefs.” Ending Roe was his supreme and urgent goal, back when it seemed impossible. He was not just against Hillarycare; he wanted to kill it and offer no alternative. His affect was a kind of above-it-all, vaguely amused world-weariness, but it merely distracted from the fact he was on the radical right.

It was a good gig until Trump arrived, which was when Kristol instantly knew his days were numbered as a GOP insider. What to do? If you had any actual, you know, beliefs, you could go into the wilderness for a while, criticize Trump and the GOP, think through where you went wrong, rally conservatives against him so far as you could, etc. But if you are Bill Kristol, you’re bereft. He was never interested in ideas as such, just how to use ideas to gain power. But what happens if you have no party left to gain power with? The answer was simple, if a little tough to pull off credibly: become a Democrat!

And so he has. And the contrasts with his previous policy positions are quite staggering…He went from declaring the overturning of Roe the sine qua non of a conservative future to urging a Democrat to use the end of Roe to gin up support. He went from dismissing the need to get Congressional support for the Iraq War to this about the war in Iran in 2026: “our elected officials have an obligation not to sit by while a wannabe King plunges us deeper into an unwise and unconstitutional war.”

How do you go from “free markets” to endorsing a “New New Deal”? From a Likud-supporting neocon constantly on the alert for antisemitism to endorsing Zohran Mamdani? How do you go from constitutionalism to supporting the idea of packing the court for the left: “Let’s be ruthless.” How do you go from curing gays to supporting trans activists?…He is an apparatchik, not a thinker, a cynical operative. And his magazine, staffed with fellow operatives, is ready and waiting to serve their new client, the Dems, with whatever they want or need. (The one principled thinking conservative in their crew, Charlie Sykes, rightly quit as the shamelessness spread.) And many Beltway Democrats (who also believe in nothing) are so flattered by this hack’s cynical support, they’re happy to let bygones be bygones, without so much as an explanation, let alone an apology…

Bingo.

Leave a Reply