The Ethics Question That Is Driving Me Crazy

I don’t like to poach advice columnist questions unless the columnist makes a mess of the answer. This is an exception, however. It is an ethics question like no other I have ever encountered, the ethics equivalent of Monty Python’s “killer joke.” It is driving me crazy.

The question came to Ariel Kaminer, the writer of the New York Times ethics advice column, “The Ethicist.” Kaminer is typically all over the map, and often makes simple ethics problems more complicated than they are, when she isn’t getting them wrong entirely. “The Ethicist” didn’t get this question wrong entirely, but she did write a long explanation that missed what was really remarkable about the question. The only answer that was absolutely required would have been, “WHAT???

Here’s the jaw-dropping question, from a student:

“My school charged a dollar for students to bet, or “predict,” which team would win the Super Bowl. It was $1 for one team, and if you won, you would get a candy bar. If you bet $3, you could choose both teams and guarantee your candy bar. Is this legal or even morally right?”


The school (Where is this school?) is not only promoting gambling, it is promoting crooked gambling, or, if you prefer, attempting outright theft. It is encouraging students to spend a dollar on a 50% chance to win something that costs about a dollar! In addition to being a scam, the school is either…

1. …teaching students to be stupid and gullible, or

2. .. intentionally taking advantage of students who are already stupid and gullible,

3. …using this as a diagnostic tool to identify which students are stupid and gullible so that they can be put into special classes, OR

3. …run by people who are themselves too stupid to realize how ridiculous and unfair this “contest” is.

But is it theft or a scam? The structure is obviously ridiculous, and so easily recognizable as such that one can hardly claim that the school is trying to deceive anyone.  It is not usually unethical to say, “Hey! Want to waste your money?” since the expected answer is “No.” Is it ethical for a school to ask that question? I don’t know. It is certainly a stupid question to ask.

The student’s question is even stranger, because it asks about a secondary option the school offers that is even more idiotic than the contest itself. The student asks, in effect, “Is it unethical or immoral for the school to make available a truly ridiculous option that no sane student would ever choose, paying three dollars to ensure a win that two dollars will suffice (betting a dollar on both teams) to guarantee, when a win is only worth about one dollar anyway?”  If this school is populated by the learning disabled, the brain-injured or the mentally ill, then yes, the school’s offer is unethical and despicable. Otherwise, it is just sad, and sadder still that the questioner has to write the New York Times to analyze it.

Sad, or frightening. The more I think about it, the more this question is driving me mad. A school devises an absurd and mathematically rigged gambling scam that everyone should laugh at. Why? A student takes it so seriously that he writes the New York Times for guidance. Why? And the Times “ethicist” answers with the solemnity of a rabbi! WHY??

What’s happening out there?

11 thoughts on “The Ethics Question That Is Driving Me Crazy

  1. Awww, Jack. This is just a fund raiser! Like a bake sale raffle. Besides, it prepares students to deal with the state lottery which, given the state of public schools these days, is their only hope of making the magic 1%. Anyway, what do dumb kids need with money at their age, when so many deserving teachers need it for their union dues?

    • If it’s a fundraiser, why have candy bar prizes? Why not a raffle? Why pretend its a football pool? Obviously it will raise funds, but the pretense that it is gambling makes no sense! I’M GETTING UPSET!!!!

  2. Ha! You are not getting me this time. I recognize that name. No link reading for me. I wonder how many students figured out they only needed to spend 2$ to guarantee their candy bar. Or if the school didn’t allow two bets per student.

  3. This is actually a civics lesson. It is training the students to grow up to be good citizens and buy their state lottery tickets. Special, today only! 1 ticket for $1 or 2 for $3. Remember, lotteries are good. They help education.

    Opps, got a little sarcasm on my chin on that one. I really don’t know what to make of this. I am really afraid the students, teachers, and administrators involved thought this was a good idea. Most teachers don’t do simple math very well and are easily misled by statistics.

  4. This story makes me sick, also. What the heck is this school thinking?! It probably is a fundraiser … but the premise is so misguided there’s no “teachable moment” left! One has to HOPE it wasn’t a faculty member who came up with the idea. MAYBE, just MAYBE it was a student or parent organization who came up with the idea and it wasn’t properly vetted by a faculty advisor before the students were told about it. Still bad, but not QUITE as bad.

  5. Pingback: The Ethics Question That Is Driving Me Crazy | Ethics Alarms « Ethics Find

  6. Sure its unethical… its illegal. In CA its called “pool selling” or more commonly, bookmaking. And its a felony. (337A CPC, et seq). I’m guessing this particular event is in New York, hence the inquiry to the NYT.

    The structure of the amount of the wager against the maximum win creates a scenario where the party selling the chances (to predict) is guaranteed to profit. Not knowing how gambling law in NY is structured, this may or may not make a difference there. And it is another wrinkle to the idea that the state lottery is a tax on the mathematically impaired.

  7. Forget about the gambling: Wait till the Fatists get wind of the prize being candy and not a carrot or apple. Haven’t they banned cupcakes and other treats in school?

  8. surely you can see through this. The person pays an extra dollar to avoid any chance of not winning. It’s the same reason even losing teams now get a trophy. God forbid they may have to endure some ego bruiser.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.