“Sarah, is slavery wrong? Sarah, is slavery wrong? Does this administration think that slavery was wrong? Sarah, does this administration believe slavery was wrong?”
—CNN’s April Ryan, yelling to White House spokesperson Sarah Huckabee Sanders as today’s press briefing ended. She really did.
I assume that this was intended as a rhetorical rebuttal to the position of President Trump and those non-totalitarian-minded citizens—I hope not just conservatives and Republicans— who regard toppling statues and memorials of important figures in America’s past as a form of Orwellian thought control and manipulation of the historical record. Maybe she attends Christ Church in Alexandria, Virginia.
Whatever it was, it wasn’t journalism, fair, or professional. Since Ryan knew the only answer that could or would be given, if Sander had been foolish enough to dignify the insult with a reply, it was really just partisan harassment and race-baiting, the equivalent of a reporter shouting out at a Johnson era press conference, “How many did LBJ kill today?,” calling out after a Bush briefing, “Hey, any signs of those weapons of mass destruction?,” or calling out after an Obama White House briefing, “Does the President still promise that if we like our health plan, we can keep it?”
A news organization that doesn’t immediately discipline a reporter behaves like this at a White House press briefing—and Ryan should have been suspended, removed from the White House beat, or exiled to cute kitten stories on Headline News—it is announcing one of the following:
a) This new organization will no longer apply minimal standards of respect, fairness and professionalism to coverage of this President.
b) This network no longer has any standards.
c) This network will allow gross demonstrations of bias and partisan animus by its reporters.
Under these conditions, the White House has no obligation to permit such an organization to attend press briefings, any more than it has an obligation to permit anti-Trump demonstrators to attend, or to tolerate reporters chanting slogans and carrying placards. And it should not. If CNN won’t uphold minimal standards of professional journalism, then the White House must. CNN should be told that until it receives a public apology for Ryan’s outburst, she is replaced by a trustworthy reporter, and the network pledges that it will not permit such conduct by its employees to occur again, CNN will no longer be invited to briefings. Its place will then be taken by Ethics Alarms, or Weekly Reader, or any entity with a concept of journalism ethics superior to CNN’s.
Meanwhile, while we are on the topic of professionalism, I have this to report:
Among the online accounts of Ryan’s disgraceful performance was one on Newsbusters,written by Scott Whitlock, who wrote in commenting on Ryan’s trolling,
“Generally speaking, journalists don’t scream at Democratic administrations to wonder if the present-day party supports the Trail of Tears conducted by Democrat Andrew Johnson or the pro-slavery Democrats who fought the Union in the Civil War. “
Andrew Johnson , who became President when Lincoln was assassinated, was a Republican, like Lincoln. He had nothing to do with the Trail of Tears, which occurred during the administration of Andrew Jackson, who was a Democrat, more than 30 years before Johnson was President. This post went up at 4:15 pm today, and it’s seven hours later as I write this. No one has corrected this wildly inaccurate version of American history. If I wrote something like that, I’d have ten “Jack, you idiot” e-mails or comments within an hour.
To recap, an unprofessional news network allows an openly biased and unethical reporter to engage in race-baiting at a White House press briefing, after which her conduct is critiqued by a conservative media watchdog reporter who doesn’t know the difference between Andrew Johnson and Andrew Jackson, whom he probably gets confused with Stonewall Jackson. Or Michael Jackson.
“Democracy dies in the darkness” indeed.
Sometimes I wonder why I bother….