Holiday Ethics: Perhaps The Easiest Question “The Ethicist” Has Ever Been Asked—And He Botches It!!!!

Your mother would be happier if you all spent Thanksgiving at home together; you and your spouse would be happier if you spent the holiday elsewhere. There’s no solution, then, that will be best for everyone. In circumstances like these, the ideal is for the parties to discuss the options. You’ve done that. And your mother has offered, in effect, to give up her preferred option so you can have yours. It would be a mistake to suppose that, because she’s your mother and you’re her child, her wishes must always come second. (Or first, depending on your cultural assumptions.) But it would also be a mistake to deny her the opportunity to make a generous choice. If that’s what she’s doing, you can accept her offer with gratitude.

There are some psychological complications worth considering, though. Even with your mother’s blessing, you may spend Thanksgiving guiltily imagining her alone. Then again, if you cancel your trip out of a sense of duty, you may resent your mother, and she may sense it. What was supposed to be a gift could turn into a cheerless occasion for you both. You’ll want to think about the prospective emotional costs of your going … and of your not going.

On balance, I’m inclined to think you should take the trip. But you should also give some thought to what your mother might enjoy doing that day. Perhaps she has friends she could spend it with, or perhaps there’s an event at her residence she’d welcome attending. You might help her make plans, and have her over for a family celebration of your own on another day.

There’s a larger question here, of course. Your mother moved across the country with the expectation of having a fuller family life, and things haven’t worked out as she hoped. You and your sibling should consider how you can help her build a more satisfying life where she now lives. That’s a good deal more important than whether you’re together on the fourth Thursday in November.

Kwame seems to think Mom is 64. The woman is 85! Eight-Five. Four Score years and five. The life expectancy of an American woman is 81. This holiday may be her last. “Discuss the options?” My mother would have been crushed if my sister and I even considered leaving her alone on Thanksgiving. There were no “options,” nor should there be. Being with Mom and/or Dad on Thanksgiving is the least that loving offspring can do when parents are hale, hearty, and have a lively social life. When they have one foot in the metaphorical grave, the decision should be automatic.

The Ethicist’s advice is a cornucopia of dunderheadedness. “Even with your mother’s blessing, you may spend Thanksgiving guiltily imagining her alone,” Kwame writes. Did he even have a mother? I know what “blessings” like that sound like: “Oh, don’t worry about me..I’m sure I’ll be fine, probably. I don’t want to be a burden, and you have your own family to care about. I’m just grateful whenever you can make time for me…I’ll just watch “It’s a Wonderful Life” on TV here alone.” How about “guiltily imagining” her dead? And what kind of jerk resents his or her 85-year-old mother for wanting to have Thanksgiving with her family?

There’s a larger question here, all right. When is the Times going to figure out that they have a dud for an ethics advice columnist? This week’s question would be an excellent interview test for potential replacements. Ask each how they would advise the writer of “Is It Wrong to Leave My 85-Year-Old Mother Alone on Thanksgiving?”, and time how long it takes for each candidate to say, “Of course it is!” And if one says, “It depends,” or “Maybe,” or “Tough one…,” end the interview and wish them success in their future endeavors.

13 thoughts on “Holiday Ethics: Perhaps The Easiest Question “The Ethicist” Has Ever Been Asked—And He Botches It!!!!”

    • That is what I was thinking. This seems like a Seinfeld episode. I never liked Seinfeld. It just seemed like New Yorkers acting like New Yorkers to me, not humor. Answers like this one just reinforce in my mind the stereotype of a New Yorker as callous, narcissistic, and cruel. When people complain about the way Donald Trump acts, I point out that he is the quintessential New Yorker and this question and answer are good examples of it.

      • The “Not that there’s anything wrong with that” episode I rank as one of the top 20 sitcom episodes of all time. The Chinese restaurant and ‘Magic Loogie” episodes would be in my top 50. The show was indeed about four unethical, selfish, irredeemable people, but was unusually well-performed (Jerry was the weak link) and Michael Richards was one of the top physical comics ever.

  1. The so-called ethicist is trying to cover every base and most of the time that might be helpful. Not in this case.

    When escaping CA we specifically moved to NM because our daughter is here. It is a blue state, after all, and we don’t need more of that craziness. But it is a rural, poor state and won’t soon have enough money to be as stupid as California.

    Normally we spend holidays with our daughter and any other family who can join us. If we go to Louisiana or Arizona or California, or stay home here in new Mexico, that’s fine with us – we’re with family. I hope to be 85 some day, spending my holidays with family as always. They’ll strap me to the top of the car if there’s no other room ….

  2. How old is the person sending the question? Do they not see their own future staring them in the face? They write, “She’s a big girl, she’ll manage, and thinking that my spouse and I should suck it up this year and have Thanksgiving with my mother, and then maybe next year things will be different.” Obviously, the most likely difference will be that mom will be dead. Somehow, that doesn’t seem to be clear to the writer. Why not spend the holiday with mom and then go away some other time?

  3. The Ethicist’s response seems insane. There is this pretend-weighing of options, but so many obvious alternatives are left undiscussed. Why can’t the travel happen another time? Why can’t writer and hubby enjoy the long weekend at home and spend several hours with mom? Why can’t mom come along and have her own room? If you’re rich enough to travel on one of the busiest and most expensive weekends, you’re rich enough to not exclude your mother.

Leave a Reply