Ethics Quote Of The Week: Heather MacDonald [Expanded]

Swan Lake

“The destruction being carried on in this post-George Floyd moment cannot be overstated. Everything in the West’s cultural inheritance, whether in music, literature, or art, is coming down….Visual and kinetic uniformity in a corps de ballet was an aesthetic ideal; it, too, had nothing to do with race. Yet that uniformity must now fall so that no individual ballet dancer feels that her precious diversity currency is devalued.”

Social commentator Heather MacDonald, in her depressing report, “Beside the Pointe:
Diversity and bias obsessions come for ‘Swan Lake’

It’s a fascinating case study of how the George Floyd Freakout, combined with ruthless determination of minority activists to exploit that tragedy to grab power, and the utter failure of sniveling organization leaders to demonstrate the requisite spine that any institution requires in its leadership, is resulting in cultural carnage with few countervailing benefits.

The iceman cometh late for the weird world of classic ballet, as MacDonald, obviously a fan (I am not) points out:

Classical ballet has largely escaped the revisionist destruction that hit the opera and theater stages years ago. Amazingly, audiences could still see Swan Lake and La Bayadere as their choreographers and composers intended them, with all the conventions and costumes of nineteenth-century fairytale intact…. the adolescent politicizing that has been inflicted on defenseless operas has been absent from the ballet stage. That immunity has undoubtedly now ended. Expect to see classical ballets wrenched awkwardly into dumbshows about social justice.

Oh, I do, I do. She relates a race controversy from two years ago, when the Staatsballett Berlin mounted “Swan Lake,” in which white body paint has traditionally been used on the ballerinas to create the illusion that the dancers are swans. The company’s ballet mistress told the company’s one black dancer to use the body make-up like the rest of the dancers. When she protested that she’d never look white, the mistress responded, “Well, you will have to put on more than the other girls.”

I would have said, “I guarantee you will look exactly as much like a swan as anyone else on stage!'”

The episode was flagged as racist treatment of a black performer, and made headlines. The company groveled an apology, admitting that it was culprit in society’s “structural racism.” It promised to hire diversity trainers and hold mandatory antiracism workshops, as well as pledging to attempt to purge its repertory for “outdated and discriminatory ways of performing,” while “re-evaluat[ing]” its “longstanding traditions.” McDonald observes, and correctly,

The accusations and the self-prostration would have been the same had the scenario been flipped. If the ballet mistress had told the black dancer: “Don’t bother with the body paint. You’re too black. It will never work,” this, too, would have been characterized as discrimination. Racism today is a non-falsifiable proposition governed by the principle: heads I win, tails you lose.

Indeed. The latest ballet-related race-based power play came when that same black ballerina’s contract was not renewed for the coming season. Eleven white dancers were also let go, but only her fate could be blamed on racism, so racism it was. Says MacDonald,

“If a white person is dismissed, not hired, or not promoted, it is assumed to be for cause. If a black person suffers a negative employment outcome, the only reason must be racism.”

Eventually, the targets of this intensifying hustle will have to brace for the attacks to come and refuse to play the game. The ethics values at stake are fairness, responsibility and citizenship,, and the the activating virtues required are courage, fortitude and sacrifice.


Added: Heather MacDonald is usually not reticent about speaking plain, but she didn’t clearly make the point she was talking around.

Ballet is an art form that has everything to do about grace,symbolism, abstract beauty, geometric and aesthetic precision, escapism and beauty expressing music visually and viscerally. It has nothing to do with race. Achieving its artistic and entertainment goals often demand ethereal uniformity, as in the “Swan Lake” photo above. The perfect chorus, in many cases, should look like clones. There is nothing—nothing—wrong or unethical about that. Diversity is not always appropriate. Ballerinas, so matter how talented, are not assets to the artistic objectives of the ballet if they are six-feet tall, or five-foot-one. They are detrimental. Similarly, if the artistic effect desired is the uniformity above, there are a limited number of options. All the ballerinas can be white. They can all be black. The effect can be to have all white swans, and any black dancers have to use make-up to match the others. Or the effect can be to have all black swans, and any white dancers have to wear black—no, that’s not allowed, is it? The remaining options are not to do the work at all, as great and popular as it is, or to stage it in a manner that does not maximize the aesthetic virtues of the work, in order to meet a social engineering goal that has nothing to do with art.

The last two, the author is saying, are not rational and acceptable options. An art form that has value to society and the culture should not be rendered impossible because it does not advance a political agenda.

9 thoughts on “Ethics Quote Of The Week: Heather MacDonald [Expanded]

  1. Jesus! We must all now be cultural lemmings and be offended by this perceived racism. I’m hoping that there will be a pushback to this woke bullshit but with Biden in office in January, I’m afraid my optimism will evaporate with the new inauguration.

  2. My ex-wife, not to be confused with my deceased wife, was both a dancer and a ballet teacher. She taught me a love for the dance. Thereis nothing inherently racist in ANY ballet.

  3. I thought ballerinas were supposed to be tough, and sacrifice for their art? This person has too much ego to be a dancer in a group.

    There’s nothing racist about the statement, “This classical dance is about white birds, so you have to look like a white bird like everyone else.”

    The ballet company knows that, but it also knows that ballet performances are expensive luxuries and it can’t afford to alienate its primary audience.

    …Actually that explains why a lot of groups capitulate to ridiculous grievances. What it doesn’t explain is why anyone decided to push this ridiculous grievance instead of focusing on real problems. This sort of thing damages the reputation of the movement and distracts from problems that are worth solving.

  4. Heather Mac Donald is on the ramparts in defense of Western Civilization, thank God, but the future looks grim. Now it’s ballet. She’s surveyed the dismal scene in academia in her excellent book “The Diversity Delusion,” which I highly recommend, and faced down the angry hordes on college campuses. She’s also spoken out against social warriors’ claims involving police brutality. Her marshalling of facts and clear presentation is always compelling. I always enjoy her commentary – concise & passionate – on radio & television as well as print. If there is aesthetic appreciation of rationale thought on display, and I think there is, you will find it in her analysis.

    The PC brigades are also invading classical music (you already know about theater). My latest issue of “Gramophone” magazine describes the efforts to address not only gender & race vis à vis the audience, performers & composer, but they are now looking into the minority administrative staff, which as you guessed it, is woefully underrepresented. I would copy & paste it, but I only have access to the print edition (they are the usual drivel) and I can’t bear to type them out.

    Thanks for the post.

  5. There is also a movement within music programs to declare Western classical music as racist and misogynist. Why? Because Brahms, Beethoven, Schubert, and De Bussey are dead white guys from antiquated centuries


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.