This Is How Our Educational System Teaches Students Not To Challenge Authority

hazel-tweet

Hazel Juco, a 17-year-old student at John Glenn High School in suburban Detroit, went to the school’s bathroom to wash her hands. When she turned on the faucet, ugly brown water came out. She then used her cell-phone to take the picture above of the discolored water and posted it to Facebook and Twitter.

Juco says she was soon called to the principal’s office shortly after she posted the photo.“They told me I was being suspended… It’s inappropriate use of electronics in the restroom. And every girl takes selfies in the bathroom and makes it their profile pictures and no one has gotten in trouble,” she said. Indeed, that policy, it has been noted, didn’t seem to apply to the many students in the school whose cell phone use didn’t involve exposing health hazards that school administrators should not allow to exist.

Thanks to social media, the school’s outrageous conduct didn’t remain an internal matter, as it would have in an earlier era. Hazel’s photos were widely circulated, and eventually the news media became involved. After all, this is Michigan, and there was that little episode involving inept elected officials and agency administrators poisoning the Flint water supply just a few months back. Hazel Juco was hardly being an alarmist.

When reporters called Wayne-Westland Community Schools Superintendent Dr. Michele Harmala, and she said school administrators made a mistake by not reporting the water issue to maintenance, and the rule against students taking pictures in bathrooms was misapplied, since Juco was taking photos of polluted water rather than students using the toilet. It’s an easy mistake to make! Anyone could make it!

Sure.

The deteriorating  pipe leading to the faucet is being replaced, and the suspension has been expunged from Juco’s record. How nice. Nonetheless, the fascist, incompetent and abusive administrators remain in their jobs, and though Hazel’s unjust punishment has been retracted, the message sent by it remains. The school has taught the lesson that it is dangerous to speak out, perilous to blow the whistle, and risky to point out the deficiencies of those with power.

Unless the counter-message is sent that Hazel did the right thing, and that serious career consequences await administrators and teachers who seek to cover up their own ineptitude by intimidating students, these episodes will continue.

 

4 Comments

Filed under Childhood and children, Citizenship, Education, Environment, Ethics Alarms Award Nominee, Facebook, Leadership, Social Media

4 responses to “This Is How Our Educational System Teaches Students Not To Challenge Authority

  1. crella

    Showing it to school staff would have been better. The school sees the photo of a problem for the first time on Facebook…I can see them feeling like they were caught with their pants down. She’s a high school student, surely she could have gone to the office and showed them the picture. If she got stonewalled, and the school brushed her off, then go to social media. She didn’t give them a chance to address it. The school was wrong in its reaction, there’s no mistake about that, but I don’t think posting it was the best choice.

    • I agree, it wasn’t, but she’s 17. She also wanted, I suspect, to warn as many parents and fellow students as possible. An ethical school would have thanked her, but pointed out that she should have alerted them first.

      Their conduct made her distrust seem like a good call in hindsight.

  2. I find it very hard to believe that the administration did not know about brown water coming out of the sink faucet. The administration punished her for embarrassing them by showing their incompetence and lack of attention to school conditions.

    jvb

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s