“Yesterday, Kelly Clarkson visited us in Brooklyn and inquired about buying ‘Molly,’ a one-of-a-kind singing and dancing bird automaton who plays an important role in the magic shows we host here,” the post reads. “Molly is permanently attached to the wall and isn’t for sale. However, the negative experience Kelly described on twitter would resonate with anyone who has ever felt judged in a shop. At Art of Play whether someone comes in to make a purchase or simply look around for a while, they are equally welcome. We greet everyone who walks in the door with the invitation to ‘pick things up and play.’ And they do, many stay for hours enjoying our puzzles, games and toys. Imagine our surprise when our small local business was suddenly attacked by 8 million people who have never visited our store. It’s been a surreal experience to be the focus of such widespread outrage after just one mention by a celebrity. Thanks to all our friends for their support and welcome to all the curious folks who have discovered us amidst the drama. We’re going to keep our heads down and hopefully, we can clear things up with Kelly someday. As a talented popular singer once said ‘what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.’”
That’s a pretty well-argued case, but the dispute quickly turned into a “she said-he said.” Clarkson replied,
“Cool, cool. Sure, it wasn’t for sale,” she wrote. “That’s the narrative Art of Play is gonna go with 👍 so the whole conversation we had when I asked you if it was for sale whilst pointing to the price tag hanging on the wall with the title Singing Bird didn’t happen as you elevator eyed me saying in a condescending tone ‘yes, it’s for sale but it costs 15,000 dollars so if you’d like me to find something comparable for you I can.’ That all never happened and now it’s not for sale. Okay, cool. So you’re not only rude, you’re also a liar. Got it ✅.And by the way, I obviously support small businesses because I was literally at a small business trying to purchase things. I love small businesses and know they are important and I always support them, but you don’t get a free pass to treat people less than in your store just because you are a small business. It’s not that hard to be kind. I never blast people but you my friend were an exception.”

Oooh. If Kelly is correct about the price tag, and she would be foolish to make that up, she wins the round. The store’s owner is lying when he should be apologizing.
Ethics Verdicts:
- John Paul asks if Kelly was “punching down.” Any customer who is mistreated in an establishment has not only a right but an obligation to address the problem. Furthermore, a celebrity’s social media complaint about bad service will have more impact than a complaint from, well, me, with my 5 followers. Being a celebrity shouldn’t prevent someone from expressing resentment in public. Yes, she has a big megaphone. But that’s an incentive for a store to train its staff to act as if every visitor has a big microphone.
- Kelly’s first move should have been to complain to management before going public. There’s no indication that she did. That’s unfair.
- Her objection has the faint whiff of “Do you know who I am?” about it, and “How dare they treat me like that! I’m Kelly Clarkson!” It’s still valid though.
- The store apparently has never heard of The Streisand Effect. The owner seems to think this is good publicity. It’s not: John Paul notes that the owner had proved himself “to be a jerk.” And why would he think a social media feud with a singing star is “keeping his head down”?
For the record, I have received the “Pretty Woman” treatment several times. In every instance, I settled the issue on the spot, demanding to talk to a supervisor or management, and making a vocal protest until I did. In a couple of cases, I got a directed apology from the offending clerk.
I had a similar instance years ago at a car dealership. I was shopping for a new diesel pickup truck after work, so I was still in my work clothes. I ran a maintenance shop at a paper mill at the time so my jacket and boots had some dirt on them. I asked the salesman to show me new trucks. He told me they were expensive and insisted on showing me used ones even though I repeatedly asked to see new trucks. I finally got tired of the guy’s condescension and told him I would shop elsewhere. I purchased a new truck from another dealer. About a week later, a salesman from the first dealer call to tell me they had some more used trucks for me to see. After I got done laughing at him, I let him know I had purchased a new $100k truck from another dealer and let him know about the treatment I had received that caused me to look elsewhere. Too bad for them.
Samson slew ~1000 Philistines with the jawbone of an a$$, salespeople kill many a sale with the same weapon…
Sales Rule #1: NEVER prejudge a prospect.
PWS
If it were me (and it wouldn’t be because I am not: a) a truck guy; or b) a $100,000 car guy), I would have gone in, parked my $100,000 truck in the front of the lot and, repeatedly say, I am not trading my truck in for THAT!
-Jut
Farmer joke: A city slicker drives his brand-new Mercedes-Benz off the road into a ditch. The farmer drives up on his tractor and offers to pull the Benz out of the ditch. Outraged, the city slicker scoffs, saying, “You’re not going to pull my eighty-thousand-dollar car with that thing!” To which the farmer responds before driving off, “You’re right. I’m not going to tow your car with my two-hundred- and fifty-thousand-dollar tractor.”
Thanks, Jack. I appreciate this.
I think on some level a lot of us have gone through the pretty woman treatment. In my first year in China, my wife and I did a tour of Beijing that was going to take us to the Great Wall. Part of the tour took us to a jade shop where the guy was giving a presentation (no clue what he was saying, wasn’t fluent yet) and after he noticed we were the only white people he looks at us and ask us something. I told him ‘ting bu dong (a common phrase for tourists in China that translates to “Listen, but don’t understand), and he started mocking me. Still no clue what he was saying (he repeated back to me what I said to him, so I know he was mocking), but several of the Chinese tourists started laughing.
I said in English that I hoped someone there could speak English well enough to translate, because the very fact I was in his country was proof I had money, and it wasn’t a good idea to make fun of his potential customers. My wife and I left after that. Always wondered what happened to that guy and if he ever learned what I said.
I was thinking about a scene in Breakfast at Tiffany were Holly Golightly (Audrey Hepburn) is condescended to by snooty and overly proper sales people.
There are certain stores and brands that are highly desired and priced because of its exclusivity. This aura of exclusivity requires that the products are only sold to people of the right class (“old money”) to retain its exclusive cachet. The status of some brands is dependent on the social status of the buyers. The exclusivity of the brand allows for extremely high margins.
There are people who have money but lack class, such as reality TV stars (“The Real Housewives of …”). Other folks act rich, but need financing. These category of customers bring down the status of the brand. As examples, Gucci and Louis Vuitton used to be exclusive, but these brands have lost their luster as too many people who want to look rich are wearing it.
It’s funny how the term “exclusive” has been completely warped by its use in marketing. Of course, it literally means, “having the quality to keep out.” But it gets turned into meaning “something desirable and even admirable.”
“It’s funny how the term ‘exclusive’ has been completely warped by its use in marketing.”
John Cleese once quipped about a sports car “that is so exclusive that none are being made.”
PWS
“Nobody goes there anymore. It’s too crowded.”
And congrats, Paulie. Is the delirium beginning to subside at all?
“Is the delirium beginning to subside at all?”
HALE no…not one (1) whit!
PWS
During my days picking mid-century modern furnishings I became familiar with a shop owner who dealt in and repaired vintage lamps. Peter’s store in Phoenix was called “Modern Lighting.” Our son came to call Peter “The Lamp Nazi” after “The Soup Nazi” in “Seinfeld. While in the shop, more often than not I’d see him run off customers. In his defense, I think most of the “customers” were young kids who wanted to just ogle the inventory, for which he had absolutely no patience. But it was comical. He was invariably incredibly rude. “No lamps for you!”
From what I had gathered of this scenario, the store had the $15,000 tag up for 1 of 2 reasons.
The Store’s Claim: It’s a semi-ridiculous price but if someone shows interest, that pricepoint indicates the shopper is a serious inquirer and the store can direct them to the artist that made it; and thus can commission a similar piece.
The Conspiracy Theory: By placing a price tag, the piece is no longer subject to some kind of arcane Brooklyn permitting and valuation scheme for non-merchandise art installations. By making it “available”, the store somehow benefited by classifying it as merchandise.
All of that to say, the store handled it improperly. Security camera footage later released showed Kelly come in, shop a few items, talk with a shopkeeper for a few moments and he moves on to other customers. Kind of a “busy day” vibe, but her account of what happened was fully supported. She then reverse-shops the items she had picked up and leaves the store as she reaches for her phone. Time-stamps then line up to her immediately posting about her experience.
The shop initially said there was no price tag on the wall. Then they admitted there was one and they replaced it with a tag that now says $15 Million.
Notable to me is that the shop owner is a guy named Adam Rubin who is an author of childrens picture books that I read to my daughter when she was younger. “Dragons Love Tacos”, “Secret Pizza Party”, and “Dragons Love Tacos 2: The Sequel”.
It’s really unfortunate that the shopkeeper interacted with Kelly in a way that did not properly convey the true situation with the bird. That Kelly let herself accept the victim status rather than continuing the conversation in person to resolve the situation. That the shop owner initially responded online with half-truths and deception in order to hit back rather than giving a full proper explanation and accepting some responsibility for the situation. A proper PR response would have threaded this needle perfectly, but they missed the mark just enough that it further fanned the flames into a Streisand Effect rather than “rising to the occassion” of a viral moment.
The whole thing is maybe not an Ethics Trainwreck…but maybe an Ethics Debacle.
Totally a product of the internet. A non-event. But for the internet, this would have never seen the light of day and would have been forgotten or dealt with personally at the time.
Yikes, Tim! You must have the most pristine sock drawer on the planet! Thanks for this extra intelligence: so the shop defaulted to the “Joke excuse”! “All right, there was a price tag, but we didn’t think anyone would take it seriously.” And security footage!
The store and its owner deserve every bit of bad publicity and loss of customer trust they get, and whether it comes at the hands of Kelly Clarkson or Birdie McBirdface doesn’t matter one whit.
What’s the story about the guy with the powerful telescopes and still not seeing any level of care for a particular disappointment?
That’s me. I don’t care about Kelly Clarkson. I don’t care about this store. I have no concern one way or another about this story. I hate Julia Roberts and everything she has been in and I am lukewarm on Richard Gere. So, no. I don’t care. I have spent way too much time on this story by writing this little missive than I should have already and clearly intend to move on to more interesting things.
jvb
Of course, the justification for paying attention to these otherwise trivial controversies is that they can convey important ethical lessons and principles. In this case:
1. Fix the problem.
2. Fixing the problem isn’t “punching down” if it makes the world a better place by teaching an ethics lesson.
3. When you screw up, admit it, make amends, apologize, and move on.
4. It’s the cover-up that often makes things worse than the original offense.
5. Treat everyone with respect until they prove they don’t deserve it.
6. Deal directly with people and organizations in disputes before going public.
Yeah, I’m online a bit too much. The latest trend is Walt Z, the Red Baron employee who fell victim to being rage baited by a social media influencer…who has just had a go fund me in support of him hit $500k. Red Baron Pizza has issued a statement in support of him and people are vowing to buy Red Baron frozen pizzas.
Or maybe we shift to the EU-backed Polish Prime Minister who waited for the Polish President to be on a plane to Senegal and then started a coup and taken control of the Constitutional Tribunal. Exciting times indeed.
coup-de-greys ?
That’s what I got when I asked google for the right spelling. Looked funny to me too. Crap. Can’t trust anyone or any thing. I wrote “gras” as WP flagged it as wrong. “grace”? Screw it, and screw French. I’ll find an English equivalent.
That was the least of my typos, at it turns out. Just fixed them all.
coup de grâce?
Oui 😉
I initially thought it was a communication problem. My assumption was that the store was willing to connect her with the bird’s maker who has another one just like it and would sell it for $15,000, but it was in the store’s best interest to sell her something they have in the store rather than something that would have to be special ordered and which she might be more likely to change her mind about before receiving it. Sell what’s in stock is Retail 101. Still, I could see where she might have felt slighted.
But, my opinion of the interaction changed after I watched the store’s security video. I think it was less of a misunderstanding on both parts and more that she was acting like a spoiled brat.
She was dressed like everyone else there and like the store’s employees. She talked to the employee (owner?) about the bird. He went in one direction to show her what they have in stock, she turned her back on him and went to look at something in the back of the store. This is not how to act if you really want a specific item. You let the salesperson show you the other thing, then you tell him that you really want the first bird. Most people only deal with this sort of thing when they’re buying a car. You want to special order, the salesman wants to sell something that’s on the lot.
On her way out, she ranted at a different employee. People near the cash register turned to look at her. She posted online about it less than 15 minutes after leaving the store. I think she overreacted.
Video Bonus, you can see the birds that the store was trying to sell her that day. All of the birds are wonders of engineering. And tacky looking.
Overreaction by ms Clarkson, certainly. This should all have been handled in the store, in the moment. There was no need to try to harm this small business, even if they were a little bit rude – an unknown at this point.
Richard Gere was not annoying in the Jackal – one of the very few movies in which my boy Bruce plays the villain!
But the movie was. If you are going to remake a flat-out classic, you better have a good reason other than “it will be fun to see Jack Black’s arm blown off.”
Will you think less of me if I say ‘that was awesome!”?
Yes.
Never mind ……..
Don’t fret. I thought that scene was gratuitously wonderful.
jvb
Yes but did you catch my Emily Litella?
You know I did. She’s in my Clip archive!
Such a sweetheart, funny, girl-next-door beauty. She was taken way too young.
A life lesson: Gilda refused to get medical treatment until it was too late. Denial kills.
Much has been said here that sis good food for thought about how to be a better customer or be a better purveyor of service.
I can’t shake the sense that Clarkson’s objection and action to flame the store is based more in entitlement and a desire for attention than on disrespect of her by the store staff. Are there other reports that the store’s assertion of welcome is false?
is false?
is false?
Do we have audio and facial expressions of store staff or Clarkson by which we could really render a judgement against either ? Even the tone of Clarkson’s post has a gossipy Karen tone.
So far, I am now all the more curious about this Art of Play store.