If Democrats aren’t in charge, Republicans are, and they’ve been happily demonstrating what that looks like for immigrants, for queer people, for brown people, for Black people, for trans people, for sick people, for poor people, for working people, and even for elected Democrats.
Great, you understand that elections have consequences. Good for you. Tell me, dearie, exactly what Republicans have been demonstrating what their governance looks like for the identity groups above. Tell me what rights they’ve lost. Zero.
Legal immigrants (I filled in the L Word for you to help you out) haven’t lost any rights at all. Queer people, so far as I can tell, are still able to work, to vote, to marry…as can brown people, black people, trans people, sick people, poor people, working people and even, yes, elected Democrats.
All that’s required of them is the same thing that’s required of all of the rest of us: obey the law and don’t demand special rights that infringe upon the rights of others. Your problem is that you ascribe to these identity groups rights that don’t exist. [ 43 points: 10 each for immigrants, black, brown and queer, another 3 for “sick people, for poor people, for working people.” Probably the worst section in the whole screed. Subtotal: 83]
If you can’t get your privileged asses to support Democrats, then you’re allowing Republicans to trample all over those people AGAIN. [5 points for the hoary “privileged” nonsense. It would be more if it weren’t so familiar and silly. Rolls right off the back. Three more for “allowing Republicans to trample all over those people AGAIN.” Subtotal: 91
Were you complaining about what ICE was doing under Republican rule? Why TF would you give them even half a chance to do it again?? Are you upset about how women are being stripped of basic health care rights? Why TF would you undermine the party trying to stop that?! Why would you risk letting Republicans be in charge again?? Were you upset that Black people were being lynched and that law enforcement kept on ruling them suicides? Or that school shootings kept on getting nothing but thoughts and prayers? And yet you think that now is a good time to risk letting Republicans back in power? WHY??
ICE was arresting illegal immigrants, some of whom had committed crimes, multiple crimes, violent crimes and/or had orders of deportation on them for years. Are you really arguing that people should be allowed to walk into our country, stay for years and behave however way they wish with no consequences?
Abortion is what you’re talking about. Basic Healthcare rights makes it sound like they aren’t allowed to visit a primary care physician or a dentist (as is the case in some strict Middle Eastern countries because they aren’t allowed to be touched by men who aren’t married to them). The argument that women have been stripped of healthcare rights because the SCOTUS left the issue of abortion to the states, many of which still permit abortion is like arguing that basic personal liberty has been stripped from full grown adults because some states don’t permit drinking alcohol until age 21.
The idea that black people are being lynched is a talking point that is decades in the past. In your mind, a black person killed by a black love interest and some black friends is a lynching. A mental health crisis in this country cannot possibly affect black citizens either? It’s impossible for a black person to commit suicide? What anti-law enforcement propaganda have you inhaled that you know what lurks in the minds of black people and what doesn’t?
As for the school shootings Talking Point, say what you mean. There’s no such thing as common sense gun control. There is only gun confiscation which will not solve the problem. This is fairy tale land thinking. Human beings are not born good. With proper training in self-discipline, ethics and morals, a human being can overcome the base instincts in all of us (and, sometimes, even that isn’t enough). Talk about stripping people of their basic rights… [No, THIS is the worst section of the rant. Scores: 7 points for the ICE nonsense, 10 for the dishonest abortion description, 15 for the unforgivable lynching lie, 5 more for the school shootings chorus, for a total of 37, and a Subtotal of 128.
Because Jeffries met with someone and didn’t ask for your permission first?! Because Schumer is old and is taking money from a PAC someone told you is evil, even though he used that money to help your hero AES win?
Can you all try to stop micromanaging leadership positions you clearly don’t understand?!
I wasn’t aware that, once elected, a Senator or Congressperson was beyond reproach and could not be criticized. That’s certainly not the impression your party has been giving me for years. [Score: 5 points on my scale. Subtotal:133.]
And before you come for me, no I don’t fully understand those positions either, but I’m also not trying to micromanage them. I’m looking at this historic win that just happened and seeing that whatever the f*** they’re doing, they’re clearly doing a fantastic job.
Micromanage? You mean criticize. I don’t want Schumer or Jeffries to let the DSA candidates take over the Democratic Party either, but that’s much different from saying that they are winners because they won a (kind of) historic win (that you are making a far bigger deal out of than you should) that makes them above second-guessing. Perhaps, you should understand their elected positions before telling American citizens they can’t express their opinions about them. [Score: 2 points. Subtotal:135.]
And yes I have held leadership positions, and I know how much easier it is to criticize leadership than it is to be a leader.
Yes, it is. That’s what being a leader is. The Bible says in the book of James that too many people should not try to become leaders because they are held to greater accountability than others. You wanted the job, you got the job, now do the job. And don’t get upset if some people question the wisdom of some of your decisions.
Try being an ally for a change and stop whining that the Democrats aren’t perfect.
Again, we’re back to the accusation that criticizing someone makes you less of a Democrat. This allyship that demands lockstep conformity and support sounds pretty scary to me. But, what would I know, I voted for the other guys. [Bonus: 5 points. I didn’t flag this. Subtotal:140.]
If you think the DSA is perfect, you are seriously kidding yourself. But even if they were, even if they did everything right, and never exhibited any hypocrisy whatsoever, they won’t have the power to make one whit of difference in the foreseeable future, there is no scenario in which they win enough seats to suddenly be in charge of the House and the Senate, so voting for them instead of Democrats is still privileged b*******
Yeah, we get it, nobody’s perfect. I don’t believe people are perfect either. See above when it comes to stripping us of guns. In fact, your argument that voting for something that will not be useful or beneficial is frankly astounding. You have a whole platform of policies on your Talking Point-addled brain that will not be useful or beneficial to this country but, suddenly, voting for the people that want the same things isn’t practical right now? Don’t get me wrong, a DSA majority in this country would be a catastrophe, but people have the right to vote for what candidates they wish. At least they do for now…[Score: 5 more points for “privileged.” Subtotal:140]
All it does is allow Republicans a chance to get back into power.
Speaking of which, God forbid people vote for the Republicans. I’m sure you’re all for preventing that, right?
You think a multiparty system is the solution?
Actually, I agree that a multi-party system is unworkable. But your party seems to want a one-party system. Yours.
Think again. Such a system requires more cooperation and compromise, not less. And while such a political system may produce the occasional winner like New Zealand’s Jacinda Ardern or Germany’s Angela Merkel (who was from the Conservative Christian Party, btw, so none of you – or me, for that matter – would have supported her party), it also produces the occasional Hitler or Boris Johnson. And the voters don’t get to pick the prime minister, the parties do. It’s literally a backroom deal, and the voters have no say until the next election.
Like I said, a multi party system requires more compromise, not less. Those of you who can’t even support the Democrats because they’re not perfect enough would never be able to handle it.
I’m clutching pearls at the idea of compromise. There will be no compromise if there’s a multi-party system. The DSA will vote with the Democrats and vice-versa to keep their majority until DSA candidates outnumber the mainstream Democrats and usher their codgy old well-past-their-pull date colleagues into the nearest MAID center.
Republicans have caused generations worth of damage, and as such it will take generations to fix. Set your expectations accordingly, and stop demanding that Democrats do this or do that, or else you’ll claim they have failed.
It is simply impossible for them to fix generations worth of damage in 2 years or even 4 or even 8 years.
And, yet, Republicans are expected to fix generations of damage caused by Democrats in a few short years. Just like Trump was expected to fix the inflation that skyrocketed during Biden’s administration in two years all the while fighting a party and media that refused to report good financial news and worked heartily to prevent him from passing any bill of consequence. [Score: 2 for “generations of damage.”It would be more, except this is such standard partisan rhetoric that it’s barely worth complaining about. Republican think Democrats have “caused generations worth of damage.” Another 2 points for “generations to fix.” Nothing like eliminating any expectations of actual change within voters’ lifetimes!Subtotal:144.]
The reality is that the more you work with the Democrats, the faster the damage will be repaired.
And the faster the rights of your opponents will be stripped, before eventually you and your allies will be stripped of Constitutional rights you actually have by a radicalized party that doesn’t believe in them. Score: 3. Subtotal:144.
When progressive voters refuse to turn out for Obama in 2010 because he didn’t give them everything they wanted in his first 2 years, they guaranteed that Republicans would be able to gerrymander the states.
That’s the country we live in. A country with an impatient electorate that doesn’t understand how its government works. An electorate made dumber by an education system in thrall to your party. [Can’t give AM the points for this: the real offense is the lie about gerrymandering, as if Democrats haven’t gerrymandered as well. Subtotal: 144.
We maybe, might have, possibly, perhaps, have just come overcome that damage, although the jury is still out on that.
But in the meantime, Republicans have had almost twenty years time to create damage that we have to undo. They have stacked the local, county, state, and Supreme courts, they have undermined institutions, they have destroyed a generation’s worth of education, and the fact that an entire generation has had no real civics education is really showing right now. I learned how the US government works in Germany in high school and I know more about it than most US Americans I know.
And back to my point in my earlier post. Republicans have been stopped at every point by Democrats and by some members of their own party. The stacking argument is a Talking Point that indicates you have no idea how our government is supposed to work and your arguments that the Republicans have undermined institutions and a generation’s worth of education is a riot, considering that most major institutions in this country, including education has been controlled by large Democratic-leaning followers, particularly in the teachers’ unions and in academia. Civic Education most certainly has lagged, but you are hardly the person to complain about it as you apparently got Talking Points about America’s system of government in a foreign country made up of just the type of people who made up the bureaucracy of the Department of Education for decades. People who nodded their heads at Republican presidents and then did whatever they wanted anyway. [Score: 10 points for the court-stacking lie (there are more Democrat-apponted judges than Republican), 15 for the projection about “undermining institutions, and 10 for blaming the Right for the ruin of our education, which is entirely the doing of the Left, and 15 more for the gobsmacking civics education comment. I have never read so many wrong claims about the government and the law in such a short period of time since the mid-terms, and almost all of it has come from this creep’s “allies.” Another 10 pts for the Germany laugher. Subtotal: 204.]
So here I am in Thailand, watching people say the most bizarre things about the role of the Speaker, how Schumer betrayed us all, how we need new leadership, et cetera et f****** cetera, and none of it makes any sense.
Because scrolling on Facebook is what someone vacationing abroad should make a priority. Someone who can’t stand that someone out there has a different opinion.
I just can’t.
Yet, you just did.
For the last 10 years, we have known that Republicans have worked closely with Russia to push divisive politics on the Left. We have known that social media was used to our detriment, that stories were carefully spun and placed to turn us against each other.
The Russian Collusion is a hoax made up by the Democratic Party to undermine the Trump administration from the beginning and mire his first term down in endless investigations that went nowhere. If any of our politics have become divisive, it isn’t because of Russia. The Devil doesn’t have to tempt us when we willingly rush into sin ourselves. As for social media being used to carefully spin stories…how ironic that you acknowledge that and not only allow it to form your worldview, but also let it cause you to take time from your vacation to lecture a fellow traveler about not being a good enough Democrat. [Score: 10 for the Russian Collusion Hoax talking point (I should have had it score higher) and another 10 for the social media lie, essentially a complaint over Elon Musk saving the US from heavy-handed censorship on a public platform. Subtotal: 224.
Knowing this, we’d think we would have become more cautious and more critical thinkers, but apparently all we’ve done is dug in deeper.
I don’t understand why it would. You demonstrate no better critical thinking than anyone else I encounter on Facebook.
At the very least, I would expect people who claim to care about politics to have paid attention to the last two impeachment trials, and to understand at this point that we need two thirds of the Senate to convict Trump if he’s impeached. That isn’t ancient history after all! That was recent! We just went through this people, ffs.
And we still don’t have two thirds in the Senate, unless we get Republicans to work with us, which will only happen if Democrats are willing to reach across the aisle. But the same people demanding an impeachment, or else, are the same people saying there should be no reaching across the aisle, or else.
Because impeaching Trump and getting a two-thirds majority to remove him is really a priority at this point? [I can’t complain about this part since it is the closest thing top reasonable in the whole post.]
With the actual f*** is wrong with those people?!
I have decided I am no longer willing to try to work with them. I can’t have it anymore. I’m too old for this s***. They just want to be mad at Democrats, and no amount of pointing out that the people who are going to suffer most if Democrats are weakened are immigrants and trans people and poor people and people who need health insurance is going to make one bit of difference to them.
Now, now. What about allyship?
And again, legal immigrants won’t suffer. Trans people are not being stripped of any right any of the rest of us have. And the health insurance Talking Point pretty much causes your argument to take a dive. I could listen to a good faith argument about whether health care is a right. Whether taxpayer-paid health care is a right is another story… [I didn’t have any points for this because it is merely a repeat of what was already said. Upon reflection, I think AM is right: the health insurance garbage warrants 5 more bonus points. Subtotal: 229.]
I am not the idiot whisperer. People who are determined to fall for every divisive psyop can’t be helped
Pot, meet Kettle. You’re not whispering, you’re shouting the divisive partisanship that social media encourages, displaying the ignorance of the American political system you got from an UnAmerican uncivic-minded high school in Germany and speaking of psyops…
***
AM’s final score: 229, ten points over what I had as the perfect score.
[That’s a photo from “Diagnosis: Murder” above.I couldn’t find a show called “Diagnosis: Asshole.”]