Comments Of The Day Day Extended! Comment Of The Day: “Afternoon Ethics Delights“

Michael R’s Comment of the Day really doesn’t refer to anything in the post itself. It was sparked by Commenter Other Bill’s statement objecting to Ethics’ Alarms use of the term “The Great Stupid” to describe the current cultural chaos, “What’s going on is a slow motion, Marxist-inspired, relentless revolution.” I like “The Great Stupid,” which is not to say that the rise of Marxism wasn’t the Greatest Stupid of Them All.

I know I’m repeating this story, but it’s relevant. In my lucky two-hour private session with futurist Herman Kahn (above) then widely regarded as the smartest man alive, we discussed the craziness of the Sixties. He opined that throughout human history, various civilizations periodically forgot what they had learned over generations, represented by traditions, values, and practices that were taken for granted but not thought about any more. “This always leads to extended periods of mass stupidity and resulting human and societal disasters, after which society is reminded why they had the rules, traditions and values for so long. Sometimes, but not always, the damage can be repaired,” he said. Herman’s example of damage that could not be repaired was the sexual revolution, particularly the end of society’s disapproval of having babies out of marriage. Another, my personal “favorite,” is the reversal of society’s formal disapproval of recreational drug use.

Right now, an epic number of really bad ideas are being accepted by people who should know better, and not all of the idiocy can be explained by Marxism. Defunding the police? Marxists need police to keep the unenlightened in line—that’s just stupidity. Allowing a single incident in Minnesota to trigger widespread riots, property destruction and death based on false information and emotion? Stupidity. A lot of the bad ideas slithering around now are best explained by the lack of critical thinking skills in the public at large, due, not to Marxist education, but to incompetent education.

Here is Michael R’s Comment of the Day on the post, “Afternoon Ethics Delights, 4/6/2021”:

The recognition that this is the third and fourth generation of communist activists in the colleges is important. It explains why everyone now seems to be incompetent. When communist activists didn’t have complete control of academia, they were taught by people who actually knew how things worked and were taught useful information. Communism doesn’t work with reality, so this became a problem. As communists took control of entire departments, they devolved into pure ideology detached from reality. As more departments fell, this ideology became the controlling voice in the universities and took over all of administration and student life. It also made the fields incompetent.

Let’s take the example of polling. Why can’t polling organizations seem to produce an accurate poll? My suspicion is that they don’t know how anymore. People figured out how to get polls that reflected public opinion pretty closely. Then, they found that polls didn’t just reflect public opinion, they influenced public opinion. Then it was time to ‘cook’ the polls, while passing the polls off as impartial. I remember reading that one poll claimed that people aged 18-25 in Columbus Ohio gave you an accurate representation of the opinions of the US. Well, that is just the Ohio State students and no it doesn’t. However, if you claim it does, you can pass your poll off as ‘impartial’. Now, when this was done, everyone knew it was hogwash. If you teach this to gullible college students and it comes from ‘respected’ polling researchers, they will believe it. They believed all the lies told about the methods used to skew the polls. The old pollsters are gone, all that is left are the pollsters and the bag of lies they believe. I don’t think they can make an accurate poll because everything they have been taught was designed to create inaccurate polls.

Now, expand this to just about every field of knowledge. Look at Modern Monetary Theory, the philosophy currently running our economy. It holds that the government can never go bankrupt because it can just print more money. In it, the government is funded by printing money (borrowing) and the purpose of taxation is solely to further societal aims. You might wonder about hyperinflation, but MMT states quite clearly that increasing the money supply does not cause inflation, so there! If it does cause inflation, you can just redefine inflation so it doesn’t. BTW, we are changing the CPI again this year so that it reflects the FED’s assertion that we have 2% inflation. Using the original CPI, we have had 10+% inflation each year since 2008.

…sigh. I just realized I started a post about lefty college professors and ended it with what is wrong with the FED.

8 thoughts on “Comments Of The Day Day Extended! Comment Of The Day: “Afternoon Ethics Delights“

  1. I agree with the Kahn observations whole-heartedly. My analogy for the phenomenon he described is biological. Society, as a living organism, seems to generate rogue antibodies intent upon destroying the host organism. Rather than defend the organism against attack from the outside, these anti-bodies turn on the host organism and attempt to destroy it by relentless attack. Perhaps it’s analogous to cancer cells which, to my uneducated understanding, are “too healthy” and grow disproportionally and crowd out healthy cells and growth. In any event, to me, it’s just an inexplicable phenomenon. And the people attacking the host organism, in this case society, have no idea of the fragility of the host and the dire consequences that will result from the host’s destruction. It’s like a kid attacking Dad. They’re confident no matter how much abuse Dad endures, he’ll always be there to take care of them. Guess what, kids, attack Dad relentlessly and he may finally snap and takes off, or worse.

    Defunding the police is a means to creating greater chaos than anyone can imagine, which chaos will allow the revolutionaries to clamp down and “restore order” in unimaginably vicious ways. Fidel Castro ran off Batista and his thugs and replaced them with … Che Guevara, a blood-thirsty murderer.

    Allowing single incidents to unleash chaos is similarly part of the plan. “Burn it Down!” Destroy the existing order to usher in the final, Hegelian resolution of all problems in the New Society. It’s not stupid, it’s part of the plan.

    Again, I simply don’t see what’s going on as people simply “spazzing out” all at the same time. I see it as a long game, well orchestrated power grab. To the extent Kahn found the phenomenon irrational and non-sensical and somehow natural, I can agree. I’d add that it’s truly bizarre and very threatening. We ignore it at our, and our country’s, peril. I just think in this case, it’s much more organized and rational than “the great stupid” implies. We’re fighting a well funded and well armed adversary, not a rag-tag bunch of crazies.

    • I agree with much that you say there, OB. The real problem I foresee is that chaos is being created, amidst a society (or, what’s left of one) in which there simply are not enough constructive enough (and competent enough) chaos-reducers and -reversers to prevent chaos from being pervasive, chronic, and FOREVER irreversible.

      When “America” is no more, there will never again – and I mean NEVER – be a group of people who will be able re-establish even a faint likeness of the society that was “America.” Even if there is such an able group that is willing. I keep warning my kids to beware the coming post-apocalyptic dystopia, of roaming bands of marauding cannibals – because that is how bad it is going to become. There won’t be anyone left alone long enough to re-learn how to even grow food. It will be literally hell on earth. The only food that can be obtained reliably will be human flesh.

      • Further to what I say above, the real problem for today’s chaos-makers is that they are SO stupid – so immersed in ideology, enslaved to it, so to speak – that they are too mind-fucked to be competent at establishing even an authoritarian form of governance that is sustainable.

        • Re the mental capacity of the revolutionaries: see eg. the founder of BLM who has acquired four luxury homes. As any good Marxist will tell you, real estate is always a good investment and hedge against inflation. And a dacha or four is always nice to have all to yourself.

  2. And congratulations to Michael on his COTD. Michael’s comments are always outstanding.

    And Lucky! You’re Back! Hooray! Cheers!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.