Observations On The President’s Stupid Hurricane Map “Scandal.”

Destined to take its place in “resistance” and mainstream media obsessions along side President Trump’s stubborn misrepresentation of his inauguration crowd, the controversy over the bizarrely altered Dorian path  map was one more in a long nauseating chain of similar incidents. If you were lucky enough to miss it, here’s the scoop.

In the middle of a Labor Day tweeting frenzy, President Trump issued an erroneous tweet that Alabama would be affected by Hurricane Dorian. I have no trouble in filing this part under “Who cares?” He’s not a meteorologist, a scientist or even a relaible source of information. Over-heated and contrived complaints that his goof “endangered citizens” are just familiar Trump derangement: anyone who depends on the President for weather predictions when there are so many obviously more reliable authorities available may be doing the gene pool a favor.

Officials with the National Weather Service quickly issued a public correction, tweeting, “Alabama will NOT see any impacts from #Dorian. We repeat, no impacts from Hurricane #Dorian will be felt across Alabama. The system will remain too far east.” That should have ended it

But, in the throes of the kind of inexplicable, self-destructive, foolish impulse that we have all grown to expect and love, President Trump then appeared in a video released by the White House in which he displayed a weather forecast map, dated from 11 a.m. on Aug. 29, supposedly showing that Alabama would  be affected. The graphic appeared  to have been crudely altered with a black Sharpie, however, as you can see above.

“We had, actually, our original chart was that it was going to be hit — hitting Florida directly,” Trump says. “That was the original chart,” Trump said. “It could’ve, uh, was going towards the Gulf.”  Later, he tweeted out that chart, saying,

This was the originally projected path of the Hurricane in its early stages. As you can see, almost all models predicted it to go through Florida also hitting Georgia and Alabama. I accept the Fake News apologies!

Here’s the  chart that he tweeted:

It also includes misleading lines drawn onto the graphic.

Why, why, WHY??


1. This is another astounding self-inflicted political wound and embarrassment by President Trump, astounding only in the sense that the mind boggles that he apparently has no functioning block on such impulses. But we knew that. Didn’t we all know that? We had hope, did we not, that once he became President he would realize that he couldn’t responsibly engage in such foolishness, but that hope was quickly dashed. Remember during the campaign when he said he watched U.S. Muslims celebrating the 9-11 attacks on TV? Then he refused to back down, even after it was shown beyond a shadow of a doubt that no such scene ever was broadcast? This is the same thing. This is the heartbreak of narcissism, and the President could be the poster child for a TV fundraising campaign.

2. And yet…so what? Does this episode tell us anything new, other than “Yup, this is the same guy we elected!” No. Does the video or the chart matter, other than to those who take glee in pointing and screaming when the President does what he does? No. Is it wildly out of sync with what any previous President would do? Yes, but the fact is that this is not a substantive episode. It’s trivia, and it also is the kind of thing The Julie Principle was formulated to explain. If one has accepted reality, that this is the elected President, then one cannot rationally keep freaking out when he does stuff like this. If insanity is doing the same thing repeatedly while expecting different results, it is also being shocked over and over when a known personality behaves exactly as he always has.

3. The Trump Deranged seized on this as they have every gaffe,  botch and dumb tweet for three years, shouting, “See? See? We’re right! He’s an idiot/liar/unfit President!” Yes, we know you think that. We know you don’t comprehend that looking for excuses to denigrate your nation’s leader even when it makes the U.S. more divided and weaker while undermining the public’s belief in our institutions is unethical and destructive.  Agreed,  the whole Dorian episode is depressing: GEE, I wish Donald Trump wasn’t the way he is, but for God’s sake, don’t you realize how boring it is for those of us who do not wake up every day hating their President  to read and hear the same mantra over and over? Don’t you realize that you are modeling the same irrational behavior the President is, refusing to accept reality?

4. No, this episode is not in any way evidence that the Plan E, the 25th Amendment coup option, is justified or could be justified.  Narcissism is not a leadership disability (often it is a feature, not a bug), and a demonstration that the President is a lousy meteorologist is not germane to his ability to be an effective President.

5. Is this news? Sure. So far, only the progressive blogs and the Left-biased mainstream media have covered the story–I haven’t seen any mention of it on Fox News—and that’s one more example showing that we don’t have a trustworthy media.  I give the New York Times credit for placing the story in proper perspective, on A-16 of this morning’s paper. That’s about right.

6. The new White House Press Secretary tweeted,

What an idiot.

If he can’t come up with something better than a #22, “There are worse things” rationalization, then he should have kept quiet. Yes, the news media reaction is excessive, shows bias, and also demonstrates a lack of proportion, but that doesn’t excuse the President’s juvenile, unsettling conduct.

7.  Now the Deranged are claiming that the President violated a U.S. statute making it a crime to falsify a National Weather Service forecast and pass it off as official. I doubt that an old forecast qualifies, since the point of the law is to prevent people from deceiving the public into believing a current forecast that is fake, and good luck proving that the President personally falsified either graphic, or was even aware that they had been altered.

Nevertheless, I’m sure the “falsified weather map” will eventually find its way onto a list of “high crimes and misdemeanors” as an impeachable offense.

8. Remember this post, from February 2017?  It’s relevant again, unfortunately.

23 thoughts on “Observations On The President’s Stupid Hurricane Map “Scandal.”

  1. Kind of a leftist tempest in a teapot, isn’t it. People with narcissistic traits however will stubbornly insist that black is white in the face on contrary evidence while looking like a foolish 10 year old. It’s hardly an impeachable offense though.

  2. Hey, what did Dorian say to the Bahamas? Nothing, it just waved. What kind of detergent are they using in the Bahamas? Tide! What did the Bahamian boy do when he heard there was a hurricane outside? He went out to sea! Thank you, thank you, I’ll be here all week.

  3. The same crowd bloviating over this is the same group that blithely dismisses “G.I. Joe” Biden’s misremembered assault on Marye’s Heights or charge up San Juan Hill, or whatever wild tale he told most recently.

    • It’s also the same group that is trying very hard to ignore the fact that Biden’s left eye started to spontaneously fill with blood during the CNN town hall thing yesterday.

      One wonders if the same “nothing to see here” attitude would prevail if Trump had a similar (minor, but still concerning) medical episode on national television?

      Actually, one doesn’t wonder. One knows exactly how that would play out.

  4. I have to ask which aide provided the map used? The assumption is that the president assembles all the data and exhibits he uses to deliver a speech. I find that hard to believe. I have never witnessed a senior executive compile data or create the exhibits they use.

    When Trump visited the victims in El Paso hospitals the NYT’s reported that “unnamed White House aides called the visit a debacle”. So I wonder if these incidents are set up and Trump’s biggest weakness is to not admit he made a mistake.

    I challenge anyone to give me a few examples of where a politician ever admitted a mistake publically. Sure they make apologies but rarely admit that they were truly wrong and change their ways

  5. Since when did elite coastal lefties begin giving a rat’s ass about Alabama or its inhabitants? Or even know or care where Alabama or or any other state in the south is?

  6. In fact there is a CBS report where they show Muslims dancing on roofs on 9/11:
    As for Alabama:


    Real early out one or two of the least probable paths did cross into Alabama. Also as late as I think the 31st Alabama was still in the ‘probability cone’ for Tropical Storm force winds.

    So Trump isn’t as absolutely wrong here as the mainstream press is pretending. His big messup was taking one of the earliest forecasts (when they were all over the place) and not mentally ‘updating’ it. But he’s a busy man, and he’s the President – not a meteorologist. By the way, here’s a nice article on how hard this storm was to forecast, esp initially. Only in the past 2 days or so have things really started to simply as it left the Bahamas, shed lots of energy and got corrolled by strong upper atmospheric winds.

    • Ethics Foul. A CBS report that refers to 8 Muslims cheering on a roof in New Jersey does not “show” Muslims doing so, and it definitely doesn’t substantiate Trump’s ridiculous “And I watched in Jersey City, N.J., where thousands and thousands of people were cheering as that building was coming down. Thousands of people were cheering.”

      As for Alabama—that’s all irrelevant. The video was petty and foolish, and the Sharpie lines were incredibly dumb.

  7. My whole question here is why Trump kept focusing on Alabama. “It will hit Alabama, a great place…” or something like that. He didn’t say anything about Florida or farther up the coast. It was just about Alabama, which makes no sense. Not that anything he does makes sense. I still shake my head in wonder that this man is the President of the US.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.