On The Unethical Hegseth Impeachment Drive

[The full resolution can be read here.]

GOP Congressman Thomas Massie, a lame duck and evidently an unrepentant asshole, has been pushing for the impeachment of Secretary of War Pete Hegseth since September. This is from September 15:

The Congressman’s grandstanding is unethical in so many ways that it makes my teeth hurt. He knows that even if the impeachment effort is successful in the House, the chances of conviction are nil, so all he can accomplish at most is a colossal waste of time. In addition, it will only further degrade the Constitution’s safety valve on rogue officials, which the Democrats pretty much destroyed already by redefining impeachment as a partisan weapon rather than a bi-partisan, last resort means of removing an objectively corrupt or dangerously irresponsible government leader. Treating “following the policies of the elected President” as a high crime or misdemeanor is a dangerous precedent to pursue, and especially so now, when the Democratic Party has signaled that it finds the Constitution and democracy annoying impediments to its plans for permanent domination. But never mind: Massey really, really, really doesn’t like the Iran war, and as a mere representative, he doesn’t have the authority to stop it. His solution to this problem is throwing a tantrum and filing indefensible articles of impeachment.

As one pundit put it, “Donald Trump is Commander in Chief. Pete Hegseth didn’t sneak into the Pentagon one night, find the big red WAR button and start bombing Iran while Trump was asleep. He’s Trump’s Secretary of Defense, carrying out the military policy of the administration.” I have heard more than one progressive parrot use the Nuremberg excuse to justify punishing Hegseth for Trump’s policies. Since the very first war crimes trial (in the U.S., over the Andersonville prison), the dirty little not-so-secret has been that empowering subordinates to disobey the orders of their superiors based on judgments they are not empowered or qualified to make is a recipe for chaos and disaster.(cont.)

Friday Open Forum (Fighting Despair Edition)

Last night I couldn’t sleep and decided to scroll down my Facebook feed much farther than usual. I was horrified. Facebook’s algorithm has pigeonholed me in several ways that distort the breadth of my interests and skills, so I am being bombarded by posts from people and groups I don’t even know with dumb memes, stupid questions, and worst of all, idiotic opinions about American history, baseball, movies, show music, Gilbert and Sullivan, dogs, TV and trivia, periodically interrupted by mind-blowingly idiotic political posts by Facebook friends that without exception tempt me to downgrade my once positive evaluations of their intelligence and character.

It isn’t only that their posts are almost all leftist gloating and anti-Trump rants, it’s that virtually none of them contain legitimate, coherent, thought-provoking arguments backed by facts. Most are unequivocal lies, misrepresentations, delusions and statements that should embarrass a 15 year old. Here’s one I noticed this morning, endorsed by an actor friend:

Right. ICE and “Medicare for All” were literally on the ballot. One Harvard poll in July found that 75% of those polled support deporting criminal illegal aliens and 55% favor deporting all illegal immigrants. Over 95% oppose Biden-style open borders.

The most depressing revelation is the truly dumb stuff being posted by former EA columnist “Curmie.” It’s like watching a cherished relative’s mind deteriorate with progressive dementia. The man I trusted with absolute freedom to publish essays on Ethics Alarms, whom I had been exchanging opinions and ideas with for more than a decade, a teacher, a scholar and a thoughtful professional, routinely posts on Facebook garbage like that thing above, which is far from the worst I’ve seen, just the latest. Watching freinds like Curmie behave like this feels like the Black Plague spreading across Europe, except that the dead are logic, common sense, truth, the ability to perceive reality—I view an obsession with Epstein as signature significance for clinical Trump Derangement—and America’s prospects for surviving in any form the Founders would recognize.

Well, I just depressed myself again. Take over and cheer me up.

How The News Media Makes It Impossible To Be Ethical: The TOTUS Debacle [Corrected]

The biased and dishonest news reporting on the incident yesterday at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier has disgusted me more than any of the disgusting unethical incidents I have had to watch, and sometimes comment on, this past week. I wrote about the news media’s lie, deceptive spin and fake news earlier today. For the record, I resent having to devote so much analysis and energy to political matters, but I don’t see a way out as long as the relentless assualt on our institutions and democratic processes by the blood-lust crazed Left continues to escalate while the Great Stupid crawls across the land like that green death in “The Ten Commandments.

There was a new development in the Get Hegseth! story: “Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth awarded a medal on Thursday to the service member who reprimanded his group for making noise at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier on Veterans Day,” CBS News sort-of accurately reported.

Photos showing Hegseth pinning a medal to Spc. Thomas Iglesias’ chest were posted by the Secretary to social media with the comment, “We love soldiers. We love standards. Well done, Specialist. Carry on Patriots.”

But the dishonest narrative continues. Here is NBC News’ despicable lie in its headline for the same story: “Hegseth awards medal to soldier who reprimanded him at Arlington National Cemetery: The soldier admonished the defense secretary, his wife and top aides for laughing and taking photos at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier on Veterans Day.

Hegseth was not laughing and taking photos. A flat out lie.

In a normal, ethical, fair environment, Hegseth’s decorating the solder for doing his duty without regard for “The King’s Pass” or perhaps more accurately, the “King’s Rude and Clueless Female Companions’ Pass” would be accepted as appropriate, proper and ethical. But, of course, thanks to the near universal smear he received by the news media as they falsely framed the incident, his actions can also be dismissed as an obvious way to avoid accountability for the disrespect he showed at the Tomb, as falsely reported. They will be dismissed that way. He can do no right. He. like the President, is presumptively corrupt, vile and incapable of virtuous action.

Instapundit has a frequently employed mantra referring to journalists: “No matter how much you hate these people, it isn’t enough.” It is spot on, and this episode amply demonstrates why.

Here is my mantra:

“Take note, you conservatives and Republicans who let the “Blue Wave” swamp the nation, for these are the execrable people you allowed to get power over your lives because you wanted to throw a tantrum about inflation.“

“Nah, There’s No Mainstream Media Bias!” Amid Massey’s Impeachment Tantrum, The Axis Slimes Pete Hegseth [Updated]

Here I was, up early to finally cover Rep. Massey’s unethical slap at President Trump using Secretary of War Pete Hegseth as his voodoo doll, and what do I see but these headlines on Google News:

Soldier Shouts Toward Hegseth to Show ‘Respect’ at Tomb of the Unknown Soldier (NYT)

Hegseth and his entourage scolded by military sentinel at Tomb of the Unknowns (WAPO)

Hegseth and advisers reprimanded by guard at Tomb of the Unknown Soldier (CNN)

…and many like it.

“What an idiot!” I think. Hegseth (I am not a fan) is going to be under fire for as long as he is running the department by the Democrat majority in Congress and their ‘flying monkeys” in the news media (that’s PJ Media’s Stephen Kruiser’s name for what EA calls the Axis media, and I find it amusing and fair), and he’s so insensitive and politically dim that he would alienate veterans by being disrespectful at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier?

But he wasn’t. Not a single story suggested that Hegseth misbehaved at the Tomb. One of the women accompanying him, either his wife, Jennifer Hegseth, or advisor Tami Radabaugh (or both) were heard “audibly laughing” as the daily ceremony at the Tomb at Arlington National Cemetery was about to get underway. As a result (I’ve seen this occur when I have been observing the ritual), “All visitors will maintain an atmosphere of silence and respect at all times,” the sentinel shouted at the group. The rules for all ceremonies at the cemetery prohibit visitors from yelling or making any other “boisterous” or “unreasonably loud” noise.

Was Hegseth disrespectful at the Tomb? No. Can he control the inappropriate outbursts of adults accompanying him, who should be presumed to know how to behave at this sacred site? No. Would the sentinel reminding a visitor of the proper decorum at the Tomb be newsworthy if it weren’t an opportunity to impugn and denigrate a Trump Administration figure targeted by progressives, Democrats and the news media? Definitely not. (cont.)

From The Res Ipsa Loquitur Files, As The Great Stupid Shows No Mercy As It Ravages The Land

This is what your friends and relatives who voted for Democrats want unleashed on society, or at least don’t care if it is. Because their scrapple costs too much.

Commentary from “Plan Nine From Outer Space”:

In Which I Lose Respect For Yet Another Brainwashed Facebook Friend…

This hurt. The long-time friend who posted the following commentary on the announcement above is someone I have long regarded as intelligent, reasonable, fair, perceptive and responsible. He is also deeply religious, and generally civically literate. Yet he posted the above announcement of this event, which I hadn’t hear of before, with the following commentary:

It seems we’re being given some warning. How do these people stay so enraged, for so long, based on such poor information? It exhausts me just reading about it…A million? The 5th anniversary of the January 6 Insurrection garnered only a few hundred participants. Success for this effort may depend on whom and from where the call to action is amplified. Let’s hope the President and White House are not inclined to acknowledge it. Ugh.

“Ugh” is right. How do “these people” stay so enraged? The online social media mob my friend is pandering to are the rage addicts; they have been enraged at MAGA and Donald Trump since he upset Hillary Clinton’s dream of being the first female President and Obama’s anointed successor! And ” based on such poor information”? “Based on such poor information”!!!!! What does he think was good information? That Joe Biden was “sharp as a tack?” That the Wuhan virus was so deadly that we had to shut down the nation, wreck the economy and tamer with election security just in time to elect Joe Biden? That the Republican party was the existential threat to democracy? That the inflation Trump inherited from the Biden administration was all Trump’s fault? That “the border is secure”?

Meanwhile, anyone referring to January 6, 2025 as an “insurrection” is either an idiot, a lair, hack, or believes everything MSNow says. Even Jack Smith, the Biden Justice Department didn’t try to claim it was an “insurrection,” and it was looking into every nook and cranny to come up with ways to lock those unruly conservatives.

This is like a production of “Rhinoceros,” Eugene Ionesco’s political allegory about a small French town where the residents start turning into horned beasts. Not you, my friend! Not you too!

How Can We Feel Positively About Veterans In A Culture That Increasingly Treats Them As Fools and Criminals?

This is the weirdest Veterans Day since the Vietnam era, and maybe ever. A major political party has just taken over Congress while decrying the use of military personnel for security and the national interest. Indeed, strong constituencies on both sides of the political divide are embracing the well-disproved notion that wars must never be fought at all.

A similar mindset immeasurably aided the rise of Hitler after the horrors of The Great War. It led the U.S. into abandoning South Vietnam before the mission was accomplished, and failing to complete the objectives in both Iraq wars and Afghanistan. That irrational and ahistorical position threatens to let Iran continue as the regional terrorism machine it has been for decades and the existential threat it aspires to be against Israel and the United States. It is why the nation foolishly no longer requires a period of military service for its citizens, and why recruitment has become increasingly difficult for our Armed Serviced.

The day before this Veterans Day, a lame duck Republican Congressman who has opposed the elected President of the United States from the beginning filed a contrived impeachment resolution against the Secretary of War for following the chain of command and doing his job. (More on this unethical debacle later today, I hope.) It appears that Democrats, progressives and the Trump Deranged will greet veterans today with, “Thank you for your service, you foolish tools of war criminals!”

Nice. I know I’m being repetitious, but these are the people most voters endorsed last week because hamburger is too expensive. (cont.)

From The Res Ipsa Loquitor Files…

Christina Lorey is an independent, Madison Wisconsin-based journalist, “positive news” creator, and former local television reporter, anchor, and producer.

And also, apparently, a moron.

Comment of the Day: “Scary Trump-Deranged/Wokified Facebook Friend Update”

I want to apologize to Gamereg, who authored this terse and astute Comment of the Day for getting it posted so tardily. Fortunately, the foolish (but disturbingly typical) sentiments he was generous enough to thoroughly rebut remain evergreen and ever destructive even though the election has come and gone.

Before I turn it over to Gamereg, I want to express particular disgust at the first line. There is nothing racist about the Republican Party, its elected officials or Donald Trump, and yet this claim—not even claim now but official Big Lie—remains a staple of progressive, Democrat, Trump Deranged cant despite my efforts and those of many others to demonstrate beyond dispute that it is untrue. When I confront the “Trump is a racist” chanters and insist that they tell me what they think is their smoking gun, their answers range from “Oh, everybody knows he’s a racist” to “He said mean things about Barack Obama/Kamala Harris/ Colin Kaepernick/”The Squad” to “He called the white supremacy protesters in Charlottesville “very fine people “to “he called nations with ‘people of color’ ‘shit-hole countries'” to “huminiahuminahumina.” The most substantive response anyone has come up with is the October 1973 DOJ civil rights lawsuit against Trump, his father Fred Trump, and their real estate company, Trump Management Inc., alleging systemic violations of the Fair Housing Act of 1968 in New York City. The Trumps settled the lawsuit in 1975 by signing a consent decree without admitting any wrongdoing or liability. The Justice Department’s evidence was strong; undeniably, the Trumps engaged in racial discrimination. Also undeniably, the episode is fifty years old. Fifty years ago Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama opposed gay marriage. I stipulate that when a public figure’s last racially discriminatory act was a half century ago, the “racist” label cannot be sustained.

I also want to respectfully challenge Extradimensional Cephalopod, our esteemed missionary of effective and civil discourse with immovable ideologues who have adopted an unshakable belief and are inclined to disrespect anyone who attempts to dislodge it regardless of the evidence offered. I would like to read a non-fantasy formula for convincing a progressive shill that the first first line is the utter bias and counter-factual smear that it is.

He/She/It has been especially smug of late with the now familiar “Oh, you poor dim Earthlings, if only you could learn the skills I bring you, the talking past each other that has resulted in such bitterness and enmity in our political disputes would be no more!” I am reacting particularly to our recent debate on this thread, which contained a reference to my post seeking the most ethical way to treat a neighbor who tells me she cuts off anyone who doesn’t sufficiently oppose Donald Trump and support the Democratic Party.

Update: I invited her to dine out with me for Thanksgiving, since my family is dead or will be elsewhere, and she is estranged from hers. She was thrilled. We will not talk politics.

Here is Gamereg’s Comment of the Day on the post, “Scary Trump-Deranged/Wokified Facebook Friend Update”…

***

Disgusting (But Not Atypical) Leftist Hate-Mongers Issue A Rare Level #11 Apology (“The Impossible Apology”)

Not accepted.

Progressive podcasters Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan laughed uproariously at an joke about digging up the body of assassinated conservative activist Charlie Kirk in order to kill him again.

The vile hosts of the “I’ve Had It” podcast read an X post stating, “We’re digging up Charlie Kirk and doing it again” on the air following Democrats winning majorities in the House and Senate in the midterm elections. They thought it was so hilarious—and assumed their sick listeners would as well—that they engaged in unrestrained hilarity at the idea of desecrating the body of a murder victim whose sole “crime” was opposing radical leftist cant. They chose—poorly. So far five sponsors of the podcast have pulled their advertising, with Cash App., which had one of their ads read right before Welch and Sullivan’s self-reveal as hateful ghouls stating curtly: