
This is what happened…
Less than a week after his undefeated team forfeited a playoff victory for using an ineligible player for 53 seconds of the game, Middletown (New York) High School football coach Tim Strenfel (above) resigned. (So did assistant football coach Isaac Cayetano, a bit later). Strenfel had been the team’s coach for ten years, but he put a kicker who was ineligible to play in any playoff games into one for eight plays. Though they lasted a less than a minute in total and had no effect on the final score, that mistake in the Section IX Class AAs play-offs wiped away his team’s perfect season, making its final record 9-1.
The player had been on the Middletown Boys Soccer team before joining the football team in the middle of the regular season. He was cleared to play in the regular season games but was ineligible for the play-offs because he was not on the team roster for the minimum three regular-season games. That rule is right in New York State Public High School Athletic Association guidelines. After the game, the coaches of the losing team, Newburgh Free Academy, learned about the ineligible player and registered a protest to Valley Central officials. Valley Central Athletics Director then reported the rules violation to Section IX officials, who decreed that Middletown had to forfeit the win.
Middletown challenged the disqualification through the athletic appeals process before taking the matter to Orange County Supreme Court last week. Following a nearly two-hour hearing, the district withdrew its petition once the judge indicated she would not reverse the forfeit.
Let the finger-pointing commence! (cont.)