More on “List Incompetence Again: Variety’s ‘100 Greatest Movie Stars’”: Seeking Integrity and Legitimacy

Part of what sunk the Variety list before it got out of port was the failure to define coherent standards, as those in charge used basically a “I know one when I see one.” Uh, no.

Here are 10 questions that need to be carefully considered before designating an actor an all-time great:

1. Was the actor or actress ever an icon, and does the performer still have that status? Icon means, in this context, “Someone or something widely admired and seen as representing a movement, era, or style.” In some of this post I will default to using numbers on the list above, but in this case, I’ll use names. Undeniable current icons on the list include Marilyn Monroe, Humphrey Bogart, Charlie Chaplin, Marlon Brando (method acting), Clint Eastwood, Cary Grant (suave with impeccable style), John Wayne, Fred Astaire (and Fred and Ginger), Shirley Temple, Marlena Dietrich, Judy Garland, Bruce Lee, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and Divine. I consider Garbo, James Dean and Rudolf Valentino to be expired icons.

2. At his or her peak, was the actor or actress considered the best, most popular, most famous, most bankable or most interesting? How long did that peak last?

3. Did he or she dominate a film genre for an significant period of time?

4. Did the actor or actress “remain on top” for an extended period, or was his or her career more of a proverbial “flash in the pan”?

5. Was he or she widely regarded as “great” by colleagues and peers in the movie industry?

6. How many movies that the star headed are now regarded as classics? How many are regularly still watched today?

7. Was the star unique?

8. Did the star have a significant, documented influence on movie history and the culture?

9. Can it be objectively concluded that no movie star not on the list was as qualified or more qualified than the star being considered for inclusion?

10. Finally, does the star have the “it” factor, the mysterious “star quality” than would make any critical viewer seeing the performer on screen in a representative role for the first time think, “Wow! No wonder he or she was a big star!”

If I had time, I would assign values on a 0-10 scale for each proposed movie star in each of the 10 categories. (I don’t.)

Perspective

Matt Damon recently suggested that the Academy Awards should be decided after 25 years have past, because only with the perspective of time can film arts be fairly measured. That’s not going to happen, of course, but his point has relevance here. There are film greats who are just as impressive after decades, in some cases more, as they were when their careers were ongoing. There are others whose styles and successes seem dated and even inexplicable to modern audiences.

From the other end of the telescope, the Variety team was foolish, at least for the sake of the exercise’s credibility, to include young, current stars whose staying power is undetermined while the ultimate critical and popular assessments of their work and careers are a long way off. Seven of the choices in the “top hundred” above are indefensible on that basis: Zendaya, Emma Stone, Kristin Stewart, Timothy Chalomet, Kate Winslet, Robert Pattinson (recently named the new James Bond: what if he bombs?), and Ryan Gosling.

Foreign Stars

This is one of the worst features of the list. Somebody decided to make the list international, but not really, mostly assigning a single slot to a particular nation’s prominent star. Would that star’s main audience abroad agree that he or she was the best to represent that country’s films? Why certain countries and not others? (Where are Mexico’s movie stars, for example?)What’s the criteria? Since the list obviously isn’t really international, why are such stars included at all, unless they deserve selection based on their American films and performances in English? Sophia Loren is an example of a foreign star whose presence on the list can be easily defended. Not Alain Delon, however: as big a star as he was in France, in the U.S. he was relegated to playing gangsters. Quick: name an Alain Delon movie that was a domestic hit. #92, Shah Rukh Khan, has not starred in a single American or Hollywood movie, as he is only a star in Indian cinema, primarily Hindi-language films. And he’s ranked ahead of Henry Fonda? Liv Ulman’s main career successes were in Sweden. Marcello Mastroianni had no appearances in significant U.S. films. Of the randomly selected foreign stars (Why Catherine Deneuve and not Bridget Bardot?), five inclusions on the list fail this basic list integrity test: Delon, Khan, Mastroianni, Deneuve, and Toshiro Mifune.

Genres, Types and Special Categories

Variety’s hacks never figured out how to handle genre and special category actors. Should the greatest star in a particular identifiable category of films be on a Top 100 stars list? How about the second greatest?

For special categories, let’s look at child stars. Shirley Temple is obviously the most important and acclaimed female child star of all time. #2, in my view, would be Dakota Fanning, and she has been far more successful as an adult than Shirley was. The greatest, most prolific and most popular male child star of all time is Mickey Rooney, and he made many more popular and successful films than Shirley. Why didn’t he make the list?

In genres, why are horror movies ignored? They comprise a major film genre, and one that produced major, even iconic stars: Lon Chaney, Boris Karloff, Bela Lugusi, Christopher Lee and Vincent Price. Bruce Lee is all the way up to #53, so Martial Arts must have been treated as a serious genre. Lee only made five major martial arts features before his death in 1973. American martial arts stars Chuck Norris and Stephen Seagal made more movies and sold more tickets than Lee, a lot more. Lee’s films grossed about $65 million at the box office. Norris’s films grossed more than $350 million, and Seagal is the champ, with about $450 million. None of these guys could play Hamlet: why does Lee get all the glory?

Marilyn Monroe is the iconic female sex symbol, but before her there was Theda Bara, Jean Harlow, and Lana Turner; after Marilyn came Raquel Welch among others. Harlow was a better actress than Marilyn and starred in more major films despite dying at 26. Raquel was a sex icon in her day. Is “female sex symbol” a category, or not? If it is, who decided Monroe should be the single representative? The only possible justification for including Pam Grier on the list is as a representative of the so-called “Blaxploitation” genre. Why her more than Jim Brown, Richard Roundtree (“Shaft”), or Fred Williamson?

Conclusions: We can all agree, I hope, that the list is terrible. Now what? Among other things, 100 is an arbitrary number and obviously too small. I will refer to “the List” meaning a list of “The Greatest Movie Stars of All Time,” with the understanding that such a list might be 132 slots in size. If I were compiling the list, I would use the scoring system described above to determine ranking, otherwise the selection would be completely subjective. I would decided on a point cut-off for “the greatest.” However, even without spending the next three months working out the scores of about 500 actors who might be candidates for inclusion, I am confident making the following calls:

Indefensible inclusions (and this is with giving quite a few others the benefit of the doubt) no matter how large the correct List is:

  • 9
  • 37
  • 49
  • 53
  • 61
  • 62
  • 69
  • 74
  • 75
  • 77
  • 79
  • 83
  • 84
  • 86
  • 87
  • 88
  • 91
  • 92
  • 94
  • 97
  • 98

That’s 21 in all, more than a fifth of the list. Shameful.

Indefensible Omissions (especially if one is going to include the 21 above):

  • Buster Keaton
  • Harold Lloyd
  • Clara Bow
  • Douglas Fairbanks
  • William Powell
  • Frederick March
  • Mickey Rooney
  • W.C. Fields
  • Errol Flynn
  • Irene Dunn
  • Greer Garson
  • Bing Crosby
  • Frank Sinatra
  • Charlton Heston
  • Gene Autry
  • Rita Hayworth
  • Ava Gardner
  • Glenn Close
  • Peter Sellers
  • Jerry Lewis
  • Bob Hope
  • Laurel and Hardy
  • Abbott and Costello
  • Johnny Depp

That’s 24.

Arguable inclusions (these are only examples; an inclusive list would take me all day):

  • Yul Brenner
  • Esther Williams
  • Jeanette MacDonald
  • Kevin Costner
  • Julie Christie
  • Alec Guinness
  • John Garfield
  • Paul Muni
  • Glenn Ford
  • Lawrence Olivier
  • Richard Burton
  • Rene Zellweger
  • Scarlett Johansson
  • Dakota Fanning
  • …and others.

There. I feel better now.

Leave a Reply