In his Comment of the Day this morning, history-besotted commenter Steve-O-in NJ writes regarding the question of whether Biden, as the Washington Post ludicrously claimed in an editorial, is a “huge” upgrade over President Trump, “Biden is so far headed for being 46th of 46.”
From a purely academic perspective, having a clear and unequivocal Worst President Ever would be useful for future ranking purposes, just as George Washington has been an invaluable role model against whom all of his successors must be compared. However, the operative words regarding Biden are “is headed.” It would be unfair, not to mention foolish, to grade Biden as the worst of the worst before he has even served half his term. True, there is little reason for optimism, but the President generally regarded as sharing the Top POTUS title with George, Honest Abe, was looking like a national disaster at this point in his first term.
How do we assess which of our leaders was “the worst”? Without objective standards, any ranking is going to be poisoned by bias and partisanship. When I first began studying the Presidency, Jack Kennedy’s house historian and shameless boot-licker and old New Dealer Arthur Schlesinger Jr. was considered the authority on the subject. He essentially ranked all the Democrats he could as “great” or “near great” and saved the low rankings for Republicans. He even rated Woodrow Wilson, a true villain in U.S. history, as “great.”
This was the beginning of my distrust of historians that has only grown since.
This series has to be shorter than the topic requires, so I will aim at providing a solid foundation. First we need to settle on who the contenders for Worst President Ever are. I’ll disqualify some along the way. Here are the possibilities among our first ten Presidents:






