Which Presidents Would Have Tweeted Trump-Style If They Had A Twitter Account?

The tweet above from the President as he doubled down on his unusually stupid attack tweets against Joe and Mika got me thinking. He’s not entirely wrong. Trump is the first President to use social media personally and for candid statements and observations, bypassing the news media, and almost all of the previous Presidents had no choice in the matter. Fourth of July weekend always gets me thinking about the Founders, and the Founders get me musing about the Presidents, and I found myself playing this mind game: Which of our Presidents, had they has access to Twitter, would have used it in a Trumpian manner?

I should clarify some issues at the outset. None of the Presidents would have used Twitter in a stupid, juvenile and boorish manner like President Trump, because none of them were that stupid, juvenile and boorish. (On the other hand, none of their critics, being comparatively responsible and sane, would have argued that stupid, juvenile and boorish tweets were justification to remove the previous 44, as Keith Olbermann thinks.) By using Twitter in a Trumpian manner, I mean using it…

..Personally…

…for the purpose of by-passing the news media and White House spokespersons…

…in order to make declarations of intent, emotions or satisfaction, or

…to attack, accuse, denigrate, compliment, rebut, defend, joke, troll, or otherwise

…communicate directly with the public.in an unfiltered manner.

One other caveat: Trump would definitely be establishing new Presidential norms were his tweets less obnoxious and embarrassing. By the time his term(s) are over, he mat have given Presidential tweeting such a bad reputation that no future POTUS will dare use Twitter for fear of being compared to the Mad Tweeter of 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.

All right, on to the inquiry!

Which of our previous Presidents would have used twitter in one or more of the ways Trump uses it. based on what we know of their character and leadership styles?

George Washington: Never. A man with a keen understanding of leadership and naturally reticent, George would have regarded such casual and informal communication diminishing, intrinsically rude, and a great mistake. He wouldn’t be wrong.

John Adams: I’m pretty sure Adams would be a twitter abuser. He would be more articulate and restrained than Trump, of course—who wouldn’t?—but John seethed with resentment, felt that he was badly treated by the press, and tweeting out insults and defenses would be irresistible to our second President. The 140 character limit would be a problem.

Thomas Jefferson is an interesting case. Tom was introverted except when pushing a pen. He loved words, and like Adams, often resented what others wrote about him. He would be a careful Twitter user, but a frequent one.

Madison, Monroe, John Quincy Adams: Unlikely. Madison and Monroe were too canny to show their thoughts to the world, and John Quincy Adams would find social media degrading.

Andrew Jackson, in contrast, would be a Twitter menace. The seventh President was a killer with words as much as with a pistol; he did not suffer fools or opponents gladly, and he would have welcomed the availability of making his fans cheer as he verbally accosted others.

Van Buren, W.H. Harrison, Tyler, Polk, Taylor and Millard Fillmore all seem unlikely Twitter users. Tyler might be the most likely of the batch: he was isolated, a Democrat heading a Whig administration, and he could be  a defiant and ornery statesman. Still, he was a Virginia country squire, like Washington, Madison and Monroe, and my guess is that tweeting would not be his style. Polk was a Jackson follower but completely unlike Jackson in style and temperament. He quietly planned and plotted, and maintained as low a profile as any successful (and ruthless) President in history. He would have viewed tweeting as pointless and counter-productive.

Franklin Pierce might have tweeted Trump-like bile, but only when he was drunk, which was often.

James Buchanan is a cypher. He was immensely intelligent, but devoid of leadership ability. His approach to every problem seemed to be what he called “restraint,” and he courted conflict by trying to avoid it. (The 15th President thought that the Dred Scot decision would settle the issue of slavery, for example.) I have no sense of whether he would have resorted to tweeting as all sides turned against him.

Abraham Lincoln, one of the handful of bona fide political geniuses we have had as President, would have certainly used Twitter as a political tool, and would have used it brilliantly—for jokes, witticisms, pin-point rebuttals of his critics and cagey spin.

Andrew Johnson would have undoubtedly been one of the most Trump-like tweeters. Insecure, over his head, impulsive, choleric, as his war with the Radical Republicans became more personal and vicious and the national press turned against him, he would have used Twitter as a final, desperate, futile tactic to build public support.

Ulysses Grant was the Hemingway of Presidents, which would have made him a Twitter auteur, but I greatly doubt that he would have used it. Grant was neither outgoing nor politically astute, and was insecure enough that he would avoid the intimacy of candid tweets.

Rutherford B. Hayes may well have embraced tweeting. Hayes was  the first President to have a telephone in the White House, he first to use the typewriter, and he had Thomas Edison come to the White House to demonstrate the phonograph. He was forward-looking regarding new technology, and might have been equally bold with social media.

I can find no solid evidence that Garfield, Arthur, Benjamin Harrison or Grover Cleveland would have issued combative, humorous or strategic tweets. Perhaps Arthur would have tried tweeting to rally public support as he increasingly became a Man Without A Party by turning against crony politics and patronage. Harrison has no enthusiastic base to tweet to, and was a staid statesman. Cleveland was secretive and careful by nature (he had a lot of secrets to be careful with); perhaps he would have used Twitter during the Panic of 1893 and the resulting Depression to calm the public and the business sector. Grover was a talented leader, and a talented leader could use social media well in a crisis.

William McKinley would never have touched Twitter. This man never left his front porch to campaign: I can’t see him invading the nation’s Twitter accounts.

Theodore Roosevelt, in contrast, would have been a twittering maniac, probably to his detriment. Self-restraint was not one of Teddy’s virtues, and his verve in attacking political foes once got him sued for slander. The public loved him, he knew it, and as with Trump, even TR’s imprudent and impolitic tweets would get a lot of applause. Roosevelt thought he was smarter than the press, and would have loved a device that allowed him to get his point of view to the public without having to make a formal speech.

William Taft would not be a tweeter. He was judicious by nature, not outgoing, dignified and placid. He thought careful before he spoke, and would have believed that nothing of value or depth could be expressed in 140 characters

Woodrow Wilson is generally regarded as one of our most narcissistic Presidents (Teddy is #1). Professorial, pedantic, and doctrinaire, he might well have used twitter as a political weapon, particularly when he was battling the Senate to have the Treaty of Versailles ratified with the his baby, the League of Nations, included.

Warren G. Harding was a gregarious man, affable but not unusually smart, charismatic and shallow. Sure he would have tweeted. That’s almost the text book definition of a social media addict.

Calvin Coolidge..hmmm. The idea of Coolidge tweeting amuses me greatly. When this was a more ambitious effort, I was going to compose a theoretical tweet for each of the tweeting Chief Executives. Cal’s would be dry comments on re-tweets, like Glenn Reynold’s arch “Unexpectedly,” or  a sarcastic “Suuure” or a deadpan, lower case, “yay.

Herbert Hoover: no.

Franklin Delano Roosevelt would have used social media and twitter as deftly as he used radio. (As would Winston Churchill.)

Harry Truman? See John Adams, but without the nastiness. Harry would have loved Twitter, and his down-to earth observations and pronouncements would have probably made him popular enough that Dewey wouldn’t even have made the headlines.

Dwight D. Eisenhower was properly called the “hidden hand President,” and Twitter Trump-style is all bout showing your hand. The General  would abstain.

John F. Kennedy: No. Kennedy’s strength was in his mystique and personal charisma. He would not tweet.

Nor would LBJ. President Johnson was an old school politician, and remote contact was alien to him. He was a master of the phone call and  face-to-face arm-twisting. I can’t see him spending his time and energy on Twitter.

Richard M. Nixon would tweet to get around what he saw as a hostile press. I think he would be prone to going too far, too, but unlike Trump, Nixon had competent and trusted aides who would put a stop to his tweeting if it got out of hand.

Gerald Ford? Who would read his tweets? I can’t see it.

Jimmy Carter is a narcissist for sure, and Twitter attracts narcissists. He might have embraced Twitter as part of his “common man” persona.

Ronald Reagan was like Kennedy, great at playing President. As an actor, he would know the dangers of going off script. I think he’d eschew the risks of Twitter.

George H.W. Bush was not the most technologically savvy of our POTUSes to say the least, and not especially fond of public contact, either. I find it hard to believe that a man who was about a decade behind in his knowledge supermarket technical innovations would use Twitter in the White House. Wouldn’t be prudent…

Bill Clinton would have been a Twitter Jedi in office.

George W. Bush knew and knows his limitations, and off the cuff statements are among them. A certain Twitter abstainer.

And we know about Obama, who could have used Twitter for more than canned, ghost-written political pablum, but didn’t. I bet he wishes he had thought about its potential, but he needed the precedent.

Summing up, I think fourteen Presidents, Adams, Jefferson, Jackson, Lincoln, A. Johnson, Hayes, Teddy, Wilson, Coolidge, FDR, Truman, Nixon, Carter, and Clinton would have used Twitter for one or more Trumpish purposes had they had the opportunity.

None of them, however, would have embarrassed the office and the nation while doing so to the extent that President Trump does regularly.

35 Comments

Filed under Character, Etiquette and manners, Government & Politics, History, Leadership, Science & Technology, Social Media

35 responses to “Which Presidents Would Have Tweeted Trump-Style If They Had A Twitter Account?

  1. Interesting. I think you meant 1893 under “Cleveland”.

    • UGH! Did I say 1993? 1693? I’m afraid to look…

      • Really interesting analysis.

        I think Cal would use Twitter. I’m a fairly quiet and reserved person when talking. But I write/type far more detailed.

        He could easily be the same.

        • A.M. Golden

          I just finished a book on Coolidge and it does seem that, while he could be terse in simple communications, he did have the ability to write significantly. I’m not sure if he would use Twitter, but I absolutely agree that if anyone could communicate using only 140 characters, it would be him.

          • Yes, and Cal actually was pretty verbose on the radio. I still am amused by his mastering super-short and pithy tweets.

            By the way, what was the shortest telegram message ever sent, and who sent it?

            Hint: it was responded to with a message that tied the record for the shortest message.

  2. bexhrob

    Hamilton, never Prez, would have been vicious. I think Jefferson might have joined Twitter to go just as savagely back at him.

  3. JP

    These types of post are my favorite. The humor, wit, and thought makes it a good read.

  4. wyogranny

    None of them, however, would have embarrassed the office and the nation while doing so to the extent that President trump does regularly.

    I’m not sure about that. Given the same technology and political climate I think Andrew Jackson, Teddy Roosevelt, Carter and Clinton might have. The key character trait being acting before thinking, or acting with questionable/unknown tactical purpose.

  5. Steve Mc

    I think Obama erred on this one though.

  6. A.M. Golden

    “Herbert Hoover: no.”

    This makes me laugh, thank you very much.

    But I’ve been thinking a lot about Hoover lately, given his similarities to Trump (in that neither were career politicians – at least Hoover had been Sec of Commerce – and both had/have a poor relationship with the press). But I read a book recently about the Hoover administration and it does seem to me that Hoover might have recognized the ability of Twitter to get his ideas across without having to filter them through the press.

    • My guess is based on his personality, which was about as far from that of a politician as one could be. He was, as you know, and engineer, and a problem solver rather than a word-smith.

      Hoover was probably among our smartest Presidents, though not politically savvy. It’s kind of unfair to compare him to Trump, as he would have regarded DT as a buffoon.

      • A.M. Golden

        You are correct, of course. I just noticed certain similarities between them and extrapolated a bit further than necessary. Trump isn’t nearly the President Hoover was.

  7. crella

    My first thought on reading the title was “Teddy!” A very enjoyable article, Jack, thank you.

  8. Sue Dunim

    You didn’t include Emperor Norton on the list.

  9. valkygrrl

    George Washington Tweets

    Crazy @George3 thinks taxes are the answer, I know better! #MAG
    Just Crossed the Delaware and low enegry British never saw me, sad! #MAG
    Lying #MSM making up stories about cold and desertion at Valley Forge #fakenews
    Little @Cornwallis marching north, does this guy have anything better to do with his life? Only I can beat. #MAG

  10. We don’t know what any of our past Presidents would have done in regards to posting on Twitter if they were facing the same political environment as we are facing today. To say that they all would “tweet” differently is completely fair.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s