In Honor Of Our New Dog Spuds, A Timely Ethics Alarms Encore: “Unethical Website of the Month: Dogsbite.Org”

That’s not Spuds above; that’s Brad Pitt’s wonderful Staffordshire Terrier in “Once Upon A Time In Hollywood,”, one of many breeds dog ignoramuses lump into the category of “pit bull.” Spuds, whom we brought home today, is almost certainly at least part American Pit Bull Terrier, like the dog in the “Our Gang” comedies, but we’ll know better when he gains back more of the weigh he lost when his owner stopped feeding him. Here he is in our kitchen tonight..

Since he is among the  types of dog who will be subjected to the breed bigotry that has led to the deaths of so many smart, loyal, affectionate and harmless dogs across America and Europe, I’ve decided to re-post this essay from 2015. It is the all-time champion Ethics Alarms post for comments, with 339 and counting. It is also the post that has continued to attract comments the longest after a post went up: the last flurry of reactions from anti-pit bull hysterics was in February of this year.


Unethical Website of the Month: Dogsbite.Org

This despicable website, created by phobics, liars, fools and bigots to promote dog breed prejudice and persecution of responsible dog owners, is discredited by the vast, vast  majority of dog experts, breeders, and people with any knowledge of dogs. It is useful in a way, in that its rhetoric mirrors that of the anti-Jewish, final solution advocates of the Nazi regime, and the most virulent American racists, like the KKK. (A dog breed is exactly like a human race.) It also apes the logical fallacies of those who want to ban guns or engage in racial profiling.

Although a mass of data and history proves that pit bull-related breeds are no more inherently dangerous than any powerful breed and arguably less, Dogsbite.Org is leading a vendetta against both the breeds and lawful, loving owners, reasoning that dogfighting uses pit bull-type breeds, and pit bulls used for fighting are more likely to be dangerous (as any dog so abused  may be), so to kill two birds with one stone, it makes sense to wipe out not just any individual dangerous dog of the type but any dog that is a hybrid of the a “pit bull breed” and any dog that looks like what people think is a “pit bull”, in part because there is no such breed as “pit bull.”

Thus because some “pit bulls” are abused, all should be exterminated.This is essentially the argument of the unethical people at PETA, which announced that it is supporting DogsBite.Org with the batty, but no more so than many of  their positions, argument that we need to destroy the dogs in order to save them. 

Pretending that there is some dog-monster known as a The Pit Bull  is just one of the lies (or examples of reckless ignorance)  perpetrated by hysteric    and her deadly band of anti-dogowner fanatics on their website. Denver’s infamous pit bull ban, like Lynn, defines the “breed” as “an American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier, or any dog displaying the majority of physical traits of any one of those breeds.” This rigged methodology renders the statistics repeatedly cited by anti-pit bull bigots obvious nonsense. When one compares one distinct breed to many or more by falsely representing them as one breed, then it’s not hard to show that the fake breed is disproportionately aggressive. Says the site: “If it looks like a pitbull, then it is one.” It is because of this kind of “thinking” that my American Bull Dog-owning friend is forced to buy exorbitant insurance,  move, or have his family’s gentle companion killed.

Except that his dog is not a member of any of the breeds fairly belonging into the category called “pit bulls,” which are all terrier mixes.  There is no terrier in a bull dog.  Never mind, though: this is about hysteria, fear-mongering,  legislators who care more about votes than they do about fairness or dogs, official ignorance, and cowardice. This is another of DogsBite’s abundant lies: it claims that most people can identify a pit bull accurately. Even most dog owners are lousy at identifying breeds, and phobics, as well as people who have no experience with dogs, often can’t identify any breeds beyond beagles, Lassie, German Shepherds and maybe chihuahuas.

More people asked me if my English Mastiff was a pit bull than ever identified her correctly. I’ve owned Jack Russell Terriers for 25 years, and more people have asked me if they were pit bulls (actually, they are a lot closer to pit bulls than a mastiff is, or an American bulldog) over that time than identified their ( wonderful, merry, loving and frighteningly smart) breed correctly. The tendency of journalists and police to mistakenly attribute attacks to pit bulls is well-documented, but the website just denies it. It also falsely claims that the American Kennel Club has tried to confuse the public by re-naming breeds in order to disguise what really are pit bulls. The AKC breeds lumped into the imaginary pit bull category all predate pit bull hysteria. When I was growing up, everyone was terrified of Doberman Pinschers (another loyal, intelligent, loving breed.)

The misguided, unfeeling, reveling in ignorance fools who man this website share responsibility for the pain and misery that thousands of families have had to experience when their loving pets and companions have been taken from them by a local government and gassed simply because killing them is part of the warped pit bull “final solution.” Dogsbite.Org deals in bad statistics, debunked fallacies and anti-dog propaganda that has turned into cruel legislation in communities all over the country. Their tactics succeed because craven political hacks would rather kill harmless pets than risk losing the votes of PETA members, dog breed ignoramuses and bigots.

I’ve written a lot on this topic. This isn’t even a close call on the facts. Most of all, you should view the heart-breaking documentary, Beyond the Myth.

If  friends start repeating the DogsBite lies, introduce them to an American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire TerrierStaffordshire Bull Terrier, or any mixture thereof. I can take my Jack Russell to a dog park in Arlington, Virginia, where, on any nice day, between 10 and 30 of these terrific, playful, obedient dogs will be romping happily and harmlessly among other breeds, large and small, and young children. The key fact is that none of the owners are dogfighters, drug dealers or Michael Vick.

UPDATE: In the future,  comments to this post that consist of nothing but repeating the same, disproven myths and ignorant beliefs about the various pit bull breeds will not get through moderation. Any serious, well-researched, civil comments presenting counter arguments and genuine statistics to the facts and expert opinion discussed in these posts are welcome. Citing as authority will guarantee rejection. Lumping multiple breeds together as “pit bulls” proves laziness, bias and ignorance, and will also result in the comment being spammed. Dumb arguments like “You can’t prove they aren’t pit bulls!” will have the same results.

It is depressing how many people will hold on to a factually unsupportable bias despite every effort to enlighten them, but then prejudice against humans works the same way.

11 thoughts on “In Honor Of Our New Dog Spuds, A Timely Ethics Alarms Encore: “Unethical Website of the Month: Dogsbite.Org”

  1. We rescued a Doberman who later clipped my kid in the head. We were playing kind of rough, and the whites of the dog’s eyes were showing as he watched my son. I didn’t understand until it was too late that the dog thought he was defending me.
    We later rescued a big terrier/dalmation mix. Patient, kind soul. A lady was walking her dog off leash while my leashed pet was walking with my (now adult) son. The small dog ran right up to them, and it was all over in 10 seconds. My dog sat right down and wagged his tail, and probably forgot about it in half a minute.
    Dogs are instinctual, and some are very quick to act/react to natural prey/threats. But vicious? These dogs were both pussycats.
    If we have them, it’s our jobs to keep everything working.
    As long as the owners are responsible, all good.
    I’d hate to see the same illogic that wants to demonize certain breeds applied to certain narrow demographics in our society based on some outliers. OTOH, one can’t ignore the anecdotes altogether.

  2. Congrats on the new member of the family! I do hope you train him well and enjoy many years of sane and fun bonding.

    Speaking as a dog trainer, I find the breed of a dog can indeed give me background information that can explain particular tendencies. For example today I worked with a 5 year old recently neutered American Bulldog. Going into our first session knowing about the breed helped me identify where he may focus. This info came in handy when he attempted to nip at someone thanks to another neurotic little dog triggering him. A bulldog poorly trained can become a gripper of flesh and to pretend otherwise isn’t respecting the dog.

    A well trained dog of any breed is a joy. A poorly trained dog of any breed can release some of their breed natural instincts in a harmful way.

    For example a poorly trained Hound may obsessively search for things or dig up a yard. A Chihuahua may become possessive. A Pomeranian too frantic. A Sheppard may try to herd humans. A Bulldog may go from nip to grip. This doesn’t mean this is what will happen but we must respect the breed for what possibilities, good and bad, may lie ahead with a dog who isn’t given appropriate attention and boundaries.

    Websites that show prejudice against any breed or look of a supposed breed, serve to instill unnecessary fear. In my experience, it’s not the breed but the owner and those around the dog that is an issue. My saying is, “If your dog is crazy, it’s probably because you are.” All of my clients with dogs who have moderate to severe behavioural issues, must accept
    and understand this and work to change it, or I won’t work with them.

    The problem is the owners who think things like nipping is “cute” or excessive: indoor peeing, body licking, digging, barking, food motivation, etc. as “not so bad” until they’re reacting with anger…which never works to mitigate what the humans allowed.

    In other words, no matter the breed, train your damn dog and respect that any dog can be a danger if given no rules or mindful discipline.

    • Wise words. Our only bad experience among our dogs was a re-homed young Bassett Hound who was uncontrollable around food of any kind, and also had a rare issue for the breed in which he would go into a weird fugue state and attack when he was frightened or confronted. After one of these episodes, he acted ashamed and upset; it was pitiful. Terriers I get. Hounds are too country for me, at least in suburbia.

  3. Congrats Jack! Wishing you many happy years with Spud.

    I just put down my dog of 15 years and I’ve a hankering for another dog. * sigh *

    My kids’ wired haired pointer bit my (then) 7 mos old grandson in the face, just a couple of months ago. A vascular surgeon, two plastic surgeons, the head of pharmacology, two nurses and a respiratory therapist later and he will be fine. Scarred – which should fade over the years – but fine. To my kids’ credit, they did not blame the dog. The dog had given every warning sign in the book that he was not fond of a crawling baby in his space. They looked away for a moment. Devastated, they did re-home the dog; with a young, single woman who fell in love with the dog instantly. I have no doubt that had the incident happened in a less understanding family, it would have been the demise of the dog. And often it is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.