
When I saw the headline on The Ethicist’s weekly New York Times column: “Is It Wrong to Leave My 85-Year-Old Mother Alone on Thanksgiving?” I thought, “Wait, is this the Onion making fun of The Ethicist?” No, “Name Withheld” really submitted that question, and Kwame Anthony Appiah, who has been The New York Times Magazine’s Ethicist columnist since 2015 and teaches philosophy at N.Y.U., really thought it was worthy of publication. The inquirer writes in part,
“…The concern here is that my sibling is going out of town for Thanksgiving with his family. My spouse and I would also like to go away for the first holiday we’ve had to ourselves in a long time! But there’s my mother. She’s pretending our proposed getaway is perfectly fine with her and that she’ll find some way to spend the holiday, but she’s clearly not looking forward to it. I’m torn between thinking, She’s a big girl, she’ll manage, and thinking that my spouse and I should suck it up this year and have Thanksgiving with my mother, and then maybe next year things will be different. I’d appreciate your thoughts.”
What the hell? Mom’s not a “big girl,” she’s an old girl, and at 85, every Thanksgiving, heck, every day could be her last. “Suck it up”? SUCK IT UP????? All the mother has is her family, and her children are choosing to leave her alone in her twilight years on the American holiday that symbolizes loving families.
Here is the brain-dead response from The Ethicist, which I am publishing in all its unethical, incompetent glory:
Cue Jason Alexander: “Would that be wrong?”
That is what I was thinking. This seems like a Seinfeld episode. I never liked Seinfeld. It just seemed like New Yorkers acting like New Yorkers to me, not humor. Answers like this one just reinforce in my mind the stereotype of a New Yorker as callous, narcissistic, and cruel. When people complain about the way Donald Trump acts, I point out that he is the quintessential New Yorker and this question and answer are good examples of it.
The “Not that there’s anything wrong with that” episode I rank as one of the top 20 sitcom episodes of all time. The Chinese restaurant and ‘Magic Loogie” episodes would be in my top 50. The show was indeed about four unethical, selfish, irredeemable people, but was unusually well-performed (Jerry was the weak link) and Michael Richards was one of the top physical comics ever.
The so-called ethicist is trying to cover every base and most of the time that might be helpful. Not in this case.
When escaping CA we specifically moved to NM because our daughter is here. It is a blue state, after all, and we don’t need more of that craziness. But it is a rural, poor state and won’t soon have enough money to be as stupid as California.
Normally we spend holidays with our daughter and any other family who can join us. If we go to Louisiana or Arizona or California, or stay home here in new Mexico, that’s fine with us – we’re with family. I hope to be 85 some day, spending my holidays with family as always. They’ll strap me to the top of the car if there’s no other room ….
“National Lampoon’s Vacation” reference?
Yes – good catch.
Imogene Coca’s most immortal film role if you don’t count the “Your Show of Shows” compilation.
How old is the person sending the question? Do they not see their own future staring them in the face? They write, “She’s a big girl, she’ll manage, and thinking that my spouse and I should suck it up this year and have Thanksgiving with my mother, and then maybe next year things will be different.” Obviously, the most likely difference will be that mom will be dead. Somehow, that doesn’t seem to be clear to the writer. Why not spend the holiday with mom and then go away some other time?
Yes, one would think this aspect of the issue would be evident…
And the cat’s in the cradle….
My comment disappeared. Is it in spam?
The Ethicist’s response seems insane. There is this pretend-weighing of options, but so many obvious alternatives are left undiscussed. Why can’t the travel happen another time? Why can’t writer and hubby enjoy the long weekend at home and spend several hours with mom? Why can’t mom come along and have her own room? If you’re rich enough to travel on one of the busiest and most expensive weekends, you’re rich enough to not exclude your mother.
Good options, Tony.