Ethics Dunces: The Reported 1/3 of American Jews Who Say They’ll Vote For Democrats

One of the many puzzling aspects of the upcoming mid-terms is that any voter of either the Jewish faith or who is of Jewish heritage is considering voting for a party that has flipped to open and almost full anti-Semitism. I don’t get it. I would ask some of my long-time Jewish friends about it if so many of them weren’t so Trump Deranged that they can barely utter any sounds other than a Frankenstinian, “Arrgagrhah!”

I just saw this on “X” (I guess its time for me to drop the “Twitter”):

…I know, polls. Still, based on my own group of friends, 30% seems too small. What (the hell) is the matter with these people? I know that many German Jews voted for Hitler too, but you know, live and learn (or die and learn). This is an ethnic group renowned for their wisdom and resilience; in other words, Jews are supposed to be smarter than this. What’s going on here?

Here’s the ad that just dropped in the Michigan Senate race for the Democratic candidate, Muslim Brotherhood supporter Abdul El-Sayed:

…Yes, those damn Jews are causing inflation! Funny, I though President Biden said that Republicans were the Nazis.

This seems like a propitious time to look in on a lamented ex-Ethics Alarms commenter, “Feminist, anti-racist, pro-fat” and cripplingly woke political cartoonist “Ampersand,” who was long one of the most articulate and engaging progressive commenters here until bias made him stupid, sadly the fate of most EA readers from his side of the ideological divide. That’s his latest creation above, and here is the main section of Amp’s explanation of it:

10 thoughts on “Ethics Dunces: The Reported 1/3 of American Jews Who Say They’ll Vote For Democrats”

  1. On the one hand, there are many people whose politics rank ahead of religious identity. If we look at Catholics, who are split somewhat evenly between the parties, this becomes clear. The Democratic Party has long set itself against so many things the Catholic Church teaches as immutable that no Catholic in good conscience should vote Democratic, and yet here we are.

    On the other hand, I’m actually somewhat surprised that this poll has Jews breaking 64% Republican, when Jews have historically been that strong or stronger Democratic. This poll is such an outlier that it probably should be examined closely for whether or not it accurately sampled the broad spectrum of Jewish subdivisions, instead of focusing, say, on Orthodox Jews. But if the poll is accurate, then a massive party shift like this actually shows the Democrats alienating a historically reliable block of voters en masse.

    As for Ampersand, all I can say is that maybe the problem with two sides seeing completely different realities lies in how much we preload biases before even viewing the data. It certainly seems to me that there’s a logical distinction between someone say, “We will wipe them out because of who they are,” and saying, “If they will not return the hostages they took, we will eradicate all these murderers.” If there’s a conditional, look at the condition. But if you have “genocide” preloaded, you can’t see the distinction when a conditional is attached. And then, for so many of those quotes in Ampersand’s comic to have crucial text omitted that show the conditionals is unconscionable. If you have to distort the text to get the evil-appearing soundbite you want, maybe you’re the one who isn’t getting reality right.

      • Well, yes, but my point is that there are a lot of mental gymnastics people will go through to justify their political beliefs over their professed religion. After all, all this anti-Semitic speech is just about the state of Israel, not Jews as a whole, right? Right? I mean, when we look at all those assaults against Jews here recently, people made sure they were supporters of Israel before attacking, right? </sarc>

      • but Catholics don’t vote for people who want them dead

        Those who want Jews dead probably plan to focus on the Catholics eventually (along with Christians), but first things first…

  2. Anti-Semitism in the democrat party has been upcreeping for a long time. At least 15 years ago I asked a politically conservative Jewish friend why in God’s name do Jews vote democrat. She didn’t know either. I am very happy that so many are now where they have always belonged.

  3. The problem with this whole situation is that no one is allowed to treat it the way all other situations are treated. This one is ‘special’ and no other precedents are allowed. What do I mean?

    Since 1948, roughly 900,000 Jews have been expelled or forced to flee the Muslim countries in the Middle East and go to Israel. Their property and money were mostly confiscated by the Muslim governments. The Jewish population of those countries fell from ~900,000 to ~5000. So, why can’t Israel expel all the Muslims within their border to those countries? The Jewish property and money confiscated could be used to compensate them.

    Gaza and the West Bank should belong to Israel by right of conquest. Why are they not allowed to administer their country? I mean, if the UN told the Trump administration that it couldn’t exercise federal law in California, Oregon, or Washington because the citizens there didn’t like his government, how would that go over? Not well, because that is the federal district court judges’ job. What if the UN told the US government that it had to let the Westboro Baptist Church have absolute authority over the Lincoln Memorial?

    All other refugees were treated as temporary, resettled, forced to relinquish any claim to their former home, and forced to integrate to other areas. They all did so. The ethnic German population of Danzig was forcibly expelled into the destroyed German territory that had no cities, no industry, no food, no running water, no housing, etc for the people there already. The Polish government didn’t care. There is no current movement for their descendants to regain their property in (now) Gdansk. This is what happened to every refugee group except the ‘Palestinians’. That is because there were 2 refugee agencies; one for ‘Palestinians’, one for all the other refugees in the world. The second agency found permanent places for the refugees within 2-3 years. The ‘Palestinians’ are still in refugee camps 80 years later.

    You can only conclude that this was by design. Israel is not treated as a legitimate country by the UN, by the media, by most governments. No other country in the world is treated this way. I am not even a big fan of the Israeli government (at all) and I can recognize this.

  4. And then there are red diaper babies like Bernie Sanders and Noam Chomsky and Howard Zinn, among so many others. Why are Jews Commies? I’ve never understood Jews who want to destroy capitalism. Haven’t they heard of pogroms? Russian Jewry has fled to Israel. They root for the Soviet Union that murdered Jews? There’s some kind of screw loose.

  5. I am wondering about whether there may be something as “justifiable genocide”, similar to “justifiable homicide”.

    Let’s assume that a rapture occurs, but with a twist: only and all Palestinians are raptured. My guesses are a) the world has become a much better place in an instant b) there is now hope for peace in the Middle East.

    Israel has taken efforts to spare civilians in Gaza when taking out Hamas terrorists and military targets in Gaza. To no avail, Israel will be accused of genocide anyway. So Israel is accused of genocide, without actually having any benefit that a genocide will offer. The cynic in me says, why spare the civilians who keep voting for Hamas?

    A war is won once the enemy considers further fighting hopeless. Hamas keeps fighting because they prefer their own death about letting Israelis live. They are as intransigent as Hitler in his final days in his bunker, wishing the entire destruction of Germany. OK, why not give the people in Gaza death, all of them?

    Israel is way too gentle with the population of Gaza, beholden to Geneva conventions. Not to long ago battles were won with siege warfare, with cities being starved until they were willing to submit to the conditions made by the besieging army.

    For the Christians among the EA commenters, there are genocides in the Bible. Sodom and Gomorrah, the Amorites in Canaan, the Amalekites.

Leave a Reply