Unlikely Ethics Hero of the Year: Alexandria (VA) DMV

Departments of Motor Vehicles everywhere are justly derided for terrible service: inefficient, sloooow, impersonal, and often surly. Disney’s “Zootopia” scored a classic scene (above) in which a DMV was shown to be staffed entirely by sloths. I have a busy day today on both the compensated and pro bono ethics fronts, and dreaded what I was sure to encounter this morning as I had to renew my driver’s license in person, because for various reasons I was not eligible for the on-line renewal process.

Believe it or not, my DMV appointment was at 9:30 am, and I walked out of the office with my temporary license at 9:46. In that 16 minutes, I moved through the check-in line in a trice. My number was called before I left the check-in desk. The cheerful and attentive DMV staffer at my assigned window administered my vision test, took my photo, directed me through the forms I had to fill out and sign, and arranged my payment with dispatch. Not only have I never interacted with the DMV in such a pleasant and streamlined fashion, I don’t think I’ve interacted with any government service, including a post office, so easily in my entire life.

OK, she was wearing a mask. I confess, I find that annoying, especially since it was a paper mask, which we all know (don’t we?) is virtually useless. She was young, so I doubt that she was immunocompromised. She was also Asian, however, and I know Asians are especially fond of masking up; she was, of course, female in Northern Virginia, so odds are that the mask was a statement, “I am a Democrat, I support Dr. Fauci and Wuhan fearmongering, and I am therefor a good non-Republican who all of you other woke saints can count me as one of you. Gooble Gorble.” I also could barely hear her through the mask and the thick glass at the window, and while the rest of her face suggested that she was returning my smiles, I couldn’t be sure.

But I digress.

The Alexandria DMV has vastly improved its processes and service, as well as its staff training and supervision. It didn’t have to, after all. We have no choice but to accept the service the give us.

There is hope.

“Zootopia” Is Unethical—But Funny!

I think you should see “Zootopia,” and maybe even let your children see it, provided that you are prepared to spend about two hours deprogramming them afterwards. Thus you may not want to read further unless you want to encounter numerous spoilers.

Children’s stories, TV shows and movies have long been the vehicle for moral and ethical messages, as well as allegories that may or may not worm themselves into unsuspecting juvenile psyches. Because there are young minds involved, engaging in what can be value-warping and indoctrination if not handled with proper humility and care is a high calling, and for the most part, Disney has always been up to the task.

I like Disney animated movies, and always have. I even like some of the flops, like “Treasure Planet.” Pixar, which is now part of the Disney creative empire, has been even more daring and aggressive in ethics story-telling, and has not seriously abused the privilege. Other studios, like DreamWorks, have been more heavy-handed in their moralizing. No animated film in memory, however, has set out to pound specific political and social points of view into the brains of kids as blatantly, relentlessly and ambitiously as “Zootopia.”

I should add “incompetently.” Like all fantasies with delusions of social significance, “Zootopia” relies on metaphors, and in this film, they become a tangle of confused and sometimes contradictory and hypocritical messages. Wrapped as they are in an often charming, funny, well-acted and well-plotted piece of technically expert art, these muddled messages approach being sinister. That the film has been almost universally praised—it has an amazing 98% positive rating on the review site “Rotten Tomatoes”—speaks either to a culture-wide conspiracy to turn the next generation into political correctness zombies, or to the mass incompetence of the film reviewing profession. Continue reading →