Let’s Try To Remember Diahann Carroll, Shall We?

The problem is that when it comes time to honor those who have made a positive contribution to our country and culture, nobody remembers who they are. I confess, it drives me nuts. Today a medical technician revealed that she had no idea what “Ben-Hur” was. No chariot race, no galley slave scene. Well, she’s a drag on the culture. Catch up.

Actress and singer Diahann Carroll, 84, died on October 4, and her death received small and momentary notice. Yet she was another one of the brave, trail-blazing African Americans whose intelligence, charm, talent and willingness to take risks helped move the stubborn needle toward racial conciliation and away from bigotry. Of course, she was remarkable–unusually gorgeous, unusually talented, unusually intelligent. It never seemed like she set out to become a civil rights and cultural icon, but somehow the  position just found her. Most important of all, when she was given the chance to make white people think differently about black people, she did it. She also made it look easy.

Carroll was a trained singer who was cast in several musicals on Broadway, but she wasn’t content to occupy such a narrow niche. She joined Lee Strasberg’s Actors Studio, and mastered precise and elegant diction and phrasing. Shortly afterward, in 1963, Carroll earned the first of her four career Emmy nomination for using that diction portraying a teacher on ABC’s “Naked City.”

Composer Richard Rodgers spotted her during one of her frequent singing appearances on Jack Paar’s “Tonight Show” and resolved  to create a Broadway musical built around  her talents. The result was 1962’s “No Strings,” a love story revolving around an African American fashion model (Carroll) and a white novelist, played by Richard Kiley, later the original Don Quixote in “Man of La Mancha,” but now known by Gen X, if at all, as the voice on the Jurassic Park ride.


The amazing thing about “No Strings” was that the interracial romance was portrayed so casually, with race barely mentioned. Kiley and Carroll pulled the miracle off, but a better score would have helped: Rodger wrote both the lyrics and the music, since his partner Hammerstein had died. Still, Carroll won rave reviews and a Tony Award, the first given to a black woman for best actress in a lead role of a musical.

Then, in 1968, she was approached by an NBC executive to star as Julia Baker, a widowed nurse raising a young son, on the sit-com “Julia. She became  the first African American female to star in a non-stereotypical role in her own prime time network series. Before her, black actresses mostly played maids.

Julia’s husband had died in Vietnam. Educated and outspoken, she worked for a crusty old white doctor (Lloyd Nolan) at an aerospace company. Later, she told an interviewer, “We were saying to the country, ‘We’re going to present a very upper middle-class black woman raising her child, and her major concentration is not going to be about suffering in the ghetto.”

No, Bill Cosby was not the trailblazer in this respect…and Diahann Carroll never raped anyone, either.

Carroll had a rich career, getting an Academy Award nomination for her title-role performance in “Claudine” (1974), playing a Harlem woman on welfare who raises six children and has a romance with   a garbage collector played by James Earl Jones. In the Eighties, she played Dominique Deveraux, the first major African American character on a prime time soap opera, for three seasons on ABC’s Dynasty and its spinoff The Colbys. She was, by her estimation,  “the first black bitch on television.”

Diahann Carroll left show business and the culture  better, more diverse and accepting than when she entered them. She made a difference. We owe her. She deserves to be remembered.

16 thoughts on “Let’s Try To Remember Diahann Carroll, Shall We?

  1. Diahann Carroll left show business and the culture better, more diverse and accepting than when she entered them. She made a difference. We owe her. She deserves to be remembered.

    She most certainly does. The question is this: given the progressive imperative to balkanize and purposely re-segregate in the name of wokeness, will she?

    I’m usually more optimistic than I am this evening. Not sure why, exactly. But tonight, my answer to the question is “probably not. At least not for a generation.”

    And to hell with those so embittered, blinded and ignorant that that’s the case.

  2. Thanks for this, Jack. Hidden in plain sight [if one wishes to search for it, which you so wonderfully did], among all the bad news with which we’re bombarded, there are these quiet stories of human dignity and virtue. Great lives lived. What Aristotle called arete,ἀρετή. I remember when the show Julia came on and how excited I was to watch it, more than 50 years ago.

  3. The character of Julia was a role model for me. No wallowing in angst. No bitterness. There was the appropriate smack down when needed. The discussion of the painting of Washington Crossing the Delaware was a lesson I took to heart. Patriotism is for us all. Thank you Diahann Caroll.

  4. I watched “Julia” quite often then. I never really thought much of the race issues but I could identify with Corey’s (Julias son) problems as we were close in age. To me she was just another actress in a TV show. When I saw her death notice earier this month it did bring back memories of that TV show.

  5. I had no idea who she was, and the only reference I could get from her work above was Dynasty (which my aunt watched religiously). As always, I appreciate you bringing this up and helping a little bit on my cultural education.

  6. I remember Diahann Carroll very well. She was a fixture in entertainment culture during my youth and young adulthood, and I have nothing but good memories of her.

    She will be missed.

  7. I think I’m going to pull out my “Man of La Mancha” Broadway cast CD tomorrow. It’s been awhile.

    I’m so surprised at Black women who are unfamiliar with some of the trailblazers. I have a former co-worker and Facebook friend who is constantly posting about inspirational black women. I shared the story of Minnie Cox with her and she was quite appreciative.

    The low-key work of Diahann Carroll, who just wanted to present Blacks as they should be, will be sorely missed.

  8. Indeed, the original stage directions for “No Strings” say: “The part of Barbara Woodruff in “NO STRINGS” is designed to be played by an American colored girl in her early twenties. It is proposed that she also be beautiful, and have style, and wear clothes well; be intelligent, witty, warmly human, and wise. The play itself never refers to her color.”

  9. Is anyone else wondering what’s going on with Jack? It’s not like him to drop out of sight for this long without saying something or declaring open forum.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.