I’m in the midst of a legal ethics tour of Virginia, moving from one hotel to another. Last night I arrived at a Richmond Hilton at 11 pm, after fighting the usual traffic jams from late night construction on Rt.95 in my two hour car trip to get there. Oh, I had all the usual fun: the room that I had been told was pre-paid by my hosts wasn’t; later, the Wi-Fi in the room didn’t work. First, however, I immediately noticed that room 527 featured a TV that was hanging limply from its pedestal, forward and to the left. I guess I could have watched it sort of comfortably if I sat cross-legged on the floor with my head tilted to one side like President Buchanan.
I decided to call the desk instead.
The chirpy clerk answered my call brightly. “Yes, Mr. Marshall, what can I do for you?” she said.
“Well, my TV is broken. The screen is crooked, and it’s tipping off its pedestal.”
“Oh dear! I’m so sorry about that.”
“Me too. Wouldn’t your housekeeping staff report something like that?”
“They certainly should!”
(Why are you waiting for me to ask what you’re going to do to fix this?)
“Unfortunately, Fred [Note: the maintenance people at hotels are always men, and always named Fred], is getting off soon. Do you need this addressed now?
[There it is. I have been subtly but clearly informed that if I were considerate and a nice guy, I’d say, “Well, never mind. I’ve got my computer, and I’m going to bed pretty soon. I don’t want to trouble you.” Well, the hell with that!]
“I would like a functioning TV in my room, yes.”
“I understand,” she says with a chill. “I think the fastest thing would be to move you to another room, if that would be OK. 528 is open.”
“Fred will be right up.”
It’s not germane to the topic, but the TV in 528 was even in worse shape than the one on 527. Fred was able to fix the one in my original room in about 20 minutes, and he was very nice about it.I didn’t tip him, by the way. I posted on this dilemma earlier, I think. I shouldn’t have to pay more to get a hotel room in the shape it was supposed to be when I walked into it.
I am, however, really tired of this response from establishments, not just hotels but restaurants, retailers and other merchants when you complain about something relatively minor that still shouldn’t be the way it is. I used to fall for it too; I bet most people do. See, the way it is supposed to work is that the hotel clerk says, “I’ll send Fred right up to fix that, sir!”and I say, unprompted, “Oh, that’s not necessary. I guess I’ll be OK.”
Then I get to generous and do my Golden Rule thing without being shamed into it.
The hotel is manipulative and irresponsible to ask me to take less than I bargained for and have every reason to expect, and it is unfair to lay Fred’s inconvenience off on the paying guest. The housekeeping staff should be confronted about why the fact that the room is unrentable seems to escape their notice, which is the real reason Fred had to go home late.
I have yet to point out to a clerk who tries this unethical ploy that I am on to their unethical ploy, and resent it.
You do the same.
10 thoughts on “The “Now I’ll Make You Feel Bad For Insisting On Getting What You Paid For” Ploy”
Tell them you’re onto it. I can’t wait to hear the response.
“with my head tilted to one side like President Buchanan.” I really enjoy the little Vignettes you do on the presidents.As a mental exercise, I took to memorizing all their names.This adds a personal note. BTW In Canada we would actually thank the desk for their time.before telling them to forget about it. .
Ugh. That just encourages them.
I was about to tell you to speak for yourself, but you’re probably right generally…. I think it’s why clerks get this odd deer-in-the-headlights look when I hold them to what’s been agreed. “Oh shit, he didn’t say don’t worry about it. Now what do I do?!?!”
Too bad you could have taken a couple pic and post them on Yelp. Fred and the clerk would have been asked to explain things real soon by somebody higher up in the hotel chain I bet.
with the TV’s in that kind of shape, I would have been more concerned with what might have been munching on me later in the night..
It seems everywhere you go, you encounter people who think they’re doing the world a favor by performing the job they’re paid for. I’m always complaining about this. Another thing I’ve noticed; I always hold the door open for people. Roughly half thank you, and the other half walk through as if it’s beneath their dignity to say “thanks”. Other times, you’ll find yourself standing there holding the door for half an hour while everyone else goes through like a herd of buffalo. Am I really old enough to be saying “kids these days”?
When a herd tries to trample by me when I’m playing “doorman”, I usually pick out a young one, maneuver him next to the door, tell him “take over” and proceed on my way. That usually only happens when I’m visiting a building crowded with expatriate Yankees!
One of my favorite lines, especially at one of the yuppie chain restaurants, is “You ain’t from here, are ya?” delivered in my best born-Texan accent
This is part of why I don’t donate to crowd funding campaigns that fund beginning singers. A la PBS, they promise CDs, DVDs, signed stuff, etc. Maybe you get it, maybe you don’t. If you later ask, sometimes you get told they have been really busy, and if you ask again they ask you if you are still stuck on that, like you are imposing on them by asking them to keep a promise they took money for.