The 2019 Oscar “In Memoriam” Snubs [UPDATED!]

Ethics Alarms has been cataloguing the infuriating omissions from the Oscar “In Memoriam” segment for several years. Why does it matter? Well, curtain calls are important to me, as are the lives of major film artists generally. I believe that the final bows of those screen artists who perished during the year have been earned with blood, sweat, tears, crippling anxieties and addictions, and their families and fans want to see that last acknowledgment from the industry they toiled for. Once the fleeting clip of a dead actress, actor or other movie figure is over, each recedes slowly in the culture’s memory to eventual oblivion, which is the real death for the once-famous.

There is no good reason they shouldn’t get that final moment. The inexplicable omissions, and there are several every year, are not oversights. They are deliberate. The Academy knows who died, and a complete list is on its website. The whole segment takes only a few minutes. Last night’s version, like the rest of the streamlined broadcast, was less leisurely than usual, but adding in the fallen few left out would have made no difference to the whole comparable to the insults and cruelty it would have avoided.

Here were 2019’s most upsetting “In Memoriam” snubs:

Stanley Donen

How hard would it have been to include a quick clip from “Singin’ in the Rain,” the all-time classic he directed with Gene Kelly, perhaps the most entertaining movie of all? Donen, who received a Lifetime Achievement Oscar, also directed “Charade,” “Damn Yankees,” and many other important films, including “Two For The Road,” a clip of which was shown to mark the passing of Albert Finney, who was, quite properly, accorded the honor of the last bow in this “In Memoriam.”

The excuse given for Donen’s snub was that he died last Tuesday. There was time to add him; of course there was. The producers just didn’t care enough to make the effort.

Sandra Locke

This one was especially cruel. If you know anything about the way Clint Eastwood treated Locke, his long-time live-in girlfriend and his frequent co-star, you are probably not quite as big a fan of Clint as you might be otherwise. Locke was very good when she had decent material to work with. Her film debut in 1968’s The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter  got her nominated for an Academy Award  for Best Supporting Actress, and she starred in many films, the most successful with Eastwood. From October 1975 until April 1989, Locke she lived with actor.   Locke had two abortions in that period, then had a tubal ligation, stating in her autobiography that her decision to have the procedures was due to Eastwood’s insistence that their art and lifestyle wouldn’t allow parenthood. Eastwood, meanwhile, secretly fathered another woman’s two children during the last three years of their relationship.

Nice guy.

Eastwood ended the virtual marriage with Locke when he changed the locks on their Bel-Air home. Locke filed a palimony suit, and after a year-long legal battle, the parties reached a settlement in which Eastwood set up a film development/directing deal for Locke at Warner Bros. in exchange for her dropping the action. (Clint also got married, after refusing to marry Locke during all of those years together.) Locke sued Eastwood for fraud in 1995, alleging that the deal with Warner was a sham. The studio had rejected all of the 30 or more projects she proposed and never used her as a director. She also claimed that Eastwood had, in essence, blacklisted her.  Eastwood settled out of court for an undisclosed amount.  Locke brought a separate action against Warner Bros. for conspiring with Eastwood, and this also was settled.

I got the horrible feeling that Locke’s snub was somehow a continuation of the industry’s mistreatment of Locke, who barely worked again after Clint dumped her.

Vern Troyer

Surely playing a famous and iconic character three times should be worth something. Troyer was Mini-Me in the Austin Powers films, but he was also a hard-working little person, one of the small actors who make so many special characters possible on screen. Did you know that he played the Squid Baby in “Men in Black?” Like most sufferers of dwarfism, Troyer died young, but he had a productive career, and attention should have been paid.

Gary Kurtz

How in the world can Oscar justify not noting the passing of the producer of the original “Star Wars,” “The Empire Strikes Back,”and “American Graffitti”?

Dick Miller

Miller is exactly the kind of actor the “In Memoriam” segment is most crucial for: a prolific character actor whose face was familiar from dozens of roles in movies and TV but who almost nobody could name.  He had 181 credits, including both “Gremlins” films and “Terminator” (he’s about to be killed by Arnold in the photo above.)

John Mahoney

Another inexplicable omission, Mahoney was one of the very best character actors extant long before he got the role he was most identified with, “Frasier’s” ex-cop father (and Jack Russell Terrier lover.) Mahoney palyed the manager of the Black Sox in “Eight Men Out,” Olympia Dukakis’s illicit gentleman friend in “Moonstruck,” plus substantial roles in “Tin Men,” “The American President,’ and other major films.

By far the worst omission, however, was…

Carol Channing

The Academy’s excuse would be that she’s Broadway royalty but was a mere Hollywood visitor. Nevertheless, Channing was nominated for an Academy Award for her one major film, Thoroughly Modern Millie. That, combined with the fact that she is one of musical comedy’s all-time greatest stars as well as one of the most memorable personalities in American show business history (and was robbed of another screen triumph when Gene Kelly foolishly cast a too-young Barbra Streisand to star in “Hello Dolly!”)  should have at least earned her a few seconds of respect on the Oscars.


UPDATE: I left out the great R. Lee Ermey (Pointer: Inquiring Mind)…

R. Lee Ermey

This snub is suspicious. Ermey was a major niche player in films, the ultimate drill sergeant. A former Marine sergeant, he nailed down that role in Kubrick’s “Full Metal Jacket,” and was praised by all critics. He played similar characters several times, most amusingly as the voice of the head toy GI in all three”Toy Story” films. He was more than a one trick pony, though, effective as, for example, the racist mayor in “Mississippi Burning.” His voice was so immediately recognizable that he supplied the voices of sergeants in animated features and videogames.

Ermey claimed that his career in films essentially ended once he expressed politically conservative views in an interview.  Political animus is the only reason I can think of for snubbing him at the Oscars. He was also missed in most of the film web sites that flagged the “In Memoriam” snubs.



22 thoughts on “The 2019 Oscar “In Memoriam” Snubs [UPDATED!]

  1. Clint Eastwood. An asshole’s asshole. Even as an eighth grader I failed to see the attraction in spaghetti westerns. Bored the hell out of me and the production quality was pathetic. They just looked cheap. And completely pointless.

    • His characters always had a grittier-morally-compromised-John-Wayne feel in my opinion – like he existed to fill the needs of people who want cool manliness without manly principles harshing their mellow. My understanding of both men’s filmographies is so far from comprehensive that I’d abandon that hill if challenged like a Frenchman in a World War (I’m part French, so that’s not racist; cowardice is our word). From these past few EA posts, it’s interesting to find that my vague, unfair comparison mostly bears out in their off-screen personas.

      It reminds me of the time that a certain Siberian I knew confirmed the stereotype my brother and I concocted as children from patterns in movie depictions that everything in Russia is made of concrete.

      • There’s a hint of a sociopath in many of Clint’s characters. Eastwood has become a better actor as he aged. Grand Torino is a fine performance, for example. He’s also a major director, though some of his films feel slack to me.

      • There’s a very beloved Soviet romcom/holiday movie whose starting premise is “everything in Russia is made of concrete”.

        • It’s called the “Irony of Fate” (1976), where a man who gets really drunk with his friends on New Year’s Eve gets accidentally sent to Leningrad (he’s from Moscow), and he tells the taxi driver his street address, and lo and behold, there is an exact same street address in Leningrad. Hi jinks ensue.

          • Including a drunk, sad, existential shower monologue from the heroine’s ex, because Soviet romcom hijinks did not quite look like US ones.

    • I’ll never look at him in quite the same way after reading Jack’s description of his treatment of Locke. Anyone with a mother, daughter, or wife should be horrified by that.

      • Bingo.

        I don’t feel any obligation to give artists or alleged artists as pass as human beings if they’re awful human beings just because they were artists of one sort or another. Fine, they can act or paint or write or whatever, but they’re still assholes and that needs to be noted.

        • That also applies to most Presidents. Jack would know the exceptions, but I would think Reagan, Eisenhower, Lincoln, and Washington might not have been. Also the ones who did nothing we know about, since being an ass helps one accomplish things in that job.


    • Never liked Eastwood, mostly because at 13 I was supposed to meet him on location in Montana during the shooting of one his less popular films, Thunderbolt and Lightfoot, (though the film was set in Idaho), but was snubbed by him. This despite having been driven out to somewhere west of Ulm, Montana to do so.

      So, whatever his politics and other personal foibles, never made it out of the bad guy category for me.

  2. :The excuse given for Donen’s snub was that he died last Tuesday. There was time to add him; of course there was”

    Especially since Finney died a mere two weeks before the Oscars and two weeks has been plenty of an excuse to leave deaths out in previous ceremonies.

    Additionally, they left out Jerry Maren, the sole remaining cast member from 1939’s The Wizard of Oz. He played the Munchkin Representative of the Lollipop Guild. They also left out Scott Wilson who gave a chilling performance in “In Cold Blood”.

    • Ugh. I’ll add them in today too. In the past, the ex-Munchkins have made the list. TWO Little People snubbed?
      You know, TCM has been running its own “In Memoriam”, and adding to it, for months. It included all of the figures snubbed at thne Oscars.

      • I’ve seen some of their previous years’ salutes, but not this year’s yet. Thanks for the reminder! Not only do I find theirs more moving and inclusive, but they seem capable of including everyone in about the same amount of time it takes the Oscars not to do it.

  3. On this we agree, my friend. Especially Ms. Channing who I got to spend some time with when I was assistant to one of DC’s “Ladies Who Lunch” back in the 80s. I don’t know that I’ve ever encountered a more delightful and decent human being — being nice to assistants isn’t usually in the contract and every encounter with her, on the phone or in person, was wonderful. One thing is for sure: when she called, I didn’t have to ask “who’s calling, please?”

  4. Ermey claimed that his career in films essentially ended once he expressed politically conservative views in an interview. Political animus is the only reason I can think of for snubbing him at the Oscars. He was also missed in most of the film web sites that flagged the “In Memoriam” snubs.

    Ermey was not just a conservative, he was a huge gun rights supporter and was featured conspicuously in many videos of firearms YouTube channels. I suspect this is an even bigger reason why he was omitted — his views on firearms were completely at odds with the Hollywood Left, and I have no doubt whatever this snub was both intentional and as pointed as they could make it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.