The case in which the Court (briefly) examined Sir John Knight’s 1686 acquittal for walking into the church of St. Michael in Bristol during services armed and with the goal of frightening the congregation was New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen. The issue at hand was whether New York’s 1911 “proper-cause” (or “may-issue”) licensing law that forced law-abiding applicants to prove a special, non-general need for self-defense in order to obtain a concealed carry permit was Constitutional. The Court’s job in Bruen wasn’t to decide whether New York’s restrictions were reasonable or sensible, but whether they violated the Constitution. Gladwell, like so most progressives, wants courts to legislate: it’s much easier to impose unpopular and undemocratic measures on the public if judges decide what’s “good policy.”
Another ethical problem with Gladwell’s argument is that in focusing on the Knight case he distorts—deliberately?—the Court’s analysis. The Knight case occupies about a page of the 63-page majority opinion, and the opinion included it because both sides raised the case in their briefs. The plaintiffs challenging the law argued that Knight’s acquittal showed the statute involved only barred carrying weapons with intent to terrify. New York argued that the law outlawed personal weapons of self-defense generally. The opinion examines medieval English law, colonial statutes, antebellum laws, Reconstruction-era measures and more while concluding that there is little legal history or precedent supporting bans on citizens bearing arms that should control in the U.S.
However, Gladwell’s main botch is that the case deciding that the Second Amendment protected an individual right to bear arms was D.C. v. Heller, which Bruen relied on. The Knight case isn’t mentioned in Heller at all.
So let’s see: Gladwell…
- Doesn’t understand the function and role of the Supreme Court,
- Thinks judges are trained to apply “common sense” rather than legal analysis and precedent when deciding whether a law should stand,
- Didn’t realize which SCOTUS decision interpreted the Second Amendment the way non-Americans (like him) think it should,
- Didn’t carefully read the opinions he’s criticizing, and
- Misrepresented the Bruen rationale.
Shut up, Malcolm.
And watch some Westerns.
It sounds like Gladwell may have been “ruined by success.”
Just like the jocular greeting card in which the character on the front says: “I’m just waiting for my chance to be ruined by success.”
= – = – = – =
Malcolm Gladwell has been successful for a long time in his niche. The consensus seems to be that he aquitted himself poorly in the “Munk Debate” about the merits of “trusting the mainstream media” vs. the alternative media back in 2022.
= – = – = – =
One of the smartest things I ever heard a respected academic say was “I would have to professionally disqualify myself from Topic X” [In this particular case it was the possibility of serving on a dissertation committee on topic X].
Gladwell has spent so much time explaining things to the general reading public (whether accurately or not) that he’s gotten out of his element, apparently without realizing it. It can happen to any of us. It happens to me!
I don’t know much about crime and homicide, except for what I read sporadically. It’s a grim topic, but periodically attracts my interest.
Regarding the issue of gun crime in the U.S., and why it’s hard for the USA to “Get to Denmark” the following blog essay from Marc MacYoung popped into my head. He’s opinionated but with a light touch as an essayist.
https://macyoungsmusings.blogspot.com/2017/07/what-criminals-with-guns.html?m=0
thanks for reading!
charles w abbott
rochester NY
Excellent article Charles.
Yes, I agree.
Do the gun control nutters ever count the millions of Europeans killed by the guns of their own governments last century when examining the data?
No.
People like this don’t even look at the Canadian figures. Numerous Canadian provinces have murder rates higher than the US average (by their own published numbers) and I view the Canadian numbers as highly questionable. When I used to live near Ontario, there was a year that the Ontario government had to apologize for their murder statistics. Ontario had a law that dictated when their crime statistics had to be published. Well, the Canadian government that year couldn’t get the national figures published in time so Ontario published theirs a day or two earlier than Canadian government. Well, Ontario had more murders that year than all of Canada combined! Ontario apologized for not ‘correcting’ their figures to make them agree with the national figures. So, if you want to know the ‘true’ Canadian murder figures, you need to triple them.
These people also don’t have a clue what would happen if we allowed militias. That is where we really have our rights restricted. We are supposed to have local militias under local (not central government government) control. Imagine if my county had a militia for the county. Imagine what would happen if the militia found out that the local high school had been molesting children for over a decade, that the school had covered it up, and that the police, city government, the DA, and the judges had made it so that the parents couldn’t bring charges? Now, a militia should have ‘military style weapons’. How long do you thing the principal and superintendent are going to keep their job when the militia shows up to the school board meeting? The city council meeting? Yeah, that is why we don’t have militias. That is why I think the 2nd Amendment became an individual right. The militias make it difficult to concentrate power in the hands of bureaucrats.
Well, by his logic, we need to ban ‘migrants’, because they make the crime rate go up. Look at Sweden’s crime rate as they became more ‘diverse’ due to ‘migration’. A ‘common sense’ reading of the data would strongly indicate that immigration from non-Western countries should be banned.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12134-024-01221-1/figures/1
I used to enjoy his audiobooks but I haven’t been able to listen to him after I watched him and Michelle Goldberg debate Matt Taibbi and Douglas Murray – The Munk Debates: Be it resolved, don’t trust mainstream media.
It was an embarrassingly poor performance. I lost all respect for him.
One reason (maybe ultimately the main one) the left wants to demonize and blame firearms and their often conservative owners for death and violence is that the stronger correlation is demographics. Political affiliation is generally not reported in homicide data, but other statistics strongly support a reasonable supposition that the majority of murders in the US are committed by democrats.