
I know I’m a bit obsessive on this topic, but none of the Democratic Party’s lies (and those of its dead-eyed allies, the news media and academia), annoy me quite as much as the “Trump breaches democratic norms!” refrain. It’s Resistance Big Lie #6 on the list; partisan scholars Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt have made a career out of peddling its hypocrisy and the fake history underlying it. Don’t make me go through the rebuttal again: a 2024 update is here.
At the moment, Barack Obama is engaged in breaching a very important democratic norm, the tradition holding that past U.S. Presidents rarely criticize the current occupant, and never actively campaign against a President who isn’t on the ballot. The reasons past Presidents don’t do this and must not are many, including that it is inherently divisive, that it encourages bitter partisanship, that it undermines the office, that past Presidents are supposed to recognize as few do the challenges of the job, and that it is cowardly, since past Presidents have nothing to lose by insulting the current POTUS except, perhaps, the respect of decent Americans. Obama is now on the campaign trail, doing less campaigning for Democrats running for Congress than insulting Donald Trump.
He is the only ex-President ever to do this when the ex- isn’t himself running for the office, as former President Trump was from 2021 to 2024. Theodore Roosevelt was a term-long critic of his successor (and onetime best friend) William Howard Taft, but Teddy was getting ready to run for a second full term. John Quincy Adams was vocal criticizing some of his successors, but that was from a seat in Congress. Obama’s shattering this “norm” because he’s special, or something.
Actually, Obama’s shattering this “norm” he’s an asshole. Obama has the gall to ridicule Trump’s construction projects, when, as Scott Bessent quipped, the design of his Presidential Library looks like Darth Vader’s tomb. He’s ethically estopped from making architectural critiques, just as he’s estopped from criticizing Trump or any President. Barack Obama was one of the weakest, most feckless, most destructive U.S. Presidents in our history: his major accomplishment was becoming President as a black man. Yay. But that’s it.
Obama may also be the most destructive and meddlesome former President in our history. John Tyler did join Jefferson Davis’s cabinet, so it’s close. But Barack has certainly proven that democratic norms only matter to Democrats when Republicans vary from them.
I guess we knew that, though.
I suppose I’d violate norms too if the current President ended my opportunity for a fourth term. (Yes, fourth.)
Boy, that third term was sure a mess…
Suddenly I’m feeling a bit peckish. Anyone for Chinese chips and a Brazilian dip?
This post makes me regret not calling your attention to a column in the Federalist called “The Anti-Trump Left Has Descended into a Persistent Hallucinatory State.” The author, Chris Bray, examines an October 24th column in the NYT by Nicholas Kristoff. I really enjoyed how he systematically demonstrated numerous presidents doing what Kristoff claims demonstrates that Trump is “breaking norms”. But this has me thinking: would it be worthwhile to have a persistent link to a litany of things for which Trump is accused of breaking norms, and for each a rebuttal with previous presidents’ doing the same or breaking similar norms?
The sub-topic of this blog is leadership, and effective, strong, transformational leaders like Trump (effective, strong, transformational doesn’t always mean “good”) break norms. That’s what strong leaders do. It isn’t an accusation worth rebutting with “but X did it too”. The whole manufactured offense is just a way of saying “we object to this guy being President at all, and using his Constitutional powers.”
Yes, but, despite the number of times I’ve commented that facts don’t matter to these people, I still have the fantasy that enough facts gathered in one place would sway them through sheer enormity…
You’re so cute when you’re delusional …
Thanks, I try my best…
That’s pretty close to an “and aren’t you precious,” GL!
Ooh – good one. I’ll use that another time …
Barack Hussein Obama – most divisive man who charmed so many into believing he was a uniter. You nailed it. Asshole
Too bad, I thought his biggest breaking of norms this year was being a narrator for an audiobook. Call me judgy, but I don’t want former presidents doing a stint as narrator, even if it is their own book. Ick. It’s like advertising for used cars. Tacky.
I would consider it tacky if it was someone else’s book, but I can’t blame him for wanting his own words to come out of his own mouth. I realize not everyone has the time or skill to narrate their own work like this, but if you can, who would know better than you how to read your own words?