Comment Of The Day: “More Evidence That Arthur Herzog’s Novel ‘IQ 83’ Is Coming True—Beside The Fact That Bernie Sanders Is Leading The Race For The Democratic Nomination, That Is”

I want to express my admiration and appreciation to the Ethics Alarms comment gang for adding quality content to the blog while I was occupied in involuntary technology wars. The comments were copious and uniformly excellent, with several strong Comment of the Day candidates. In fact, I feel completely superfluous.

Here is Chris Marschner’s Comment of the Day on the post, “More Evidence That Arthur Herzog’s Novel ‘IQ 83’ Is Coming True—Beside The Fact That Bernie Sanders Is Leading The Race For The Democratic Nomination, That Is“:

While the focus is on Michelle Wu, Bloomberg’s past comments regarding the intellectual skill sets of farming and manufacturing are beyond the pale for stupidity. He flat out stated that farming requires only the ability to dig a hole and plant a seed, while manufacturing – using a lathe – one only needs to turn on the machine and make it go the right way.

Sure, he was not running for President at the time he made those comments but for him to suggest that the analytical problem solving skills the information age requires are not present in these occupations is prima facie evidence that he either lacks analytical skills when he made such a deduction, or his cerebral library of information on occupational skill sets has too few volumes of information.

While we are closer to AI than we were when Bloomberg established his financial reporting enterprise that allowed investors to make better investing decisions, most computing still relies on if x do y, if not do something else. If the computer cannot make sense of the data it returns an error code and stops, Fundamentally the computer says, in the immortal words of the robot from Lost in Space ” That Does Not Compute”.

The fact is that IT is about processing and codifying bits of information that other people who are not in the “information industry” create. The IT worker is in many ways merely a librarian for managing the storage of real creative knowledge and the ability to retrieve it quickly. Unless you understand properties of fluidics, mechanics, material sciences you cannot create an engineering computer program that does anything worthwhile. The same is true in most other industries. The creation of knowledge does not come from the IT sector, it comes from people creating stuff that people want and need. Without that, there would be no need for the IT sector.

When I taught Econ to first and second year college students a great deal of relatively basic math was employed. Invariably students would ask if they can use a calculator. My answer to them was I did not care but they should know that the calculator is merely a tool to get the wrong answer faster if they fail to understand the subject matter and rely on the computer to answer the question. I told them if you don’t have an idea of what the answer should look like you will not know if the calculator was correct

4 thoughts on “Comment Of The Day: “More Evidence That Arthur Herzog’s Novel ‘IQ 83’ Is Coming True—Beside The Fact That Bernie Sanders Is Leading The Race For The Democratic Nomination, That Is”

  1. ALL the farmers I ever met, and I’ve met them in every last one of the 72 counties that comprise America’s Dairyland and beyond, could work that arrogantly smug little sawed off POS runt into the dust!

    FTR; seed (as opposed to slips, sets, bulbs, etc.) is planted in SOIL, and unless you have an irrigation system (most fields don’t), you DON’T add water.

  2. Little Mike is an arrogant and ignorant rich man. He has no idea how food gets to his table, and would starve should the supply line from the heartland be cut.

    I am willing to lay money he has never even planted a flower box, much less run a commercial farm or ranch operation.

    Congrats on the COTD!

  3. Thanks Jack

    My comment was not in any way meant to demean anyone in the IT field.

    Like every industry there are different heirarchies of “grey matter” need. My brother before e retired designed software that designed silicon chips for AMD and Intel. Those who design the logic structures are completely different in talent than a help desk specialist. No job is better or worse than any other. End product satisfaction relies on every member within the production chain be continually learning to ensure continued success.

    • > My comment was not in any way meant to demean anyone in the IT field.

      Having worked in both IT and software engineering, no offense taken, though I’d dispute some of the characterizations in your CotD. Overall, I think I get the gist of where you’re coming from. I’ve previously worked in manufacturing (and know some farmers), so I’m not keen on Bloomberg’s past comments either.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.