In an interview, assistant football coach Cayetano acknowledged that the team’s coaching staff bears responsibility for the botch—that’s generous of him—but said that athletic department officials should have flagged the player’s ineligibility before it cost the team its season. Cayetano said Coach Strenfel sought and received approval from athletic director Justin Sturge before adding the player from the school’s soccer team as a kicker during the regular season. Court documents show that Sturge attended a training session approximately a month earlier that covered the postseason eligibility requirement, but nonetheless, his assistant says, he never made his head coach aware of the rule.
“You can blame him. You can blame me. You can blame everyone on the staff. However, we have bosses as well, and we have people who are supposed to educate us,” Cayetano said. So he blames the athletic director and David Coates, who serves as a district consultant involved with Section IX athletics.
For their part, the school administrators think the forfeit is just mean, or as the school claimed in its appeal, “arbitrary and capricious.” Why should the students be punished because the adults screwed up? “While we are deeply, deeply disappointed that we are unable to find a remedy for our young people, our hearts are with our football team and cheerleading scholars who have given so much to this remarkable football season and cheerleading season,” Middletown’s superintendent Amy Creeden said.
Ugh.
Ethics observations:
1. Wait, isn’t the primary purpose of a high school education? Why does any school pay a full time football coach and an assistant coach? No wonder kids graduate from high school with warped priorities. Why do parents permit this?
2. Watching the adults in charge immediately try to pass the blame around to others conveys a destructive lesson. Everyone from the staff up to the athletic director and the consultant (The schools pay a consultant?) is responsible, each should acknowledge that, each should admit that he should have flagged the issue, that and all should be held accountable.
3. The false principle advocated by the superintendent is toxic and indefensible. The students should learn that if you break the rules (or laws), there have to be consequences. Her “Aw, we should just let this go. The kids shouldn’t suffer because grown-ups were wrong!” theory is how we got the “Dreamers” debacle. Both utilitarianism and absolutism support enforcing rules strictly even if the results seem overly harsh in some scenarios.
4. Similarly, she is trying to erase the leadership principle. An organization can’t separate itself from the decisions of its leaders when the leaders make a mistake or when their decisions backfire.
4. The school’s reaction to a clear and fair response after a bright-line rules breach—sue!—demonstrates another destructive cultural habit. “It was just a technicality!” is a rationalization too many people think is profound. The Challenger blew up because of a “technicality.” Details matter, even the smallest ones. The school’s response should have been to apologize to the students, accept full responsibility, and not to deflect the blame by claiming that the forfeit was somehow unfair.
5. Should the losing team have just accepted the loss and not sought to get a victory it didn’t deserve? That would have been a gracious gesture? I believe that is the most interesting ethics issue raised by this scenario. In a professional sport or a legal case, technicalities absolutely should be enforced. In an amateur event…maybe not. Sportsmanship might suggest that the losing team accept the result even though it didn’t have to. This would be a Golden Rule response.
5. Meanwhile, do reporters even know how to practice journalism any more? Why do none of the stories about this incident reveal why the coach resigned? (We can guess why the assistant coach resigned: he publicly blamed everyone he could think of when he was as guilty of negligence and incompetence as anyone.) Did Strenfel “fall on his sword” and accept full responsibility? Was he really fired? Why didn’t any reporter dig into those questions? What do the parents think? I would have been cheered to read a quote from one who said, “It’s a shame, but in the end, it’s just a football game. Coaches make mistakes in all levels of sports and we don’t want them fired for every one. Ten years on the job should mean more than a single lost game.”