Worst Sequel Ever: “Cheer Your Rapist II”

The Penn State disease is not restricted to colleges.  Now there comes a lawsuit showing how ugly it is when the contagion hits a high school.

The Southern Columbia Tigers are a real high school football power in Pennsylvania, and naturally the Southern Columbia Area School District and Southern Columbia Area High School Principal James A. Becker wouldn’t do anything to change that…like, for example, barring two rapists from playing on the team when they were so good at scoring the legal way, as well as…well, you know.

A law suit filed by “C.S.” in Federal Court alleges that the school district and high school principal protected two star student athletes after it had been proven in court that they had sexually assaulted the girl, a student at the school as well. From the complaint:

“Despite these adjudications, the school district did not take any action to discipline the perpetrators, or prevent them from having contact with or harassing C.S., or otherwise restrict their ability to attend or participate in extracurricular activities, and they were both allowed to play on the boys’ basketball team that winter. The boys’ permission to participate on the basketball team resulted in the constructive deprivation of C.S. to participate on the basketball team’s cheerleading squad, as C.S. could not reasonably be expected to cheer for, and rally behind, two students who had recently sexually assaulted her…Officials for the school district, including principal Becker, informed C.S. and her parents that they would take no action against the perpetrators and that the school could do nothing to separate C.S. from the perpetrators without a court order since the assault did not take place on school grounds.

…During this meeting, when C.S. specifically raised concerns of being scheduled in the same ‘honors’ English class as the perpetrators, the school district refused to offer any reasonable accommodation to her. In fact, C.S. was advised that if she did not wish to be in the same ‘honors’ English class as the perpetrators, her alternative was to remove herself from the ‘honors’ class and schedule herself in the ‘general’ class since there was only one section of ‘honors’ English.”

Enough. You can read the whole revolting story here; it is bringing back bad memories for me. Maybe you remember too: do you recall the Texas high school that kicked a rape victim off the cheerleading squad after she refused to cheer for her own rapist, who was still allowed to play on the school’s basketball squad? This is how the Penn State disease works, you see. It causes a form of insanity. Before either of these cases happened, before the administrators responsible got their jobs, how do you think they would have answered if you asked them this hypothetical:

Q: A star athlete rapes one of your female students, who happens to be a cheerleader.

Do you…

A. Expel him and force him to go to another school, or
B. Tell the rape victim to like it or lump it?

Similarly, if you had asked Joe Paterno, or one of his minions (like the Penn State president) before their brains were addled and consciences rotted away by a “football is everything” culture, if they would take no action to protect children at risk after receiving credible information suggesting that a former staff member was a pedophile, is there any chance that they would have answered, “I’d give the guy a firm talking to, and tell him not to bring any of his victims on campus”?
Whole university, college and school district administrations don’t suddenly mutate into monsters overnight. Their cultures become so fogged and distorted by publicity and excitement and parents cheering and other benefits that simple considerations of right and wrong are just lost in a blur. Their ethics alarms freeze up, or if they work at all, they can’t be heard in the din of distractions. As a result, horrible things happen.

There is no ethical defense for what this school’s administrators did to “C.S.,” or what their Silsbee High School counterparts did to its raped cheerleader, “H.S.” Nor is there any ethical defense for the Penn State enablers. They were once normal, intelligent, ethical people, and tunnel vision corrupted them, until they could no longer tell right from wrong.

There are things that can be done to them now, but little that can be done for them. The only purpose in telling tales of the Penn State disease at all, really, is to keep it at bay. We all suffer from a powerful mental state known as “restraint bias,” the belief that we are less corruptible than everyone else. All the victims of the Penn State disease thought this way too, and before they knew what happened, they were convincing themselves that the best courses of action were to let child molesters run wild and make cheerleaders cheer their rapists.

If it can happen to them, it can happen to any of us.

Believe it.

___________________________________________

Pointer: Rick Jones (Thanks!)

Facts: Courthouse News

Ethics Alarms attempts to give proper attribution and credit to all sources of facts, analysis and other assistance that go into its blog posts. If you are aware of one I missed, or believe your own work was used in any way without proper attribution, please contact me, Jack Marshall, at  jamproethics@verizon.net.

9 thoughts on “Worst Sequel Ever: “Cheer Your Rapist II”

  1. Wow!

    My favorite sentence from the link was this, “the school’s athletic trainer appeared in court on behalf of K.D., to support his effort to have his ankle monitor removed so he would not be inhibited during football games.”

    What an unfortunate inconvenience. Great to know where the school’s priorities were. Absolutely disgusting.

  2. This is worse than the Texas case.

    In the Texas case, the players had not been convicted of a sex crime. This case involves findings of delinquency for indecent assault. And under juvenile law, indecent anything is a sex offense.

    Similarly, if you had asked Joe Paterno, or one of his minions (like the Penn State president)

    You have that backwards. Joe Paterno was a minion of University President Graham Spanier.

    (Of course, I do not imply that Paterno’s misdeeds, if any, can be excused by “President Spanier made me do it”.)

    • You really don’t understand how Division I football programs work, do you? When the Michigan State U. coach was reprimanded by the President, the coach went over his head to governor Blanchard and had the president severely reprimanded. It didn’t work when he tried it again with governor Engler, however.

      • You really don’t understand how Division I football programs work, do you? When the Michigan State U. coach was reprimanded by the President, the coach went over his head to governor Blanchard and had the president severely reprimanded. It didn’t work when he tried it again with governor Engler, however.

        So now the governor of Pennsylvania was part of the cover up?

        • No, but you are under the mistaken impression that the football coach reports to the University President. In practice, the football coach is independent and doesn’t report to any university official as long as he is winning. Any University President of a major football school who gets too big a head and thinks he can order the football coach around will soon learn differently.

          • Yes, all we need to know is that Penn State’s prez wanted Joe Pa to retire, and Joe said, “No.” Not “please, no,” just “No.” That tells you who was in charge of whom.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.