Once Again, Stop Making Me Defend President Trump, And Tell Fox To Stop Making Me Defend The People Who Are MAKING Me Defend Him!


See? What does Comey have to complain about?

Fred, my topic scout, sent me this and suggested that it was the apotheosis of  Rationalization #22, Comparative Virtue or “It’s not the worst thing.”

Boy, was he right.

In last night’s episode of the Tucker Carlson show—right-wingers are actually impressed with Tucker’s skills at taking down lame liberal fanatics, which is sad in so many ways—featured the Fox News conservative dilettante agreeing with guest James Rosen, who was making the fatuous and ethically offensive point that people shouldn’t get so upset about what Trump does because the Civil War and the Cold War were worse.

This argument is the Mother of All Terrible Rationalizations, and especially bad because it spoils a good point, which is that absent historical perspective, it’s not easy to know what a real crisis is. Arguing that people shouldn’t object to something, however, because something else was worse is the mark of desperation as well as intellectual deficiency. Explain why the alleged crisis isn’t one (as in the Comey firing); explain why the assumed harm is exaggerated, or being hyped, or the product of bias and emotion. But to say, as Rosen, a “conservative historian,” which only means he isn’t an aggressive leftist like almost all of his colleagues, did,

“During Watergate, the term ‘crisis’ was thrown around as well and there were people at that time who were old enough to remember when there were legless Civil War veterans still in the streets of Washington.”

And I’m sure conservative historians were reminding those Civil War casualties while their legs were being sawed off without anesthesia that the Civil War wasn’t nearly as horrible as the Black Death. “Ah, I feel much better now,” they smiled. “Just call me ‘Stumpy!’

Here, for the sake of reference, is the description of #22 on the Ethics Alarms Rationalizations List:

22. The Comparative Virtue Excuse: “There are worse things.”

If “Everybody does it” is the Golden Rationalization, this is the bottom of the barrel. Yet amazingly, this excuse is popular in high places: witness the “Abu Ghraib was bad, but our soldiers would never cut off Nick Berg’s head” argument that was common during the height of the Iraq prisoner abuse scandal. It is true that for most ethical misconduct, there are indeed “worse things.” Lying to your boss in order to goof off at the golf course isn’t as bad as stealing a ham, and stealing a ham is nothing compared selling military secrets to North Korea. So what? We judge human conduct against ideals of good behavior that we aspire to, not by the bad behavior of others. One’s objective is to be the best human being that we can be, not to just avoid being the worst rotter anyone has ever met.

Behavior has to be assessed on its own terms, not according to some imaginary comparative scale. The fact that someone’s act is more or less ethical than yours has no effect on the ethical nature of your conduct. “There are worse things” is not an argument; it’s the desperate cry of someone who has run out of rationalizations.

Incidentally, one of the most prominent peddlers of #22 is Donald Trump, as when he argues that waterboarding is nowhere near as bad as what terrorists do to their prisoners. Please don’t listen to him when he does this. See what that kind of thinking has done to James Rosen and Tucker Carlson?

It’s not only bias that makes us stupid. Presidents can make you stupid too.


Pointer: Fred


Filed under Ethics Alarms Award Nominee, Government & Politics, History, Journalism & Media, Professions

20 responses to “Once Again, Stop Making Me Defend President Trump, And Tell Fox To Stop Making Me Defend The People Who Are MAKING Me Defend Him!

  1. Welllllllllll your Vlad picture there DOES put the danger that bureacrats are in under Trump in some perspective.

    And your “Just call me Stumpy!” line would have made me spit up my coffee if I hadn’t already finished drinking it. So there’s that.

    Comedy, another reason to come here.

  2. “And I’m sure conservative historians were reminding those Civil War casualties while their legs were being sawed off without anesthesia that the Civil War wasn’t nearly as horrible as the Black Death.”

    Don’t like that at all. I would assume someone would say “not nearly as bad as perpetuating the servitude and destruction of four million human beings. Thank you for your sacrifice.”

  3. John Billingsley

    Actually, about 95% of Civil War surgery was done under anesthesia. When anesthesia wasn’t used, it was usually because the patient was critically wounded and unconscious or in the case of the South because the blockade had limited the supply. Chloroform, discovered in 1832, was most commonly used but ether first used in 1846 was sometimes used. Ether being extremely flammable was not safe to use around kerosene lamps and also took longer to work. For relief of pain after amputation, forms of opium were used. Many soldiers became addicted and after the war opium addiction became known as the soldier’s disease. The soldiers probably rationalized, “Sure they call me “Stumpy” but just think how much worse getting your leg sawed off was during the Revolutionary War. Pass me the laudanum.”

    • See, they only reminded the soldiers who didn’t get anesthesia about the Black Plague. I should have been clearer…

      • John Billingsley

        One of my ancestors, Dr. Claiborne J. Walton, was a surgeon with the 21st Ky Volunteer Infantry. In a letter to his wife from Kennesaw Mountain in 1864 he began, “I am sick. Yes sick and tired of the bloodshed.” Sherman was right, with or without anesthesia, “War is cruelty.”

  4. I cannot resist…

    Presidents can make you stupid too.

    Common core?

  5. Other Bill

    “The Fox News conservative dilettante”. Amen. Also heir to the Swanson Frozen Foods fortune and non-college graduate. But he has a nice head of hair and wears a bow tie. So he’s got that going for him. Which is nice.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.