My favorite Christmas gift this year, as it has been in recent years, is the new Bill James Baseball Handbook, which will be my primary bathroom reading for the next ten months. Oh, it’s not as much fun as the old Bill James Abstracts, but in those days, three decades ago, Bill was revealing then-unknown nuances of the game that spawned the elaborate (and still developing) analytical tools that have changed how baseball is played, watched, and understood.
James typically writes a few long, Abstract-like articles for the Handbook, which has many contributors, and he is, as always, fascinated by the selection criteria for the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. My gift is especially timely, because his observations in the Handbook dovetail nicely with the recent voting by sportswriters on the latest entering class, including Derk Jeter, naturally, and perhaps others. The results won’t be announced for a while.
Bill did research this past year to determine who the public wanted to see elected to the Hall among players who had not yet been deemed worthy ( meaning that they hadn’t been listed on at least 75% of the ballots cast, or are not yet eligible for various reasons, including players who are still active. The results, as he explored the gap between public opinion and past voting, were disturbing, if not exactly shocking. Continue reading







Today’s impeachment commentary come from commenter Humble Talent, who gets a Comment of the Day for his efforts during last week’s Open Forum. I called it an “Impeachment Edition” because I decided “Jack Being Turned Inside-Out Like That Pig-Lizard Thing in “Galaxy Quest” seemed too obscure.
HT is Canadian, but his perspective is a great deal keener on this issue than most Americans, a large number of which, I read yesterday, actually think that the House vote meant that Trump isn’t President any more.
My fellow Americans are embarrassing the hell out of me in this matter.
Here’s Humble Talent’s Comment of the Day from “Open Form, Impeachment Edition’: